
How NOT to win a Formula One race: McLaren Edition
Max Verstappen’s victory at the 2025 Japanese Grand Prix from pole position stands as one of the most impressive weekends of his career.
In a machine that is no better than third fastest behind the runaway McLaren and the consistent Mercedes, the Dutchman’s superlative win has received mixed reactions.
Praise has rightfully come his way for stringing together arguably the best qualifying lap in recent Formula One history, but his triumph on Sunday has received fewer plaudits.
Behind the Red Bull driver on the grid sat the two early championship favourites driving for the Woking operation, Lando Norris and Oscar Piastri.
Both papaya contenders made mistakes on Saturday, handing an unexpected pole position to Verstappen and creating a challenging task to overtake him for the victory.
In a race dominated by tyre strategy and managing the gap to cars in front to avoid turbulent air from other drivers, it seemed McLaren showed no desire to win.
Their decision to bring Piastri into the pits before the leaders while sitting in the third position left me baffled, as the undercut is often weak at Suzuka.
The Australian returned to the track on cold tyres in light traffic behind the Haas of Oliver Bearman and lost ground to Verstappen and Norris.
Despite it being obvious that tyre degradation was minimal and that the new hard compound rubber struggled with warmup, McLaren then made another blunder.
They opted to bring Norris in on the same lap as the leading Red Bull, expecting their driver to do all the work on track despite the difficulty faced with overtaking.
Had they bided their time and allowed the Brit to perform an ‘overcut’, the current championship leader would have pulled out a sizeable gap before minimising the time spent on the hards.
We saw with Mercedes’ rookie Andrea Kimi Antonelli that this was undoubtedly the optimal strategy due to the slow degradation of the medium tyre.
Even if the papaya squad didn’t know that such a peculiar situation would arise on the second stint, pitting Norris at the same time as Verstappen was a stupid idea.
The Brit’s blunder on the pitlane exit, expecting to be given room when he wasn’t in front nor in the fast lane, compounded McLaren’s poor decision-making.
In the last stint, it was obvious that Piastri was marginally quicker than his teammate, yet the pit wall decided against swapping the two cars.
I agree with this decision, as the Woking duo are in a title battle that should not be interfered with, and it was unlikely either could overtake the leader.
Norris never got anywhere near making a move, and Piastri was only marginally quicker than him, meaning it would’ve most likely been another case of following first place to the finish.
Strategic blunders aside, the Brit still leads the driver’s standings, albeit only one point clear of Verstappen, while the Australian is lagging behind.
Rookies shine while a veteran falters
Removed from the lead battle, several drivers showed weak or strong performances relative to their machinery, from legends struggling to rookies rocketing to great results.
The start of Lewis Hamilton’s Ferrari career has been underwhelming, as his finishes have been lacklustre, aside from a win in the Chinese Sprint.
He was a lowly tenth place in the season opener in Melbourne, then after his mini-victory, was disqualified from the main race in Shanghai.
This weekend in Suzuka, while his teammate took fourth on the road, Hamilton could only muster seventh with an uninspiring drive on the alternate strategy.
Maranello’s star signing sits eighth in the drivers’ championship behind his teammate Charles Leclerc and far adrift of Antonelli and George Russell at his former employers, Mercedes.
If Hamilton wishes to achieve his record-breaking title tally with the Scuderia, surpassing Michael Schumacher, he needs to put his foot down and start performing.
His teammate has a small fraction of his accolades yet has a comfortable advantage over him; this is not the mark of someone who many claim is the greatest of all time.
His results so far in the first three races of the year have been average at best, which is not worth the large sum of money paid to hire him.
While the seven-time champion continues struggling to adapt to his new environment, two of the rookies, Antonelli and Bearman put on great performances.
The 18-year-old Antonelli qualified well and ran long on his first stint, giving him better tyres at the end, with which he set the fastest lap.
He became the youngest driver to do so in Formula One history, while his close friend Bearman achieved the Haas team’s first Q3 appearance of the season.
A composed drive to tenth place followed, finishing half a minute clear of his more experienced teammate Esteban Ocon, who failed to impress.
Racing Bulls youngster Isack Hadjar was another driver who impressed, qualifying in seventh place and scoring eighth on race day.
He showed resilience on Saturday when his seatbelts began causing him extreme pain due to being too tight, however, he pushed through to claim the best starting position of his short career so far.
The Frenchman has quietly recovered his form since his debut in Melbourne, where he crashed out on the formation lap, regaining his confidence with a good drive.
With both Yuki Tsunoda and Liam Lawson struggling to show their talent in the cursed Red Bull second seat, Hadjar could be promoted to the main team next season.
Doohan's crashing calamities could give rise to Colapinto
The other rookies, Jack Doohan and Gabriel Bortoleto, had markedly less success, with the former totalling his car in free practice.
Doohan tried to drive Turn One with the DRS (Drag Reduction System) activated, which sent him spinning into the barriers as he lost the rear end.
It’s believed that he had tried this previously in the team’s simulator, and it worked; however, the results were less fruitful in real life.
He trundled to an anonymous finish during the race, leaving many to question how long he will stay in F1 full-time while the Argentine starlet Franco Colapinto waits on the sidelines.
In my opinion, Doohan has proved since his lacklustre debut in last year’s Abu Dhabi Grand Prix that he is simply not good enough to race in the sport.
He has shown no moments of brilliance, is error-prone, often finishes far behind his teammate Pierre Gasly and costs Alpine lots of money in crash damage.
Thus, Colapinto should be drafted in as he showed glimpses of potential, at times performing better than Alexander Albon in his team's other car.
A boring race still has storylines
This race was one of the dullest in recent memory, but there are still many conclusions to draw from an event that captured no one’s attention.
Pirelli brought tyres that were a step too hard with not enough degradation, while Red Bull still hasn’t found a fix for their second driver curse.
McLaren has a serious problem brewing, as it’s clear Norris isn’t champion material, while Piastri isn’t a much better option long term.
Hamilton, the second-most experienced driver on the grid, is struggling, while rookies with a tiny fraction of his experience are putting in better performances.
Doohan is the odd one out in that category, as he proves that middling junior series results and being loyal don’t make you a good F1 driver.
Nonetheless, this was a race that, despite sending most to sleep watching it, has provided several talking points and created many storylines.
My driver ratings for the 2025 Japanese Grand Prix weekend:
- Max Verstappen: 9.5/10
- George Russell: 8.5/10
- Andrea Kimi Antonelli: 8/10
- Isack Hadjar: 8/10
- Oliver Bearman: 8/10
- Charles Leclerc: 7.5/10
- Oscar Piastri: 7/10
- Alexander Albon: 7/10
- Lando Norris: 6.5/10
- Pierre Gasly: 6/10
- Lewis Hamilton: 6/10
- Fernando Alonso: 5.5/10
- Liam Lawson: 5/10
- Nico Hulkenberg: 5/10
- Carlos Sainz: 4.5/10
- Esteban Ocon: 4.5/10
- Gabriel Bortoleto: 4.5/10
- Lance Stroll: 4/10
- Yuki Tsunoda: 3.5/10
- Jack Doohan: 2.5/10

