Watergate: In Support of Eakins

Watergate

That’s what they are calling it, the moment Eakins and Hall almost threw down on the Oilers bench…over a splash of water. In a moment of frustration Taylor Hall, well-known emotional player, smashed a water bottle on the bench and upon doing so, water splashed Head Coach Dallas Eakins, ex-NHL grinder/fighter, at which point it is on!

That’s the scene. What happens next is the embarrassing part. Eakins absolutely lost his mind over his suit getting wet. He attacked Hall with a verbal barrage that was caught on National Television. Hall being Hall didn’t back down. He shouted right back. Clearly both guys were at a boiling point and this was the pin that popped the balloon.  It is embarrassing anytime grown men are caught on camera fighting over spilt milk (water) they look like fools. But in this case, at this point, with this team, maybe it was the necessary reaction.

There are two ways to look at this incident:

1) These are two emotional guys, losing yet another hockey game to their hated rivals from Calgary. The game was out of reach before it was even half over. Hall showed his frustration, and when Eakins got hit with water he released his frustration right back. If you look the video Eakins takes a look in Halls direction, realizes it was Hall, then pounces. He decides in that moment that Hall, a leader on this team, needs to channel those emotions in more productive ways. Slamming the water bottle is an act of frustration sure, it’s also a crybaby move. Why not turn to Eakins and say something like “put me out there, I need to do something to turn this game around” Then go out there and have one hell of a shift. Hit someone, score a goal, fight someone or take a roughing penalty. Do something productive with your frustration, instead of slamming a water bottle on the bench. That is the message Eakins was sending, knowing it was Taylor Hall, a leader on this team, it made sense to send that message at that time. Hall can handle it and Eakins knows that by now. He used the frustration both he and Hall felt to vent and show some emotion. Sure it didn’t help at all, but maybe it helps next time.

2) The second way to look at it is to blame Eakins for showing emotion about something that had nothing to do with being run over by the Flames on home ice. Eakins gets made cause he gets a little water on his fancy suit. Eakins, according to many, has shown no emotion until that very moment all season long. He has lost the team, lost the bench and now lost his mind. It is time to get rid of Eakins.

Well unfortunately for people taking second verbal, that’s a very negative way to view this supposed scandal. Try and put yourself in the shoes of coach and player at that exact moment. Hall smashes a water bottle on the bench. That was his push back. He didn’t send the Flames a message; he sent the bench a message that he was giving up. The game was out of reach and he didn’t want to do anything about it, so he smashed the bottle. Eakins notices this, notices it’s a team leader, and lashes out. Rightfully so. This team has been playing spoiled hockey all season long. They are not dedicating themselves 100% to the system that Eakins is trying to employ. The pushback is coming against Eakins as much as against other teams. That is unacceptable.

Sooner or later the players on this team need to get the message that the Coach is not always going to be the one to blame. Firing another Head coach sends the wrong message. The coaching carousel has been hard and fast the past couple of seasons. The young core of this team has remained unchanged. The players don’t believe they have to do anything to change; all they have to do is wait for the next coach and hope he lets them run costless. Well that’s a formula for continued failure. Mact needs to stand by his guns, hire a experienced NHL associate coach (Eakins gets no say in this) and trades one of the core. Why would anyone trade one of the young core players? Well this team has run coaches out of this town year after year, so why not try something different. Why not change the formula the coaches are working with and see that happens.

The Oilers can choose to fire yet another Head Coach and bring this same mix back next season with some more unproven young players to fill out the roster. Or the Oilers can try something different. A team will trade for Eberle or Yakupov or the first round draft pick. It is a risky move, but what is the harm? Maybe it backfires and the Oilers finish last in the West next season.

Then again they’re last in the West this year.