
Bob Stauffer, who works for the Oilers as the host of Oilers Now Radio in Edmonton, just tweeted out something interesting as he heads to the NHL Scouting combine.
“Heading to Toronto for the NHL Scouting Combine. Here is MY top 5 at this time. #1 Ekblad #2 Reinhart #3 Draisaitl #4 Bennett #5 Dal Colle.”
As an employee of the Oilers Stauffer definitely has connections within the organization, which is why this tweet is so interesting. It feels a little bit like stage setting for the selection of Draisaitl in the upcoming draft.
The most interesting part of his tweet was that he has Bennett fourth, which is a far cry from almost all of the Scouting lists that have been released. Bennett sits 1st or 2nd on almost every list so for Stauffer to have him at 4 may be telling as to what the Oilers are thinking heading into this draft.
This is likely a hint that the Oilers are leaning towards the big German born Leon Draisaitl. This is not a surprising revelation, considering his size, position and ranking in the scouting reports. The top end of this draft is a mixture of players that have failed to separate from one another and really stand out as the number one player. This year there is no Nathan MacKinnon at the top who is a no-brainer pick (and even he was debated as the top pick last year…)
Because the top of the draft is inseparable, the intangibles become that much more important. Size, attitude, and the upcoming interviews will all play a part in what order the top 5 go in this draft. But what if the Oilers are forced to choose between Ekblad and Draisaitl at #3? Do they choose the big defenseman with a wide range of skills or the big bodied centre man who put up points at the same rate as Sam Reinhart in the WHL this season?
Most people looking at the Oilers would say take the defenseman, the Oilers are weak on defense and they have been for years. Why would they add another young forward to the mix? The thing is, the transition from Major Junior to the NHL is a very hard one to make, but it’s even more difficult for defenseman. The opposing forwards are bigger, stronger, and smarter and are incredible at exploiting every single mistake made on the ice. The margin for error is miniscule. All young players make mistakes that the other team capitalizes on, but for defenseman these mistakes stand out and have a more visual connection on goals scored.Because their mistakes quite often lead directly to a goal, as they either happen in the defensive zone, or in the neutral zone which results in odd-man rushes for the opposition. The seperation of the mistake and the goal are far less removed with defenseman. Forwards can give the puck away deep in the offensive zone, which triggers a sequence that leads to a goal. But the turnover happened so far away from the end result that the mistake is less glaring.
On top of this, the Oilers boast a decent prospect pool on defence. Klefbom, Nurse, Marincin, Gernat, Simpson are all decent prospects with a good amount of upside. With Marincin making his mark this past season, Klefbom soon to make his own, and Nurse about two years away, the temptation for a potential number one defenseman from the draft to add to that group will be high. The problem is that most scouts are unsure if Ekblad will be that Drew Doughty, or Alex Pietrangelo. He could be more along the lines of an Erik Johnson…in that he projects well in junior but may be right at the cusp of his ceiling as a player. In other words what you see is what you get. That doesn’t sound like a top 3 pick, especially when the need is for a better second line to compliment and offer offensive support to the top line in Edmonton.
The second line is a mess, and adding a capable centre man gives the Oilers the option of moving Yakupov down the depth chart to help build his confidence while sliding Sam Gagner to the wing on line 2. This is not an ideal circumstance of course, but Gagner is not able to handle the responsibility which comes alongside being a top 6 centre in the NHL. However he still has some offensive upside, and sliding him to the wing decreases his defensive responsibility somewhat, which will allow him to focus more of his effort on putting up points. This could be a very beneficial move for Edmonton and Gagner, especially if the two sides are ready to part ways. It would allow Gagner to restore some of his trade value as teams become aware that he is a decent winger.
However the forward prospect depth is frighteningly bare. There is no replacement for Sam Gagner as the second line centre on this team or in the system. None whatsoever. That is bad news for an Edmonton team that needs a significant upgrade in the 2C spot. It means either spending big money on a costless-agent, trading away some of the defensive prospects to fill the 2C need, or they can draft a big-bodied centre man with a lot of upside as a future NHL player in the upcoming draft. The cheapest, but most time consuming route is making the selection at the NHL Draft be Draisaitl.
He would fit a need, while still being in the conversation as BPA at the #3 spot. It may be a bit of a reach, and if it somehow is between Draisaitl and Bennett, the Oilers should lean towards the younger, smaller Bennett. But will they? Based on that Stauffer tweet something tells me they won’t.

