
Brendan Rodgers' preferred formation this season seems like it will be the 4-3-3 system.
For most of pre-season Liverpool lined up in this system or something similar. However, against Stoke City on Sunday, the team started in a 4-2-3-1 shape rather than the 4-3-3. Starting off without a specialised defensive midfielder, Philippe Coutinho played ahead of both Jordan Henderson and James Milner in Liverpool’s midfield.
It must be noted that instead of the two English midfielders staying as a 'two' in midfield throughout the game, they took turns to sit back when the team was on the attack for spells of the match, especially in the first half.
So the 4-2-3-1 morphed into other shapes during spells of the game. The arrangement diminished the strong qualities of the two. Henderson's box-to-box play which forces errors and wins balls to set off attacks, was missing. Milner's all action energy-filled midfield play evident throughout pre-season was also absent.
The shape contributed to a lame attacking display from the Redmen in the first half, where they had just three shots at goal with none being on target.
Reds become more effective after system switch
Liverpool’s attacking play became more inventive and fluid when Emre Can was brought on for Adam Lallana on the 63rd minute. The German sat just in front of the back four with Henderson and Milner playing ahead of him, signaling a switch to a 4-3-3. Liverpool then had more control of the game, and had five shots in the second half with three being on target. The passing and movement was also significantly better.
The 27 minute performance instigated by the introduction of Can and the switch in formation to 4-3-3 should be a pointer to how Liverpool should set up this season.
The system suits most of the midfield talents Liverpool have. For Henderson and Milner, who seem certain starters, their best attributes are utilized in this shape more than a 4-2-3-1. Coutinho also functions effectively as a 'number eight' and can easily slot into the midfield three due to his defensive and pressing qualities.
When a midfield trio of Can, Henderson and Milner squeeze the Brazilian out of the midfield, he can also do a job at the wide-left position - signified by his increasing influence in the Stoke match when he took Lallana's position after the latter was substituted. Then there is the fact that, in terms of squad rotation and coping in other tournaments, the likes of Joao Carlos Teixeira, Joe Allen, Lucas Leiva and Jordan Rossiter can all function in the 4-3-3.
A defensively focused midfielder required if Reds to persist with the 4-3-3
However, as Can showed against Stoke, the system requires someone with the ability to sit infront of the back four.
Can aside, Lucas looks the most capable in the squad to perform that role. However with speculation about his future rife, chances are that he may not be at the club after September 1 and Can cannot be expected to play in that role throughout the season, so a replacement for Lucas will be a necessity.
Effective squad rotation will also determine the effectiveness of the system. So far Henderson and Milner seem to be the obvious cornerstones of Rodgers' midfield. They are certain to play once fit: Henderson by virtue of being captain and Milner because the promise of game time by the manager was the reason he chose Liverpool. But there are matches in which this pairing should be broken up.
Rodgers has a good blend of midfield options available to him and he will not be doing himself and the club much good if Milner, for instance, is made to start every match. There are matches a midfield trio of Can-Henderson-Coutinho will be more suited than one with Milner. A Lucas-Henderson-Can midfield may also be a good option for some other matches, granted the Brazilian stays at Anfield.
Rodgers should stick with the 4-3-3, but other formations available to him
The 4-3-3 is Rodgers’ preferred formation and the talents available to the team are more suited to it than a 4-2-3-1. To get the best out of the system, Rodgers has to effectively utilize the talents he has in midfield as against building everything around Milner and Henderson.
Should Lucas leave, a replacement should also be brought in to compete with Can for the deepest lying midfield position. The preference for 4-3-3 notwithstanding, the presence of great attacking talents in the team and the resolute defending in the first half against Stoke should also see formations like the 4-4-2 diamond and 4-2-3-1 feature in certain matches. The diamond can be for home matches against bottom half teams whilst the 4-2-3-1 can be of value in difficult away matches.
But if the Northern Irishman is looking for a long-term system to settle upon, it has to be the 4-3-3 - as it allows Liverpool to channel all their best assets into a system which maximises their potential going forward and at the back.

