Referees: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly

Ah referees, the sporting enigma which transcends space and time.  They are ever present; across all sports, in all cultures, and in every country.  Most are average, some are good, some are bad, and some are terrible. In a season which saw Italian Calcio witness some brash refereeing decisions, provoking heated discussions about true match winners (several betting sites even went so far to refund a second outcome for the Juventus - Catania match last fall), many have questioned the competency of the referees, and expressed a desire for instant replay.  I propose an alternative view on these referees, and what they mean to sport. 

Imagine a calcio not graced with the omnipresent referee intervention.  Where would it be without Tagliavento, Rizzoli, and their crews?  Maybe a couple of different results, but definitely less entertainment.  Call it what you will, but theatrics such as those bring attention, passion, debate, and energy to the sport. It is not always wanted, and is rarely positive, but is it negative?  It gives the tabloids something to talk about, it gives fans something to argue about, and it gives supporters a third party to blame.

Imagine sport without officials, one where every call was the right call.  How boring would that be?  Even add instant replay, the only place it could even conceivably work is through goal-line technology, and that would still slow the game down. Football is poetry in motion, not the stop-and-go rehearsal that is American Football.  Do we really want to add breaks and stoppages to the beautiful game?  Instead of yearning for perfection, and creating a monster, let's stick to imperfection, and keep this almost perfect game the way it is.

Go ahead, try and convince yourself you'd like instant replay, or perfect calls ever time; you've come to 1 of 2 conclusions.  Either you're a strictly logical, rational, no-nonsense (and no-fun, might I add) person who would love it, or you've realized that the variable created by the occasional bad call, and the occasional call that gifts your team the victory is worth it.  It creates an uncertainty in sport that is unmatched. It makes gambling that much more unpredictable, ranting and banter that much more common (and well, once again, fun), and creates one last outlet for passion that might go untapped without this variable. 

Now, granted, there have been some absolutely head-scratching works of genius this past season that undoubtedly should have never happened, but that is the way of sport; it mimics life. Nothing is fair, and because of this victory is that much sweeter. So, while it is easy to agree that referees are a necessary evil, remember that they add a certain element to the game.  The point of this is not to stick up for atrocities (i.e. gol di muntari), but to point out that refereeing has always been, and will always be a part of sport, and that we need to embrace its imperfections, because nothing is perfect.