Plagiarism and its dangers
Photo from spreadbetmagazine.com

It's the big story in tennis (or at least tennis journalism). Neil Harman, chief tennis writer at The Times and author of the Wimbledon Yearbook for the last ten years, has been using other writers' material in the Wimbledon Yearbook without acredditing them, for at least the last three years. He's currently dealing with the concequences - so far he's been suspended by The Times, replaced in his role at the All England Club, and his twitter account - he was the most followed tennis journalist on the site - has disappeared. So why is plagiarism such a big issue?

Firstly let me say that plagiarism is seen as a pretty serious transgression in most walks of life, and at all levels of expertise. From school age this is stressed - teenagers sign a declaration form to state that their GCSE coursework is entirely their own work, and keeping work accredited to you your own is an important responsiblity from then on, whether you're an academic, an author, a researcher, or a journalist. The fact that you should accredit other authors if you use their work in any capacity is therefore an extremely well-known, and actually pretty obvious one.

Why is it such a big deal? Getting marks you shouldn't, getting paid for work that isn't yours - at whatever level it occurs, it boils down to falsely trying to gain reward for material others have written - rewards (in whatever form) that are due the original author. Any incidence can be serious, but repeated plagiarism in a yearly publication from a world famous institution like the All England Club is very serious indeed. Here's the report on the details from Ben Rothenberg.

The big question for me here is what prompted Harman to cross the line in such a big way. He's already a man at the top of his profession - you don't get yourself into that position without being exceptional at what you do. Why, then, cut corners and flout important rules of journalism? It's clearly not as though he was incapable of writing high quality material. He's quoted as saying 

"I thought I tried very hard that every time I used work from someone else, I had given them the attribution that that work deserves. And clearly there have been times through rushing, through not being careful enough, I blurred those lines between what’s right and what’s wrong.”

Harman may well have been under time pressure, and it strikes me that using others' articles isn't a problem when writing a yearbook - so long as permission is obtained from the relevant authors and they are acknowledged in the proper way. He's claiming that he was fully intending to credit the other writers for their work, and made a bad job of doing so, rather than what others have suggested - that he thought he could get away with lifting passages of text from other articles and passing them off as his own.

Harman's response hasn't had a good reaction. Surely a journalist of such stature and experience (he's been in journalism for 40 years this year, according to his twitter biography) should know the importance of referencing passages properly? It's hard to see the fact that he didn't do so as a mistake from such an experienced writer.

Whatever the truth of what happened, one thing is clear - plagiarism is an offence that is taken extremely seriously in the journalism world. If cases like this are not taken seriously, how can any writer have confidence in protecting their work, of their right to claim ownership over an article or a passage? It's a mark of just how (entirely justifiably) strongly the journalism community feels about this that one of the world's leading tennis writers suddenly finds himself facing what could be the end of his career.