
In one of the biggest upsets of the college football season, the Vanderbilt Commodores stunned the No. 1 ranked Alabama Crimson Tide with a 40-35 victory on Saturday, marking Vanderbilt’s first-ever win over a top-ranked team in its football history. The result shook the college football world, as Alabama, a heavy 23-point favorite, could not overcome turnovers and a relentless Vanderbilt offense. The loss has far-reaching implications for both programs moving forward, and it highlights several key trends that could shape the rest of their seasons.
The Early Dominance: First Quarter Breakdown
Vanderbilt came out swinging, taking immediate control of the game. The Commodores capitalized on their first offensive possession with a quick strike. Running back Sedrick Alexander set the tone with a 7-yard touchdown run to give Vanderbilt a 7-0 lead, electrifying the Nashville crowd. But the momentum did not stop there.
On Alabama’s very next possession, quarterback Jalen Milroe, who has had a strong season up to this point, threw an ill-advised pass that was tipped and intercepted by Vanderbilt’s Randon Fontenette. Fontenette returned the interception 24 yards for a touchdown, putting the Commodores up 13-0 and shocking the No. 1 Crimson Tide, who had not trailed Vanderbilt by multiple scores in over two decades.
The pick-6 was a critical moment, not only because it extended Vanderbilt’s lead but because it highlighted Alabama’s early struggles on offense. Milroe’s mistake was the first of two costly turnovers that plagued the Crimson Tide throughout the game.
Halftime Lead: Second Quarter Action
Alabama began to find its footing in the second quarter, but Vanderbilt maintained its aggressive approach. Alabama’s offense, led by running back Jam Miller, responded with an 8-yard rushing touchdown to bring the game back to 13-7. Miller’s performance was one of the few bright spots for Alabama in the first half as he tried to provide a spark to a team struggling to keep pace.
Vanderbilt, however, refused to let Alabama take control. The Commodores extended their lead again with another touchdown from Alexander, this time a 1-yard rush, followed by a 51-yard field goal from kicker Brock Taylor. Taylor’s field goal capped off a stellar half of football for Vanderbilt, who led 23-7 late in the second quarter.
Alabama managed to pull within nine points before halftime, scoring a second touchdown via Miller with just over a minute remaining in the half. This brought the halftime score to 23-14 in favor of Vanderbilt. Alabama, though trailing, appeared to have some momentum as they entered the locker room.
Alabama’s Attempted Comeback: Third Quarter Developments
The third quarter saw a much more determined Alabama team. With their backs against the wall, the Crimson Tide began to execute more effectively on both sides of the ball. Jam Miller added another rushing touchdown, narrowing the score to 23-21, and it appeared that Alabama was poised to stage a comeback.
But Vanderbilt continued to defy expectations. Facing a critical 4th-and-1 at the Alabama 36-yard line, the Commodores took a calculated risk. Rather than play conservatively and attempt a short-yardage run, they called a play-action pass. Quarterback Diego Pavia delivered a perfectly thrown ball to wide receiver Junior Sherrill, who caught the pass for a 36-yard touchdown. The bold play extended Vanderbilt’s lead to 30-21, leaving Alabama’s defense stunned and the Commodores in control as the third quarter ended.
The Fourth Quarter: Vanderbilt Seals the Victory
As the game entered its final quarter, Alabama continued to fight back. They pulled within two points again after another successful drive culminated in a touchdown, bringing the score to 30-28. However, Vanderbilt’s efficiency on offense, especially on third down, proved too much for Alabama’s defense to handle.
Vanderbilt extended their lead again with a field goal, followed by a clutch touchdown pass from Pavia to tight end Kamrean Johnson. With the score now 40-28, the Commodores had a 12-point lead, and time was running out for Alabama. Although Milroe led the Crimson Tide to one more touchdown, making it 40-35 with under three minutes left in the game, Vanderbilt’s defense held strong, securing a historic victory for the program.
How Did This Happen?
Vanderbilt’s victory over Alabama is one of the biggest upsets in recent college football history. The Commodores had not beaten Alabama since 1984 and had not scored more than three points in their previous three matchups against the Crimson Tide. Yet on this day, Vanderbilt executed almost flawlessly, taking advantage of Alabama’s mistakes and converting on key opportunities.
Defensively, Alabama was unable to get the stops they needed, particularly on third and fourth downs. Vanderbilt converted 12 of 18 third downs and scored on their lone fourth-down attempt, reflecting a level of efficiency that Alabama simply could not match. Meanwhile, Alabama’s defense, which had been suspect in earlier games, was exposed again, allowing Vanderbilt’s quarterback Diego Pavia to throw for 252 yards on just 20 attempts, including two touchdown passes.
What This Means for Alabama
For Alabama, this loss is a devastating blow, coming off a huge win over Georgia the previous week. While the Crimson Tide still have a path to the SEC Championship and College Football Playoff, this game exposed serious issues on both sides of the ball. Defensively, Alabama’s secondary struggled to contain Vanderbilt’s passing game, and offensively, costly turnovers — including a pick-6 and a fumble by Milroe — made it impossible for the Crimson Tide to fully mount a comeback.
Alabama’s run game also lacked explosiveness, averaging just four yards per carry. With the loss, Alabama now needs to regroup quickly as they face a challenging road ahead in the SEC.
What This Means for Vanderbilt
For Vanderbilt, this is arguably the biggest win in the history of the program. Under head coach Clark Lea, the Commodores have struggled in recent years, going winless in SEC play last season. However, this victory over Alabama provides a massive boost to the program’s credibility and future prospects. With this win, Vanderbilt now has a realistic chance of reaching bowl eligibility for the first time since 2018.
This upset victory will likely be a defining moment in Coach Lea’s tenure and could serve as a turning point for the program as they look to build momentum for the remainder of the 2024 season.
A Game for the Ages
Vanderbilt’s 40-35 victory over Alabama will go down as one of the biggest upsets in college football history. From their early 13-0 lead to their gutsy play-calling late in the game, the Commodores executed when it mattered most. For Alabama, this loss is a significant setback, but their season is far from over. As both teams move forward, this game will serve as a reminder of just how unpredictable college football can be.

