Jurgen Klinsmann Should Be Fired

For any of the regular readers, it's no secret that there are those (including yours truly) who have been asking for USMNT head coach Jurgen Klinsmann to be fired for years now. His man management, bizarre personnel decisions and over training of players have all been huge strikes against him. Still, he had managed to get results that are the bare minimum required of any coach at this point, which is win the Gold Cup and reach the Round of 16 at the World Cup.

Things are completely different now.

After Wednesday's 2 - 1 loss to Jamaica in the Gold Cup semifinal, those who have long been asking now have a concrete reason to point to nearly demand his immediate firing. Before delving into the specifics of the afore mentioned reasons, lets look at the base line of the Gold Cup.

The previous manager had a successful World Cup after previously winning the Gold Cup and having won the US' first senior medal in the modern era (ie since 1990). That silver medal came when the US lost to Brazil in the Confederations Cup final. The coach? Bob Bradley. After all that success and reaching the Gold Cup final again, his team ended up losing to Mexico 4 - 2 after having a 2 - 0 lead in the match. Almost immediately after the game, USSF President Sunil Gulati fired Bradley and hired Klinsmann.

That's the standard set by Gulati: embarrass the team at the Gold Cup and you're gone.

If blowing a 2 - 0 lead in the final falls in that category, what does losing to Jamaica in the semifinal qualify as?

Now on to other reasons why fans have long been wanting a new coach.

Over training

Before the World Cup, the US suffered a rash of ligament and muscle injuries that devastated the squad. The worst of which was an injury to Jozy Altidore in the opening match against Ghana a mere handful of minutes into the game. While players were tight lipped about the goings on of practice the rash of injuries one after another were the clues needed for experts and fans alike to point at the cause. Which leads us to the next issue.

Personnel Decisions

Every coach has a system they want to use with their players. This is their choice lineup that leads to victories. What a good coach needs is a Plan B that uses the same players in a different way or different players in the same system. Injuries and suspensions will throw a wrench into every plan. It's just going to happen and coach's need to prepare for it.

When Klinsmann announced his World Cup roster, eyes were drawn to Landon Donovan's absence. Many others saw the lack of forward depth, especially the absence of Terrance Boyd. The talented striker was playing well in Europe but left off the roster. Boyd was the only other player in the pool that possessed the similar skills of Altidore. When Altidore went down, he had no replacement and no other lineup he could use. So he awkwardly forced players into bad positions (such as Dempsey as the target striker) that caused the US to play poorly in the World Cup.

Both of these decisions hurt the US immensely and left the team worse for wear.

This Gold Cup has it's own issues as well, with Klinsmann relying on Altidore once again despite the fact that he's coming off an injury before the tournament began. The lack of youth in the squad and players with speed and difference makers cost him a shot to defend his title. The most egregious decision is his insistence on using John Brooks and Ventura Alvarado. Both are incredibly talented and ones that will likely be the heart of the defense in the future. In a tournament setting today, though, neither one has shown themselves ready to be that player.

Jurgen would have been much better off relying on his World Cup veterans of Matt Besler and Omar Gonzalez. Timothy Chandler is another choice that had fans scratching their heads. For all the good the German-born outside back has done in the Bundesliga, he's never been able to translate that to the national team. In friendlies ahead of the Gold Cup he showed himself incapable of manning the right back spot. Still he went with him when he might have been better off using Brad Evans or Fabian Johnson in that role.

Man Management

The story of Klinsmann and Donovan is well-documented and familiar to all so it won't be discussed here except to note that it happened and was handled poorly. Clint Dempsey being named captain was another interesting choice that later turned out to be a poor choice when Deuce said he didn't enjoy being captain. With Michael Bradley the obvious choice even back then, it's strange Jurgen didn't go with the obvious one. His shutout of Benny Feilhaber and the strangeness surrounding Geoff Cameron just shows how he has handled the top talents.

His constant criticisms of Altidore, Bradley, Dempsey and others, especially as it relates to Major League Soccer, is another huge strike against him. There's ways to handle things and the way he handles things under the guise of increasing pressure on players to make them better isn't the best way to go about it. Antagonizing the player pool won't get the same reaction as others in Europe where Klinsmann is familiar.

The last three reasons are enough in many cases for coaches to be let go. Add in the loss to Jamaica and the potential miss out on the Confederations Cup should they lose the playoff this October and there is reason enough to let Klinsmann go.

Naturally, the counter argument is: who takes his place? Another article for another day.