A mission cut short: Tito Vilanova

“Our coach is not in New York on holiday.”

Javier Mascherano made matters exceedingly clear to the press as they gathered around, questioning Barcelona’s sudden drop in form. When Tito Vilanova left the Barcelona bench to receive treatment in the United States after it had been announced on the 19th of December that he had suffered a cancer relapse, his club had slumped to it’s first defeat of the season. The previously undefeated Barcelona dropped more points and lost more games over Tito Vilanova’s spell away than they did in the rest of the season put together.

Tito was the man that made the difference for them. It was not just that he was in New York, it was that everyone was well aware of what he was doing there. Mascherano hit the nail on the head, emphasizing that there was a human side to the issue as well.

When Pep Guardiola stepped down 12 months ago, there was an audible sigh of relief when Tito Vilanova was announced as his replacement. It appeared to confirm to everyone in the Catalan capital that things would continue as they were, that the person at the helm would implement a similar style, a similar philosophy, and win with flair.

Barcelona, while they had been emerging with the points under Tito’s guidance, were not playing particularly convincingly. They were riding on sheer determination, rather than skill. While in the past they had gracefully slid the shiny silver dagger in after having worn down teams with their passing game, now they murdered teams with a bloody axe. There would be no dignified, systematic dissection of their opponents, just wild hacking.

They cared less about how they won so long as they did. It was an unfamiliar situation, with games ending with outrages score lines. One of the hallmarks of their early season triumphs were that they would win despite not having been the better team. They would win in Osasuna after being comprehensively outplayed, only to be saved by a couple of late goals. They would concede four to Deportivo, but win because they managed to score five. They would be losing 2-1 at Sevilla in the 89th only to be walking out 3-2 winners. Systematic dissection may have been more dignified, but sometimes mindless hacking could be entertaining to look.

There was much talk that season about how Barcelona were a team that did not actually need a coach. Their performances while their coach was absent beg to differ. Video conference calls pre-match, Skype, WhatsApp messages during games… they’re all well and good as replacements, but how do you truly instill in your players a sense of belief that they can go the extra mile, that they can beat the odds and emerge victorious, through a laptop screen? With fairly poor audio, how do you tell your players that you can come back in the second half during your motivational speech? How do you relay complicated and precise instructions via WhatsApp to assistant coach Jordi Roura about how to alter tactics mid-match, when many of us would struggle to put even the most simple of concepts into text? You cannot gage the atmosphere and weigh up every possible variable before deciding on the right plan of action without actually being present in the stadium. Tito tried valiantly, but ultimately his focus had to be on his health.

Barcelona president, Sandro Rosell had this to say after having visited Vilanova in New York during his treatment: “Tito’s health is the most important thing: everything else is secondary. Tito is our coach, nobody else. We are not going to move anyone, even if it means winning nothing. For us, a good season is Tito making a full recovery.”

Tito Vilanova did return from treatment to coach again but the joy was short lived. While the season ended fairly successfully in terms of silverware (with Barcelona clinching the Spanish League with the joint highest number of points), the true victory, the one that every culé and football fan truly wanted was not achieved. Puyol had the two members of the club that had gone toe to toe with one of the most terrifying diseases on Earth lift the La Liga trophy for the Camp Nou. Only one of them was well and truly able to say that he was rid of it. Eric Abidal, now at Monaco FC, will continue to do the thing he loves most in the world: play football. Take that, cancer.

Tito Vilanova, however, is still fighting his battle. And he has the support of absolutely everyone. He will not return to the Barcelona bench next season, he will not be able to fulfill the second year of his contract due to the treatment he will require.

He is, in the words of Spanish publicist Risto Mejide, “not so much retiring, but instead concentrating on the most important match of his life.”