
The 2018 FIFA World Cup is simultaneously one of the best and worst things to happen to England in the modern era.
Gareth Southgate led a young team to the tournament in Russia, and expectations among the English public were low for the first time in decades.
However, this young team stunned the world and themselves by reaching the semi-finals, but Croatia halted their courageous journey in extra time in Moscow.
Upon their return, the team was welcomed as heroes and showered with praise by the public, a sentiment equally extended to Southgate.
They were the first English team to reach the semi-finals of a tournament since 1996.
Their success was not limited to the pitch; through social media and Southgate's interviews, a nation fell in love with their football team and the characters within it.
With success came greater expectations. The public now thirsted for achievement like never before.
Three years later, the side came agonisingly close to fulfilling that expectation at the 2021 UEFA European Championship when they lost to a savvy Italy team on penalties in the final at Wembley.
While some members of the public praised the team for reaching a final and saw it as a sign of progress, others saw this as an opportunity missed and declared Southgate as in over his head.
People scrutinised his tactics with a fine-tooth comb, suggesting he was overly cautious and afraid to remove the handbrake.
The boo-boys are still in full voice as we sit here in 2024 with England in their third semi-final out of four tournaments under Southgate.
Back to the point that the 2018 World Cup, while incredible, raised expectations to an ultra-high level.
The question is, are England fans right to have lofty expectations of winning tournaments while also playing swashbuckling attacking football, or should they be more grateful for the work Southgate and his side have done over the years?
-
The Beginning
It is very easy to forget where England were when Southgate took over.
In the summer of 2016, Iceland dumped them out of the 2016 European Championship in one of the darkest days in English footballing history.
Sam Allardyce was appointed the new manager after the shock defeat, an appointment that did not spark optimism among the public.
Allardyce's tenure did not last long (one game, to be precise) after he was accused of malpractice; he resigned with immediate effect.
England's attempt at revitalising a broken footballing nation had faltered at the first hurdle.
At the time, Gareth Southgate was in charge of the Under 21 side, but he agreed to take over for the next four games temporarily. The team went unbeaten in those games, and the former Middlesbrough manager was offered the role permanently.
Reluctant initially, he eventually agreed to a four-year deal with the FA.
At this point, feelings towards the national team were not overly favourable, and fans did not see too much talent to get excited about as we waved goodbye to the golden generation and looked towards the future.
As we sit here seven years after Southgate's appointment and mere days away from yet another semi-final under his stewardship, it may be worth reflecting on where we were as a football nation.
Lost, lifeless and void of hope.
-
Victims of their own success
If the 2018 World Cup raised expectations, the 2021 European Championship elevated them to another level.
The tournaments that define the Southgate era more than any other.
The team came so close on both occasions that these performances became the measuring stick future sides would be measured with.
But also, it was the peak of the nation and Gareth's love affair.
His name was sung in pubs up and down the country, and people were adorned with Southgate-esque waistcoats.
A semi-final and a final seemed so far away when England had been embarrassed by Iceland in 2016 that Southgate was surely above any criticism, wasn't he?
Well, that was put to the test when England went to Qatar in 2022 for the World Cup.
After the previous two tournaments, the public was ready for their side to be crowned as World Champions. And it looked like they may do that, scoring 12 goals in their first four games.
But in the quarter-final, they battled hard against France but ultimately lost to Didier Deschamps' side.
There is an argument that this tournament was the best football England had played during Southgate's tenure. However, because he had set the standard so high in the previous two tournaments, the fans felt this was not enough, and it may be time for Southgate to go.
Southgate, the man many had dubbed the hero of English football, had lived long enough to see himself become the villain in the eyes of some.
-
So, are expectations too high?
Flash forward to the current tournament; England topped their group, but not in the way many had hoped.
After their 0-0 draw with Slovenia, Southgate and his side wandered over to their fans only to be greeted with boos and empty cups thrown from the stands.
A physical manifestation of Southgate being the victim of his own success.
We are now at a point where anything other than perfection results in abuse for Southgate and his team; it is genuinely bizarre behaviour from some fans and something that cannot be condoned.
But if we bring the conversation back to what are reasonable expectations for England fans, do some fans have a point?
There is a strong argument that, on paper, this is one of the best England teams of all time and a team that has the potential to strike fear into opposition's hearts.
Yet, England rode their luck in this tournament and have delivered abject performances.
England have reached their third semi-final in recent years, but because the performances have not been up to par in the eyes of the fans, some believe it is still not good enough.
This may be related to the fact that England have consistently underperformed in major tournaments for over 50 years despite having the resources and players many nations can only wish for. This is an issue that outdates this current team and Southgate.
So, have England fans become greedy with the success they have seen over recent years, or are they well within their rights to complain despite England still having a chance of winning the competition?
The answer is that there is no correct answer; both can be true, but as we sit here in the present day, talk of performances and line-ups must be put to bed, and as a nation, we must back Southgate and the boys as they bid to make successive European Championship finals.

