
The weirdness that has been surrounding the main event for UFC 189 now has some clarity. After reports that current featherweight champion Jose Aldo (25-1) missed Tuesday’s highly anticipated training, it was only a matter of time before a final decision was made. It was rumored that we would receive word on Friday about the status of Aldo but as of Monday afternoon, the UFC issued a statement that he has pulled out. So, in steps Chad Mendes (17-2) who was notified late last week to be ready just in case the Brazilian champion could not compete and 'Money' was more than happy to oblige. The question that remains is whether this was the correct selection or should Frankie Edgar (19-4-1) have received that call. While it’s no question that Conor McGregor (17-2) will see the team Alpha Male product on July 11th, there is a strong case that could be made for Edgar.
Edgar is on a four fight win streak facing a murders row of some of the top talent in the 145 division. Wins against Urijah Faber, Cub Swanson, BJ Penn and Charles Olivera would put most fighters in a contender's spot. There was even a time when Frankie jumped to the number one spot but that was changed after Mendes faced Ricardo Lamas. Both Edgar and Mendes have faced and lost to Aldo but for Frankie, it was only once back in 2013. There was no guarantees on the table that he would be listed as next in line but it seemed to make sense after the Faber fight. If Frankie was not the number one contender, then we would have seen Aldo - Mendes with a victory for Jose over McGregor. Now Frankie will just have to sit back and wait, which could be longer than the New Jersey native cares to do.
On this Monday’s The MMA Hour, Ariel Helwani spoke with Edgar who was not pleased he didn’t receive the call to step in for Aldo. As mentioned above, he felt that his body of work more than justified his position to get that shot. He also said he wanted to fight one more time before the years end and if so, more than likely it won’t be for a title. The best case scenario for that to happen for Franke just doesn’t exist. Let’s say Conor beats Mendes or vice versa, it will be for an interim title which means once Aldo is back and healthy he will still be next in line to face the winner. If by chance the winner of the fight is Conor more than likely we could get a trilogy scenario right off the bat. That could mean Edgar wouldn't have an opportunity to possibly late next year or even longer. In the stacked featherweight division, there are fights to make but when you are the number three guy, is it worth the risk even though you are so close?
There was no way the UFC, Conor McGregor or the Republic of Ireland were not going to allow the main event for UFC 189 to take place. Mendes is a formidable opponent for McGregor whose only downfall maybe the short notice. The Team Alpha Male fighter, like his brothers, take pride in staying in shape all year round. The same can be said for Frankie who posted a photo on his social media of he and his daughter expecting a call from the UFC brass. That call didn’t happen and the speculation of 155 fights with Nate Diaz and other dream scenarios can now be put to bed. UFC fans would have no issue regardless of the opponent so it’s a can’t lose scenario for them but what about the fighters? Many will start to question what else is needed to receive the ultimate opportunity. If opponents and a shuffling of the rankings doesn’t do the job, then how can anyone say they are truly worth of receiving that next title shot?

