
The signing of James Milner is one that has split opinion amongst Liverpool fans.
This is no indictment on 'Milny', as Jordan Henderson calls him; neither is it an affront on his talent.
He is a very good footballer, very experienced and a winner. That definitely counts for a lot in this Liverpool team that is short on experience and winners. Milner will prove to be a useful acquisition.
My mind goes to the Liverpool - Manchester City match at Anfield in 2013/14 anytime I am tempted to doubt his ability. He used his panoply of technical abilities and hard work to virtually drag City into the contest that had passed them by in the first-half.
Too many options?
His presence adds experience and work rate to the Reds' midfield. But it throws up a number of challenging issues too. There is a plethora of midfield options available to Liverpool this season: Henderson, Milner, Philippe Coutinho, Emre Can, Lucas Leiva, Joe Allen, Joao Carlos Teixeira and Jordan Rossiter.
Henderson and Coutinho were two of Liverpool's influential midfielders last season. Their versatility contributes to their influence, but Coutinho is better as the "number 8" while Henderson thrives very well in the box-to-box role. So if Brendan Rodgers is to go with three in midfield, those two pick themselves out.
As was widely reported prior to his move, Milner was won over by the guarantee of regular game time in central midfield. Pre-season matches have very much confirmed those reports. His appointment as vice-captain only goes to rubber stamp that. Milner has started and played 90 minutes almost all of the main matches so far and in all those matches he operated from central midfield.
It is increasingly clear that Henderson-Milner is the guaranteed bedrock of Liverpool's, midfield around which others may revolve. These are two good professionals with a good engine to battle 90 minutes non-stop. They also have the ability to create and score goals. That should be positive for Liverpool.
But looking at the talent at Rodgers' disposal it is not totally a good news that the ex-Man City man is a guaranteed starter, possibly for every league very possible match. It is very possible the team will be better in some matches with different combinations other than the Milner-Henderson axis.
But as it looks he is here for game time and to play in midfield so as long as he is fit and in form he will get the games. That is what troubles me.
Developing Emre Can
The chant on the Kop for the young German is simply, "Emre - can", meaning Emre is capable. The Liverpool fan base has very high hopes for the midfielder, with some daring to think he is the one to step into the shoes of Steven Gerrard.
The expectation was that after a season where he impressed in defence, this season was going to mark the period he establishes himself in his preferred midfield role.
However, given that Henderson and Milner are guaranteed starters, Emre’s chance to play regularly in midfield is severely affected. That certainly cannot be good news given that he is considered a future star for the team.
Whether Rodgers will be prepared to rotate Milner in and out of the squad to accommodate Can is yet to be seen. Emre Can could yet get a chance to operate as the defensive midfielder since he is more suited to that role than Henderson or Milner. He could as sit at the base of a midfield diamond if the manager goes for that formation.
However it can be gleaned from the preseason that Rodgers intends going with a 4-3-3 or 4-2-3-1 this season. This is very worrying for Emre and the fans who expect him to grow into a big star for the team.
Deploying the diamond formation
Even though Rodgers’ preference has always been the 4-3-3, some of the best results and performance under his reign has been achieved with a 4-4-2 diamond formation.
The present squad is more equipped this season to play that formation effectively especially against lower table teams particularly at Anfield.
The Henderson-Milner axis is a disciplined and hard-working pairing that gives a lot of drive, pressing and harassing. But over the course of the 38 weeks there may be matches, a lot of matches the club’s potentially explosive attacking talents should just be unleashed. In this case the Milner-Henderson axis should be broken up for a midfield four of say: Can at the base of the diamond, Henderson and Coutinho at the sides of the diamond with Roberto Firmino at the tip.
Christian Benteke can then partner a fit Daniel Sturridge upfront. This is a mouthwatering prospect. However the guarantee of first team football to Milner and his coronation as vice captain may mean this prospect will never be realised.
Henderson-Milner Axis and Defensive Midfield
It is widely known that Rodgers does not prefer a specialized defensive midfielder. He has in previous times played Allen in that role even though Lucas has also featured in that position. His determination to develop a Milner-Henderson pairing in midfield potentially leaves problems for the defensive midfield area and in effect Liverpool’s defence.
When he has chosen to go with the two as a pairing in front of the defence, the team has been left exposed when the opponent is on counter attack. It happened on several occasions in the Helsinki friendly. Even though on occasions they two took turns to stay behind, large gaps were left between the defenders and the midfield area.
A quality opposition would have exploited this very well. As a pairing in front of a back four, the two are not akin to the Nemanja Matic-Cesc Fabregas axis, one of the best in the league. Whilst they may have the creativity Fabregas offers Chelsea, none of them offers what Matic brings to the Chelsea team.
It is not enough that they are hard workers and have good engines to run throughout the 90 minutes. At least one of them need the skill to screen and shield the back four to be able protect the defence. Rodgers’ determination to stick them there regardless of these issues may hurt the team especially against top opposition.
Utilizing Coutinho and Firmino Effectively
The Brazilians’ best positions are in the centre of the pitch and not on the wings in as part of a front three. They are talented footballers so they can function on the wings but they are at their best in the center of the pitch.
Imagine a midfield three that has Coutinho in the “number 8” role and Firmino in the “number 10”. Creativity and hopefully goals will be boundless. This can blow away lower table teams especially at Anfield. With a good defensive minded player by them, they could wreck havoc whilst not significantly sacrificing the hard work Milner and Henderson offer.
Firmino is noted for his hardwork and Coutinho has added graft to his silky skills since he came to Anfield. But this is possibly a pairing Liverpool fans may never see because Milner has to play and play all times once he is fit.
James Milner is a good acquisition by the club and greatly boosts Liverpool’s midfield options. But the terms with which he came to Anfield - playing regularly and in central midfield - is not all good news.

