
On 23 September, Aston Villa announced that Monchi is moving on from his position with the club.
It was a decision that the manager, Unai Emery, confirmed had been in the pipeline for some time.
"It was something we were working on, knowing about while speaking with Monchi.”
The final straw seemed to be the sluggishness of the work in the transfer window of this episode.
"After the transfer window had finished we were speaking about our relationship here, working with the club and working together. Then, we decided with the club and him, and with Roberto Olabe as well, to do a normal transition. It has not changed anything, it is only changing the man.”
There is no doubt that the Basque boss is unhappy about the sluggishness of squad strengthening.
“Some players joined us late. We are trying to recover as soon as possible out performance.”
Only the players can perform on the pitch, but a different direction is emerging behind the scenes.
Olabe's reunion with Emery
Roberto Olabe operated as a Director of Football for seven years at Real Sociedad. However, he also helped to appoint Emery as Almeria manager in 2006 and was also the manager of Real Union in the 2011/12 season, a club that Emery now owns. A strong bond should help make up for lost ground.
"We reacted quickly with one person I know personally, I have a lot of confidence with Roberto.”
-
A story of suboptimal gambles
Monchi meant business when he arrived in June 2023. Youri Tielemans was a free pickup from Leicester, finding a home in Emery's system, and becoming the club's Player of the Season last term.
Pau Torres was a trusted lieutenant of the manager from Villarreal, adding progressive passing from the back, and in the winter window came another steal in the form of Morgan Rogers. A misfit for the traditional idea of ten, he felt he had the freedom to express himself back in the Midlands.
But a series of slightly unreasonable bets since the summer of 2024 has eaten away at the margin for error. Players like Lewis Dobbin, Enzo Barrenechea, Samuel Iling-Junior, and Jaden Philogene played minimal or no role for the side, which suffered from a lack of options at the turn of 2025.
The bets that piled up
Signings like £37.5 million man Ian Maatsen or £50 million Amadou Onana have to hit for a club like Villa. Both are good players, and Onana, particularly, is blessed with a unique collection of traits. However, neither nailed a place as a pivotal part of the 'structure', and the risks have kept piling up.
Donyell Malen, a £21.5 million purchase from Borussia Dortmund, has not been a game-changer in the attack. Marcus Rashford and Marco Asensio added depth and impact as winter window loanees, but their wages put pressure on the budget. Champions League qualification was a must for the club.
It all hinged on a trip to Old Trafford, and a disallowed Rogers goal could be the turning point of a project on the up. Villa lost 2-0 to Man United, finished in sixth spot, and things have not picked up.
Jacob Ramsey was the latest departure to balance the books and a big miss as a Birmingham boy. Meanwhile, the likes of Harvey Elliott and Jadon Sancho only arrived on conditional packages by deadline day, leaving the attack short after Leon Bailey switched to Roma on a loan agreement.
Olabe has a serious job on his hands to respond to spending struggles and keep the club competitive.

