ICC Champions Trophy 2025: Can England Bounce Back?
Harry Brook  reacts after being dismissed (Photo by Michael Steele/Getty Images)

After a dismal tour of India where England were decimated in a whitewash in the ODI series, and earned just a solitary T20 victory in another series defeat, Jos Buttler and his side must bounce back as they turn their sights to the ICC Champions Trophy.

The one sided series domination was a stark lesson to an England side plummeting with India dismantling their opponents with ease. With new limited overs coach Brendon McCullum overlooking, the sheer task ahead of the new limited overs coach would have dawned very quickly as England continued their dismal limited overs form.

Despite reigning World Champions in both limited formats upon the conclusion of the T20 World Cup in 2022, Buttler’s tenure has since seen England deteriorate at an alarming rate. The prospect of even just competing at the Champions Trophy appears to be daunting.

England have failed to win an ODI series since claiming a 1-0 series victory over Ireland in September 2023 (two fixtures were abandoned due to weather without a ball being bowled).

Since then a pitiful showing at the ICC Cricket World Cup 2023 ensued before series defeats to West Indies twice, Saturdays opponents Australia, and the aforementioned drubbing by India.

Ill disciplined and weak minded batting has seen frailties at the top of the England order exposed, and with injuries ravaging the bowling attack, England have struggled to find consistency resulting in slipping down to 7th in the ODI rankings.

Whilst recent history fails to offer much encouragement for England, the arrival of McCullum, who replaced Matthew Mott, offers some encouragement, particularly after the coach helped rejuvenate the Test side. So what changes can he make for England to bounce back and respond against their bitter rivals in Lahore?

  • Smith at Three

England have announced their side to play Australia with Jamie Smith returning from injury  to bat at number three. The Surrey wicketkeeper will also replace Phil Salt with the gloves who will continue to partner Ben Duckett at the top of the order.

The aggressive move sees Smith rise up the order, and the 24-year-old can take advantage.

Smith currently averages 22.16 with a high score of 49 in seven ODIs, and has never batted higher than five in the order but Smith impressed with his aggressiveness during his recent Test appearances, and has boasted an impressive showing at domestic level in the limited overs formats. The move should allow Smith to take advantage of any early wicket losses in the powerplay, and also provides the wicketkeeper batsman more freedom when there is likely to be more pace on the ball.

The move also allows Joe Root to drop to fourth in the batting order, and after England saw their frailties against spin implode versus India, Root dropping down the order allows for one of Englands best players of spin to hopefully be present during the middle overs, and the flatter pitches in Pakistan will also be welcomed.

Another knock on effect is Buttler dropping to six, which may help provide further firing power later in the order, and boost Englands finishing ability- with the side unable to push on after getting themselves into good positions in recent times. There will also be hope that Harry Brook can excel after his previous performances in Pakistan.

  • Misfiring Bowling

England failed to provide enough pressure during the middle overs against India, struggling to take wickets or limit scoring effectively with McCullum experimenting with several different attacks.

The match against Australia has seen England prioritise batting, with only four frontline bowlers selected, and this will mean Liam Livingstone and Joe Root will be expected to pick up a significant amount of overs. Jamie Overton is also with the squad but England are unlikely to opt for an all round seamer.

Jofra Archer and Mark Wood are set to play an ODI for the first time together in two years, and they will be accompanied by the returning Brydon Carse, whilst Adil Rashid will provide the spin options with England very reliant on whether Rashid can perform.

Archer and Wood shows a clear effort at pace, but with both struggling with fitness, Gus Atkinson and Saqib Mahmood will hopefully provide ample depth. 

  • Tom Banton

Despite not originally being selected, and left out of the eleven to face Australia, Tom Banton could be the "X" factor that England need. 

Banton originally made his England debut at the age of 19 in 2019, and after featuring in limited overs competitions throughout the world, Banton has become a short form specialist batsman, and his experience could be a decisive factor and an exhilarating option.

The 26-year-old scored 493 runs at an average of 54.77 during the recent ILT20 in the UAE, and Banton showed promise in the third ODI against India despite the defeat, scoring 38 when batting at number three to lead all scorers alongside Atkinson.

Banton has an average of 28.66 in seven ODIs, with a top score of 58, and after returning to work with McCullum, who Banton previously worked with at Kolkata Knight Riders in 2020, England will hope the batsman can provide the missing spark.

  • Depleted Aussies

England can perhaps take solace that despite Australia reigning as current World Champions in the ODI format, several members of that side will be absent on Saturday. 

Pat Cummins (ankle), Josh Hazlewood (hip) and Mitchell Starc (personal reasons), all remain absent, with left-arm quick Spencer Johnson, seamer Sean Abbott and left-armer Ben Dwarshuis tasked with the duty of replacing the Aussie trio.

Although all three are talented bowlers, England will certainly feel more optimistic without Cummins, Hazlewood and Starc who have 525 ODI wickets between them and all featured as part of Australia's 2015 and 2023 World Cup successes.

The Aussies will also be without all-rounders Mitchell Marsh (back), Cameron Green (back) and Marcus Stoinis (retired) too, and after a disappointing series defeat to Sri Lanka prior to the tournament questions surround the world champions, but even so, Australia will enter the match as favourites against an England side struggling for substance.

England XI: Phil Salt, Ben Duckett, Jamie Smith (wk), Joe Root, Harry Brook, Jos Buttler (capt), Liam Livingstone, Brydon Carse, Jofra Archer, Adil Rashid, Mark Wood