Man City’s new fragility keeps coming to the fore with continual collapses
Getty: Carl Recine

It’s a position that Manchester City have been in countless times before under Pep Guardiola: less than five minutes of regulation time remaining and close to victory.

Not seeing it through would have been unthinkable for this team only a few months ago. Now, it is as regular as the weekly shop.

The dramatic 3-2 defeat to Real Madrid in the first leg of their Champions League play-off was the fifth time this season that City have lost a match from a winning position. To give some perspective,  that is more than the past four seasons combined. Whereas Guardiola’s side were once so dependable, now they are utterly fragile.

Take the 86th minute when City should have been calmly seeing through the final minutes. Instead, Ederson, who had earlier made a string of saves, played a stray pass into midfield, leaving Ruben Dias to try and win a header with City’s defence out of shape. Real were able to run right through with Brahim Diaz tucking home from Vinicius Junior’s rebound that the City ‘keeper failed to hold.

If that was poor game management from the home team then six minutes later was even worse. City were too open again in the final minute of stoppage time when Vinicius nipped in ahead of Rico Lewis to steel Mateo Kovacic’s awkward pass. Ederson was caught out of position as his compatriot raced through to set up Jude Bellingham’s winner.

It’s the type of slapdash defending that was hardly associated with the current four-time Premier League champions. But is becoming uncomfortably familiar for Guardiola.

“When you are 2-1 up, psychologically you are scaring the opponent and continue to attack, and after I could understand, but in 2-1, nothing wrong happened,” the City manager explained. “Then, we were closer to creating chances than them.

Getty: Julian Fenney
Getty: Julian Finney

"After: what happened happened. It’s happened many times this season [giving up a lead]. I know the quality of Real Madrid. They started really well, first 10 minutes, and then we took the game. In the second half we gave away what we had.

“Its just bad decisions, that’s all. Everyone has to take accountability — I take it. It’s not about you and me, it’s everyone. It’s tough, but we will recover.”

With Paris Saint-Germain, Manchester United, Brighton & Hove Albion and Sporting Lisbon being the other teams that have triumphed over City despite falling behind, there are lessons not being learnt.

“I don’t know how to put it into words straight away, it’s so raw and frustrating for everyone,” John Stones said. “We were in the game until so late and then it’s two situations that happen and we concede. It’s frustrating as a defender to come away with that result. It’s a feeling of anger and frustration.”

City's muddled minds make it easy for Real

Guardiola’s players are clearing lacking confidence. This is a season unlike many of them have experienced before: 12 defeats and plenty more subpar performances, too; it is a rut that is proving difficult from which to get out.

When the time came for clear heads to see out a valuable victory, City only contrived to throw it away. They now have an almighty task in next week’s second leg to prevent their earliest exit from the competition since the 2012/13 campaign.

And yet, Real deserve to be heading back to Madrid with the advantage. Despite City’s capitulation, Carlo Ancelotti’s team were the better side and performed well with a completely makeshift defence that had never played together before.

The visitors accumulated chances — both Vinicius and Kylian Mbappe struck the woodwork — and were, again, indebted to their reluctance to give up even as the clock ticked down. They remain inevitable.

Getty: Anadolu
Getty: Anadolu

Their season has not been as plain sailing as their position at the top of La Liga suggests, though. The Spanish and European champions had already lost eight games this term — including against Liverpool, Lille and AC Milan — and have been, rightly, accused of being too unbalanced.

But they play the moments like few can match. None more so than Vinicius. The prematch tifo that read “Stop crying your heart out” alongside an image of Rodri kissing the Balon d’Or came back to bite the City fans.

It may have been a slight on Vinicius and Real but it only served to fire them on. Real’s No.7 had a storming game and was instrumental to both of their late goals.

“I saw it — I saw the banner, but whenever the opposing fans do things like that, they give me more strength to have a great game, and here I have done it,” said the forward. “They know our history, everything we do in this competition.” City have a lesson to learn.