
Bukayo Saka should have been the unbridled shining light after Arsenal beat Fulham 2-1. But in keeping with the team's season, they lost a player who matters just as much to the success of the side.
While Saka stands out on their lineups, the outstanding aspect of the Gunners is not their firepower in the final third. At the other end of the pitch, the defensive line is on track to be the tightest rearguard for the second season in a row, conceding two fewer goals than runaway league leaders Liverpool.
At the heart of that unit is Gabriel Magalhaes. The Brazilian, a bedrock in his prime years, has been one of their best players this campaign. Is there any way the team can compensate for his absence?
-
How did Gabriel’s injury unfold?
The first sight of discomfort for Gabriel was only twelve minutes into the game at the Emirates Stadium on Tuesday night. He clutched the back of his leg, looking to be in severe pain, and had to limp across the edge of his penalty area for a further two minutes to see off danger from Fulham.
Once the play paused, the defender was in no fit state to stay on the field. He headed straight down the tunnel and Mikel Arteta announced in his post-match press conference the Brazilian "felt something in his hamstring." Less than 48 hours later, the club confirmed the worst fears of the fans. Gabriel will have to undergo surgery on the injury and is set to sit on the sidelines for the rest of this season.
This blow to the Brazilian marks the fourth major hamstring injury to afflict Arsenal this campaign.
The victory on Tuesday saw Saka make his comeback after tearing his hamstring at Crystal Palace in December. Gabriel Martinelli missed a month of action from the start of February, coming off in the first half of the Carabao Cup second leg semi-final at Newcastle United. Kai Havertz accompanies Gabriel as an absentee for the rest of the season, picking up his injury when the squad was in Dubai.
At least Arteta can now pick two of his main attackers and has also engineered a solution to the striker shortage with Mikel Merino. But the injury to Gabriel has come at the worst time for the back four.
-
A dearth of deputies
Though the 27-year-old is a major miss, the situation is much more serious due to other absentees.
Less than a quarter of an hour after the Brazilian bowed out of the clash, Jurrien Timber took a blow to his knee. He endured the struggle to last until the second half but could not complete the final fifteen minutes of the game and Arteta said "there's a chance" that he could play on the weekend.
The same hesitation applied to the availability of Ben White. The right back has been building his sharpness after knee surgery as a member of most matchday squads over the last six weeks. But he was missing from the group earlier this week with a niggle and his health is in doubt once more.
Neither White nor Timber is a left central defender, but both are trusted pieces in the defensive unit. The natural candidates to fill in for the Brazilian are players who have struggled for form and fitness.
Riccardo Calafiori will not be able to play away at Everton. The Italian has not thrived in his first season of English football, falling foul of a series of knocks. For now, he is missing from the squad due to a knee injury he picked up in injury time during a 2-1 loss to Germany on international duty.
The other possible replacement, who came on for Gabriel in the last league match, was the man most likely to deputize for him. Jakub Kiwior had a significant spell at the start of 2024 as a left back, but Arteta has mostly asked him to try and plug holes across the back four. That versatility is useful, but a tally of 382 league minutes this season shows how he is typically an option only as a last resort.
-
Angel Gabriel: an irreplaceable guardian?
No one can replicate what Gabriel gives the team as the rock in the back four. He has cleaned up the erraticism from his game to turn into a highly reliable partner for William Saliba and also has much better ball playing attributes than some have seen in his game. Moreover, his leadership, aerial ability, and rugged style make him better than the Frenchman at the rough and tumble of defensive duties.
Arsenal are four points ahead of Nottingham Forest and should stay in the top four of the Premier League table. But all eyes are on the two legs of the quarter-final with Real Madrid. Against an elite outfit, Arteta has to take all the lessons from the squad's injury crises to try and engineer a solution.
There is a small chance that Arteta could use the other 'captain without the armband' in the squad to step in for the Brazilian. Declan Rice was a central defender in his youth days and played in the position away at PSV in the final Champions League group stage game of the 2023/24 season.
However, he might be wary of innovating too much. No matter what he does, the defence will not be at its best, so is it worth pulling apart the midfield to try and repair it? A deeper role for Rice would mean moving both Jorginho or Mikel Merino into the middle of the park, sacrificing his engine.
On the other hand, if Kiwior continues as part of the team, Arsenal are at risk of repeating history. A year ago, at the same stage of the Champions League, Leroy Sane stormed down the right wing and had a critical part in both legs as Bayern Munich booked a spot in the final four of the competition.
There is no way around it: Gabriel will be a massive miss. As the Arsenal attack has waned in output, his headers from set-pieces pointed the way forward. When the team has been in troubled times (of which there will be plenty against a club like Los Blancos) the defender has demonstrated he is ready for the fight. The irony is this tie would have been the best way to appreciate his presence.
Instead, his class will be clear in his absence. Just like with Saka, fans will pray angel Gabriel gets back to full fitness soon— and does not cause the club an additional headache in the summer window.

