
Sunderland have gone above and beyond in the market this summer to overcome the supposed gulf between the Championship and the Premier League.
14 signings added to Sunderland’s books and more money splashed out on incomings than any of the previous promoted sides before them upon entering the top flight.
This sheer quantity signifies ambition to strive for stability in the Premier League after an eight-year absence, rather than settling for inevitable shortfalls and attributing them to explicit disadvantages.
Two victories from their opening three Premier League games at the Stadium of Light suggest the project is coming into fruition while integrating the sea of arrivals remains a significant task.
The youngest squad in the Championship last term has undergone a major revamp and The Black Cats have done due diligence in an unprecedented transfer spree to give them every shot at staying up.
Their business is a very strong facilitator of achieving that objective, one that should not be deemed outlandish by any means.
However, Sunderland’s tactical approach, Regis Le Bris’ personnel dilemma, consistency, and failing to instill core principles which permeate through the newly-fledged squad could equally be prohibitive to their progress.
So, dissecting the quality of their recruitment model is significant to avoid getting caught up in their glaringly soaring expenditure figure and incomings.
It remains to be seen what heights Regis Le Bris can take this Sunderland team to, but their ceiling is far greater than the promoted sides that have come and have been conquered before them.
-
New attackers enabling adaptability
Although a cast of youngsters ultimately delivered the elusive play-off triumph at Wembley, the prospect of Premier League football seems to elicit a shift in the types of profiles a club should search for in the market.
At first, the signings of Chemsdine Talbi and Simon Adringra turned heads since they went against that sentiment at the beginning of the window.
Talbi joined from Belgian side Club Brugge fresh from Champions League football and he was handed regular minutes from the wing as a teenager in the league.
While Adingra cast a light on Sunderland perhaps not veering from their preferences to recruit younger players when he penned a contract to sign for The Black Cats from Brighton, as Yankuba Minteh and Kaoru Mitoma threatened a consistent place under Fabian Hurzeler.
These moves materialised quite early in the window considering the moves for Bertrand Traore and Brian Brobbey from Ajax were ratified on Deadline Day.
Traore adds strength in depth in the wing department and he was sought-after for versatility and to provide an alternative style to the aforementioned Talbi and Adringra.
The 29-year-old has Premier League experience under his belt from his time at Aston Villa and arrives on a one-year contract with an option for an additional year.
A bold stamp of Sunderland pursuing results for the immediate and short-term.
He featured alongside striker Brian Brobbey for the Dutch giants who followed suit to Wearside.
The 23-year-old Netherlands international had been earmarked by Sunderland chiefs prior to speculation emerging in the eleventh hour.
He has notched several goals at his boyhood club and had his sights set on embarking on a new challenge.
Not only was it his personal push for the transfer, but Sunderland encountered a dramatic twist on deadline day which provoked their decision over Brobbey.
Marc Guiu had to be called back from his loan at Sunderland to parent club Chelsea who had to find an instantaneous solution to Nicolas Jackson’s departure as Liam Delap sustained an injury.
Brobbey may oust Wilson Isidor and Eliezer Mayenda not least diminish their minutes, though both remain fundamental components to Le Bris’ plans.
What these acquisitions demonstrate is a willingness to approach games in different ways and to have the tools necessary to accommodate for varying demands, whether that be transitional play or prolonged possession.
Le Bris will be able to deploy certain players depending on what the game needs.
That is also an asset which could intensify expectations over what can be achieved with this crop of attackers.
-
Well-oiled midfield machine
The Sunderland faithful had been accustomed to seeing Dan Neil and Chris Rigg in the midfield in the second division.
It was always time for transformative upgrades but Sunderland fans perhaps had little inklings over what names would be brought in.
Senegal international Habib Diarra became the club’s record signing as The Black Cats spent £30 million to prise his transfer from French side Strasbourg.
Meanwhile, central midfielder Noah Sadiki joined from Union Saint-Gilloise, who won the Belgian league title for the first time in almost a century.
Sadiki’s move exemplifies the Premier League’s superior appeal, since the chances of Union Saint-Gilloise retaining him were heightened when they were granted a historic Champions League spot.
A 21 and 20-year-old respectively to entirely change the midfield and already Diarra has received raving reviews from his opening outings, together with Sadiki who has played every minute of Premier League action so far.
Both are young but with considerable experience behind them domestically for several campaigns.
Meanwhile, Diarra in particular has been able to roam further forward by virtue of Sunderland’s marquee signing of the window.
-
Signing of the summer: Granit Xhaka
The Switzerland international has returned to the Premier League and opted for Sunderland as his destination.
A turbulent spell at Arsenal turned on its head when he became expressive under Mikel Arteta and developed into a vastly different player.
Two seasons at Bayer Leverkusen then brought out the best of Xhaka, and Leverkusen went unbeaten to dethrone Bayern Munich in his first campaign under Xabi Alonso.
Upon arriving in the North East, Xhaka was handed the responsibility of taking over as captain.
His traditional leadership qualities were at the forefront of that verdict but also Xhaka’s ability to lead by example on the pitch rendered the captaincy undoubtedly suited to him.
He is an experienced figure in the dressing room who has witnessed all the game has to offer, from mounting pressure to lifting major silverware.
He has many strings to his bow as a midfielder from aggressive tackling to pinpoint crosses, and eye-catching shots from range have always been another facet of his game.
Xhaka already ranks third highest in the number of successful final third passes completed from the opening three league matches which elucidates his quality in-possession.
Often, he was prone to stepping over the edge with reckless infringements for his previous clubs but completely neglecting that quite inherent trait would surely be costly to his performance.
Xhaka has matured and excelled as his career has progressed beyond a lot of expectations.
This next step in his journey is an incredible opportunity to steer Sunderland away from relegation and is ultimately the club’s most shrewd piece of business, and one of the best signings throughout the Premier League this summer.
It is enterprising and he will be the cornerstone to Sunderland’s ambitions.
-
Defensive overhaul and prodigy goalkeeper
Sunderland refrained from forking out significant sums for full-backs this summer as left-backs Arthur Masuaku and Reinildo Mandava both signed for Sunderland as free transfers.
Both 31-years-old and offer two assured options for Le Bris, who can rely on experienced personnel to guide the team much more than last season.
Lutsharel Geertruida had several keen admirers around Europe while Nottingham Forest seemed the closest to snapping up the right-back from RB Leipzig with Monday’s deadline day looming.
However, Sunderland proposed an attractive offer for the offloading club and the individual, which secured a loan for the Dutchman, as competitors Forest walked away.
Nordi Mukiele was the lone defensive acquisition by which Sunderland had to empty their pockets for as they paid £12 million to Champions League winners PSG to tie him down.
Still, calls for a centre-back circulated despite Paraguayan international Omar Alderete arriving from Getafe.
The only missing piece of the puzzle seemed to be Jhon Lucumi from Bologna, though Sunderland missed the boat as the Italians were able to retain their stalwart.
Perhaps this was the only caveat to their successful business, especially with Dan Ballard ruled out with injury in the coming weeks.
Sunderland also delved into unknown territory by signing goalkeeper Robin Roefs from Dutch top-flight side NEC Nijmegen.
His penalty save against Brentford only boosted his confidence while he earned a first senior call-up to the Netherlands for the upcoming international break.
This speaks volumes of the 22-year-old who has been rewarded for his impressive displays for his nation’s Under-21s in the European Championships in the summer.
Netherlands bowed out to England in the semi-finals courtesy of Harvey Elliot’s brace, but Roefs was lauded for his quarter-final performance against Portugal when he kept a clean sheet despite his side going down to ten men early on.
Certainly, it was a tournament which put many into the shop window for their senior national teams and at club level. Roefs has evidently been one of those beneficiaries.
A reliable goalkeeper will be critical for Sunderland’s fortunes this season, and all Roefs needs to do is ensure he continues to perform.
He looks to be a stable number one between the sticks, while homegrown Anthony Paterson will make way.
-
Outgoings: Recouping funds and appropriate loan deals
Shortly after winning promotion, Sunderland were praised for their endeavours in the market regarding two key departures which supplemented their revenue generated from play-off glory.
Teenage midfielder Jobe Bellingham was swiftly picked up by Borussia Dortmund, following in his brother Jude Bellingham’s footsteps for just shy of £27 million.
While Tommy Watson’s move to Brighton for a fee of £10 million had been finalised weeks before the play-off final at Wembley, where he came off the bench and scored the all-important winner in a scintillating comeback.
There were clearly profits to reinvest and substantial revenue to utilise. It warranted seismic spending.
What accompanies that opportunity, however, is the consideration of how to attend to players who will inevitably fall out of favour once higher calibre signings are introduced.
Sunderland did well to offload players on loan to prevent resentment within the squad due to lack of playing time.
Jenson Seelt secured a move to Wolfsburg on loan and stalwart right midfielder Patrick Roberts was also given the green light for a loan deal as he made the switch to Birmingham City, returning to the Championship.
They left it late to get both over the line but recruiting all the new faces seemed the prerequisite to letting both go.
Marc Guiu was also unexpectedly called back by Chelsea amid their late striker mishap, and Sunderland reacted promptly in the market to replace him.
-
New contracts, including Regis Le Bris
The Sunderland head coach Regis Le Bris committed his future to another three years at the club.
Following his successes in the Championship, the club are willing to support Le Bris at the helm and evidently see him as the man to guide them to stability.
It is his first managerial post in the Premier League while recruiting right-hand man Luciano Vulcano to assist him in the coaching team will provide crucial advice.
His credentials principally at clubs in Serie A will aid decisions over refinement and navigating the best way to stay clear from the drop zone.
18-year-old Chris Rigg made 45 appearances last season and signed a new deal until 2030 at the club.
While Trai Hume extended his stay, and longest-serving player Luke O’Nien signed a new two-year contract with the club.
His fidelity to the Sunderland project and unrivalled passion for the club makes him an essential leader and simultaneously swells Le Bris’ defensive options.
-
Does stability simply boil down to recruitment?
Their business in the summer transfer window, from incomings and outgoings to players retained, will undoubtedly induce optimism for the campaign ahead.
What threatens to dampen the mood is the ruthlessness of Premier League football whereby transfers alone, especially for the promoted sides, won’t always convert to meaningful results.
The manager’s approach to each game and decisions over which players are best fit for the opposition sit at the forefront of reaching their objectives.
Many say there will be little excuse for Sunderland to at least be competing with certain teams like Brentford, Wolves, and West Ham United let alone their promoted counterparts.
However, if Regis Le Bris is unable to figure out what is required and get the new signings aligned with an effective system and mentality, this lavish spending will ultimately be futile and put Le Bris’ job in jeopardy.
The Sunderland boss has spoken countless times over the influence of the Stadium of Light and how utilising fine margins like the home advantage will allow them to put crucial points on the board.
It is difficult to see their squad on paper languishing or even make the club recede and be forced to start all over again from the Championship, despite parachute payments.
They have the minerals to buck the trend since they ultimately led the way this summer in their business. They have laid the groundwork to the best of their abilities.
If Sunderland are unable to stay up, it would be attributed to a collection of mistakes aside from their initial recruitment.
Ultimately, out of the three promoted sides they have spent the most and now boast the most quality in their ranks.
So, if they were unable to stay afloat, it may also further expose a disparity between the divisions that is so difficult to surmount, despite Sunderland pulling out all the preparatory stops.

