With just one shot on target for both teams combined in the whole game (it came from Pape Sarr in the first half), it certainly wasn’t a classic, but, an important three points in the UEFA Champions League league-phase for Spurs, nonetheless.
Let’s analyse how the Tottenham Hotspur players fared in this UEFA Champions League encounter.
Guglielmo Vicario - 7
The Italian shot-stopper remained composed and assured in his performance against Villarreal, helping Tottenham keep a clean sheet. Despite limited action, he looked organised, communicated well with his defence, and made sure his positioning, especially acting as a ‘sweeper-keeper’, frustrated the Villarreal attackers; they couldn’t manage a single shot on target. Four clean sheets in five games this season for Vicario, just one goal conceded. The Spurs defensive unit will be looking to keep up this defensive form.
Pedro Porro - 7
The Spaniard has had a strong start to the season, especially in regard to discipline and keeping his cool in defensive situations, i.e. not diving into challenges as often as he may have in previous seasons. However, Porro was beaten a few times down Villarreal’s left-hand side by the speedy Villarreal Tajon Buchanan, but did complete 86% of attempted passes and had a 100% tackle success rate.
Cristian Romero - 7
The World Cup winner showcased the leadership and aggression that made him an ever-present (when fit) under Postecoglou in 24/25. From the outset, he set the tone with sharp positioning and timely interventions, repeatedly stepping in to challenges to cut out danger before it developed. A mature, assured display from the defender; continuing the strong start to the season he and his side have had.
Micky Van De Ven - 7
With just one goal conceded in Spurs’ first five matches in all competitions this season (bar the UEFA Super Cup final), it’s no secret that Van De Ven and Romero’s partnership is as strong as it’s ever been. The Dutchman did have a nervy moment late in the second half when he brought down Georgian international Mikautadze, but was fortunately (for him) shown a yellow card for the challenge. Four clean sheets from five games - a solid start to say the least.
Djed Spence - 7
The newly capped England international impressed with a lively and disciplined performance at left-back. He balanced his defensive duties well with attacking intent, making several overlapping runs that stretched the Villarreal right back, especially with Simons coming inside so regularly. Defensively, he stayed switched on, making a few key tackles and recovering well when caught high up the pitch, with his pace always making him a real asset in the team. With Udogie now back fit, Spence will be looking to keep his place in the side going forward - good options in the full-back areas (Porro, Spence and Udogie) that Spurs have got, for sure.
Rodrigo Bentancur - 7
The Uruguayan dictated the tempo of the game brilliantly and was always available to receive the ball and recycle possession under pressure. His ability to turn away from markers and find progressive passes helped Spurs transition quickly and control the game for long spells. Defensively, he was alert and proactive and worked so well alongside Bergvall and Sarr, who are both in fine form themselves. Bentancur was a key figure in a Spurs midfield that dominated on the night (58% possession and 414 total passes completed).
Pape Sarr - 6
Sarr’s athleticism has shone through this season in Thomas Frank’s new system, and again on the night, his constant pressing and tracking of off-the-ball runners worked effectively for Spurs, disrupting any sort of Villarreal momentum. On the ball, he was tidy and purposeful, keeping possession moving and linking play well with the attackers. He also made a few surging runs forward, adding dynamism to Spurs’ midfield. Another strong performance in the 23-year-old's development.
Lucas Bergvall - 7
Bergvall was at the centre of most good things for Spurs on the night, and played a key role in the winning goal as his attempted cross was, unluckily, diverted into his own net by Villarreal’s goalkeeper. The young Swede’s ability on the ball shone through once again, after a brilliant performance at West Ham on Saturday in which he received the player of the match award, he received the award once again this Tuesday night. A fine UEFA Champions League debut. One of the first names on the team sheet at the moment, for sure.
Mohammed Kudus - 7
Mo Kudus was tidy on his UEFA Champions League debut with Spurs, demonstrating good passing accuracy and attempting a few dangerous crosses that kept the opposition cautious. He also worked hard defensively, pressing and recovering possession when Spurs needed to calm the pressure, and showed intelligent movement off the ball when Spurs were in attacking areas. However, like other players in the side on the night, the Ghanaian lacked a little bit of end product in the final ball. A good start to his Spurs career, overall.
Richarlison - 6
The striker was put back in the side after being on the bench at the weekend against West Ham, and didn’t offer too much off the ball for Spurs. A nuisance for the defenders, sure, but as mentioned previously in this piece, the whole side didn’t show lots of attacking intent in the game, with just one shot on target in the entirety of the match. Richarlison will be hoping to start Tottenham’s next match against Brighton, where Spurs might have three fit strikers available for the first time this season (Richarlison, Kolo Muani and Solanke).
Xavi Simons - 6
Spurs’ £51.8m summer signing started on the left-hand side again as he did against West Ham on Saturday, and looked a little ineffective. The 22-year-old did flash a fierce long-range volley over the bar just two minutes in to the game, but often found himself receiving the ball a bit too deep. He did have a nervy moment in the second half where a risky tackle nearly earned him a second yellow card, but all in all, there are definitely positive signs for Simons early in his Spurs career.
Subs:
Destiny Udogie - 6
Udogie played 21 minutes as he continued to come back to full match fitness after a big injury at the back end of last season, and he looked sharp. The Italian ensured that Spurs saw out the win with a clean sheet.
Joao Palhinha - 6
Palhinha also played 21 minutes and did the dirty work in midfield, as usual. Committing two fouls, the Portuguese international was a little rash but his defensive nous helped the team gain a vital three points in their first game.
Brennan Johnson - N/A
Johnson played on the left-hand side with 13 minutes left to play and made no meaningful contribution.
Randal Kolo Muani - N/A
Kolo Muani came on with 13 minutes to go and was booked for a mis-timed challenge, but made no noticeable contributions in the match. These minutes were the Frenchman’s first for his new club, on loan from last season’s UEFA Champions League winners, PSG.
Kevin Danso - N/A
Danso played just one minute of the match.




