Top to bottom: What has gone wrong at Bournemouth?
Marcos Senesi after the 1-1 draw against Burnley, a 90th minute equaliser earning a point for the visitors. (Photo by Robin Jones - AFC Bournemouth/AFC Bournemouth via Getty Images)

After beating Nottingham Forest 2-0 with goals from Marcus Tavernier and Eli Junior Kroupi in October, the Cherries sat second in the Premier League and had not lost since the opening game of the season, going eight games without defeat.

Fans were dreaming once again of European football, full of praise for the new summer recruits, and enjoying “Iraolaball” for another season.

New owner, Bill Foley, announced the club would be operating under a new motto: “Always advance, never retreat.”

But nine games on, the picture is very different.

Now, following a heavy 4-1 defeat to Brentford, Bournemouth sit 15th and have not been able to find a win in that time contributing to a total collapse in the mood around the club, and suggesting that “retreat” is not off the table just yet.

But what has led to this free fall and can they rediscover their winning ways?

VAVEL goes through the reasons behind the drop in form.

  • Mounting injuries and suspensions

Bournemouth’s poor run of form cannot be attributed to one single cause, with several factors contributing simultaneously.

Since the Cherries’ last win in October, injuries and suspensions have been mounting, leading to a frequently disrupted line-up.

The midfield and defence have been most affected; two areas widely praised prior to the last nine games.

At the back, long-serving figures Marcos Senesi and Adam Smith have been in and out of the side due to persistent minor injuries over recent months.

And in a defence where four of last season’s regular back five have moved on, the absence of familiarity and leadership has had a clear impact on consistency and organisation.

Similar issues have been felt in midfield.

USA captain Tyler Adams has been a revelation since the start of the season, but an injury sustained in the dramatic draw against Manchester United has ruled him out since, with a return not expected before March.

That absence has been compounded by Adams’ yellow-card suspension against Chelsea and the red card Lewis Cook received against Sunderland.

As if that was not enough to create a selection headache for Andoni Iraola, 2024/25’s player of the season, Ryan Christie, has also struggled for fitness, often limited to appearances as a substitute.

New signings Veljko Milosavljevic and Ben Gannon-Doak, both of whom impressed early on, are also currently sidelined, further reducing options both in the starting eleven and from the bench.

With so many players becoming available and unavailable on a week-to-week basis since October, Bournemouth have been forced into constant changes, resulting in confused selections and inconsistency.

  • Unresolved situations

Bournemouth’s commitment issues are no secret and they span on and off the pitch.

Most well-known is Antoine Semenyo’s transfer away from the club, which, as of writing, looks all but complete ahead of a move to Manchester City in January.

But what is more, is the uncertainty, surrounding the contracts of key defender Senesi and Head Coach, Iraola, who are both set to leave come the end of the season.

What effect losing the club’s best player and goal scorer, best current defender, and star manager has on the squad, only the Bournemouth players will know themselves.

However, analysing the situation from the outside it is unlikely to create a harmonious and positive atmosphere.

Rather pessimistically, it begs the question: if the club’s best assets keep leaving, what is the long term strategy?

And this is a fair question to ask from a fanbase who have recently already seen their top assets stripped just six months ago.

Whilst Semenyo and Senesi look set to leave the club, Iraola is famously patient in his approach to contract renewals and that does not look to be changing any time soon.

  • Summer squad changes

Heading into the 2025/26 season, it was a summer of significant upheaval for the Cherries, with no fewer than twelve players departing for a combined total of €238.41m.

Of those exits, five were established first-team regulars, whilst at least three others played peripheral yet meaningful roles within the squad.

Such turnover inevitably placed pressure on recruitment and Bournemouth responded by bringing in seven new players, four of whom now make up the defensive unit.

In any circumstance, that level of change would test any side.

Combined with injuries and the demand for immediate results, there was an expectation that these arrivals would seamlessly replace those who had departed, matching their quality.

That expectation was always unrealistic.

New signings require time and a supportive environment to adapt, both tactically and to the demands of the Premier League.

Milos Kerkez, Dango Ouattara, and Illia Zabarnyi did not excel immediately but went on to become key contributors, underlining the patience often required in such transitions.

Expecting the latest incomings to replicate that impact instantly ignores the difficulty of integrating into an unfamiliar team, particularly one low on confidence and in transition.

Given the club’s recent recruitment record, it is unlikely the new signings will prove to be poor investments.

However, the circumstances they have entered have been far from ideal, both for them and for the team as a whole.

With further arrivals expected in January, there will again be pressure for immediate returns.

That makes getting recruitment decisions right all the more critical, and may prompt reflection on how recruitment is handled in future seasons.

  • Loss of confidence

Nine games without a win takes its toll, even more so when there are some drubbings in between.

The effect of confidence appears to have been lost in this debate but it plays a great role.

Players that once performed like Justin Kluivert and Evanilson, have lost their way.

Alongside this are the new players desperate to show their worth but who are also struggling to pick up the form from earlier in the season.

The once praised Djordje Petrovic, Adrien Truffert, and Bafode Diakite, are now picking up criticism and whilst this is not unwarranted, it is without the backdrop of the whole team underperforming and finding this a difficult period to navigate.

The press is inconsistent, duels are being lost, and mistakes are creeping into the 90 minutes.

It should be of no surprise that the squad are struggling to adapt when everything seems to be going against them.

But there is a way out of this sticky run.

One win can change everything, the newcomers can spark into form, the injury crisis can soften over time, and commitment anxiety can turn into clarity.

All of this we have already seen at Bournemouth over the past few years, so supporters should not be surprised if it happens again.

And if there is one thing Cherries’ fans should have learned over the last 15 years, it is to expect the unexpected.