
German clubs have long had a history of producing talented central defenders, Franz Beckenbauer the most famous with more recent additions of Christoph Metzelder and Mats Hummels. But in an age where the art of defending is dying, there looked to be another addition to that list; until a horror challenge in the Winter of 2012 put an end to any such suggestion for the foreseeable future.
Born in March 1989, Holger Badstuber quickly progressed quickly through the Bayern Munich youth system, making his first team debut in 2009 along with other academy graduate, Thomas Müller. The young German defender born in Memmingen quickly became a regular in the Bayern eleven and was even selected in Joachim Löw's 2010 World Cup squad.
Louis Van Gaal then Bayern manager described him as “the best left-footed defender in World football”. As a result of his good form, in the summer of 2010, Badstuber was rewarded with a contract extension until 2014.
Over the coming years Badstuber became a crucial part of the Bayern defence, seeing off experienced professionals such as Martin Demichellis and Lucio. It was certainly a quick rise to fame for the young defender, but he didn’t let it get to his head. Bayern fan, Maldeika on the Bluemoon forum described his introduction, “Badstuber had less bad matches in this season than most older players like Micho or van Buyten had. He showed a lot more eagerness to work and learn. It just made real fun to see him in the team”.
However, things would take a drastic turn for the worse in December of 2012, in a DFB Pokal match against Borussia Dortmund at the Allianz Arena. A fairly innocuous challenge with Mario Götze left the Bayern defender with a cruciate rupture, which would see him out until the next summer.
Just when it looked as if Badstuber would be returning to first team action, disaster struck again; he ruptured the same ligaments for a second time. Maldeika again commented, this time on his injuries; “And the injuries - that was just a sad story. Especially when it happened a second time.” The sheer lack of shock, details how unlucky Badstuber has been, perhaps even preventing the defender from a World XI spot such was his form before the injuries.
The defender made his long awaited return at the start of the 2014/15 season, against Preuβen Münster in the DFB Pokal, the same competition in which he originally sustained his injury. Badstuber was quickly reinstated in the Bayern starting eleven; current Bayern boss, Pep Guardiola was full of praise for the returning defender.
Once again, Badstuber’s joy was cut short; it was like a tape on constant repeat, injury after injury, after injury. Early in September, after featuring in the Bavarian’s first 4 games, Badstuber would injure his hamstring and be ruled out until the New Year. You’ve got to admire Badstuber's resilience, after his latest injury he simply put “I will come back, AGAIN!!!”.
This brings us to the current day, around Christmas 2014. Badstuber has resumed light training, and looks to be back for Bayern’s first league match after the Winter break, against VfL Wolfsburg in Lower Saxony. It remains to be seen if Badstuber will this time hold up, and not be struck down once again by injuries; that’d be the last thing for anyone connected with Bayern Munich and German football would want to see. The burgeoning defender looked to have a great career on his hands until his injuries postponed that for the foreseeable future.
However that doesn’t mean all is lost for Badstuber; he still has time on his hands and could easily be added to that list alongside the likes of Beckenbauer and Metzelder. To understand why he is rated so highly by many, you have to look back at his early days in Bavaria.
Coached by Hermann Gerland, the famed trainer at Bayern Munich; Badstuber has long been regarded as one of the biggest prospects in German football, even surpassing the likes of Mats Hummels, who Bayern were quick to get rid of to pave the way for Badstuber.
Badstuber and Hummels have long been friends, ever since their days at Bayern Munich youth academy. From a young age, Gerland described the pair as “the future central defence partnership for the national team”. So you can ask the question, why was Hummels deemed surplus to requirements at the Sabener Straβe? Lack of first team opportunities proved to be enough for Hummels, as he left for Jürgen Klopp’s Borussia Dortmund.
Badstuber has long been known for his cultured style of play, a great passing range has been admired by many including opposition a like. Being able to play at Left back has been a real asset for Holger, who has found himself an integral part of Joachim Löw’s side when fit.
Badstuber’s father has also had a large impact on the defenders game; Hermann worked with numerous clubs in South West German and Thomas Tuchel and Markus Gisdol described him as their mentor. Holger Badstuber definitely had some very special inspirations whilst progressing through the youth ranks of VfB Stuttgart and Bayern Munich; perhaps working with such famed characters instilled his defiant spirit.
When he returns for the third time, he cannot be rushed back into first team action. Something that was aimed at Pep Guardiola after his latest setback in September. Another injury could spell the final end for Badstuber.
If he remains fit there is no doubt that Badstuber could still develop into a superb defender, at either Left back or his natural Central position. He provides something different to most other defenders on the planet, his cultured style suits Pep Guardiola’s philosophy to a tee.
But will he be able to displace such figures as Jerome Boateng, Mehdi Benatia and Javi Martinez?
It’s been a difficult 24 months for Badstuber and it could get worse in the near future, but it’s evident that the Memmingen born defender won’t give in. Whether Badstuber will ever recover to his form pre-injury, is yet to be seen; but if he can get anywhere near that level, he could still yet be added to that famed group of German defenders.

