
ADVERTISEMENT
New York Yankees ace Gerrit Cole was told the dreaded three words no pitcher ever wants to hear: ‘Tommy John surgery’. For some days, it seemed inevitable, but the Yankees confirmed their worst fears on Monday afternoon, announcing that their starting pitcher would undergo surgery the next day. He is now set to miss up to 18 months. He had made a strong start to Spring Training with two starts, the first of which was an impressive outing allowing three hits and one run. His second start against the Minnesota Twins saw him give up six runs, but there were no signs of any health issues. While hit five times, he averaged 95.7mph on his fastball, just a tick less than his average of 95.9mph of last year. Manager Aaron Boone even said he expected Cole to be ready for games one and five of the season, just hours before news emerged that he would be having tests.
It is a devastating blow to Cole and the Yankees, who were looking forward to a healthy year after injury disrupted last season. He started 17 games to end the season with a 3.41 ERA, before a strong postseason. But many felt they had dodged a bullet when Cole avoided elbow surgery, ultimately missing just over three months. This was a scenario the Yankees should have been prepared for.
And indeed they were prepared, signing starter Max Fried to the biggest contract in MLB history for a left-hander (8 years, $218m). It was an immediate pivot from the failed pursuit of Juan Soto, though raised a few eyebrows as the Yankees' shift in direction quickly became clear. After losing a generational offensive talent, their priority became the rotation and bullpen, despite it already being an area of strength. General manager Brian Cashman sold the signing, and each corresponding move, as a focus on defense and run prevention. But perhaps they knew Cole’s elbow was a ticking time bomb and needed another ace as insurance. The Yankees proved it with their actions in the off-season. Cole’s contract included an opt-out clause, voidable if the Yankees added a tenth year. He opted out, but the Yankees did not want to add the extra year. Why? Their reasons may have just played out in front of their eyes. However, Cole did not want to test the open market, and mutually, the Yankees did not want to let him go. So strangely, he opted back into the contract as if nothing ever happened.
Yankees Rotation Still Can be Strong, Despite Cole’s Irreplaceability
There is no doubt about it - Gerrit Cole is irreplaceable. His last appearance of the playoffs was the ill-fated game five of the World Series, in which he pitched dominantly until the infamous fifth inning. In fact, he should have left the inning with the lead well intact, but was let down by his defense. He is also less than two years removed from his first Cy Young award. He is one of the best pitchers in the game and his absence will hurt the Yankees. But while this may be the case, the rotation still has the potential to be strong this year.
The signing of Fried gives the side a ready-made ace to assume the responsibility on Opening Day. The former Atlanta Braves pitcher boasts the lowest ERA of any qualified starter since the 2020 season (2.81). Carlos Rodon and Clarke Schmidt had solid 2024 seasons, though the latter suffered with a lat strain, which cost him significant time. The same injury currently sidelines reigning AL Rookie of the Year, Luis Gil, causing him to miss a large portion of the upcoming season—another bitter blow. His return is expected sometime in the second half of the season, however. Added pressure now weighs on Rodon, entering year three of his six-year, $162 million contract. Schmidt’s back issue delays his pre-season preparations; he is set to start the sixth game of the season.
This means an extended opportunity for Marcus Stroman, who was largely expected to be traded prior to the season to lower payroll, but is now set to play an important role. The rotation is likely to be rounded out by rookie Will Warren, who struggled in limited spot starts last season, but has shown great promise so far in Spring Training, much like how Gil did last season, who ultimately minimised the impact of Cole’s absence.
There will be question marks, but the potential is still there. Stroman did not pitch an inning in the playoffs, but can be a serviceable member of the rotation. He enjoyed a good first half of last season, before being largely let down by the defense behind him, an infield and outfield that has been much improved in the last few months. A playoff rotation will be shortened, and will include Fried, Rodon, Schmidt and Gil.
Injuries are the biggest factor to consider. Fried, Rodon and Schmidt are not exactly beacons of health. It means their unreliable depth is likely to be tested, with 37-year-old veteran Carlos Carrasco currently projected as the sixth starter. There is little wiggle room in a thinning pitching department. Insurance on Cole’s contract means the Yankees have a bit more money to play with, but will owner Hal Steinbrenner utilise it? The options on the free agent market have dwindled, though the likes of Patrick Corbin, Lance Lynn and Kyle Gibson remain available.
The trade market could be a realistic avenue, with Miami Marlins starter Sandy Alcantara a linked name. San Diego Padres’ Dylan Cease was reportedly available, but it is unlikely the Yankees have the assets available to attain the pitcher with prospects Jasson Dominguez, Spencer Jones and George Lombard Jr almost certainly off limits. A call to the St Louis Cardinals for Erick Fedde, perhaps? Regardless of where they go, it would be wrong to declare the Yankees’ season dead, especially in a weaker American League. Their standing as the best may have diminished, and questions on offense remain, but they still have the talent to remain competitive, spearheaded by MVP Aaron Judge, who just produced one of the greatest seasons by a right-handed hitter in MLB history.
Aside from the team outlook, it will be a great shame to watch the Yankees’ season play out without Cole. A master at his craft and undeniably popular with both fans and his teammates alike. He will still be a crucial figure behind the scenes, providing a source of wisdom for his fellow pitchers. A return in mid-2026 appears to be the timeline, a long layoff, but do not count out Cole from coming back strong.
Explore more stats, standings and news on VAVEL Data: New York Yankees
ADVERTISEMENT

