Getty: Clive Brunskill

Was this Everton, or was it Burnley? This was a performance dripping in sweat, containing spirit, plenty of energy and a strong defensive base — qualities that haven’t been seen too frequently at Everton in recent times. Crucially, it also brought about a victory, which was Everton’s first since October 22.

The winning goal, arriving on the hour, was crafted in Burnley too. Sean Dyche, Everton’s new manager who spent a decade at Turf Moor before being sacked last April, played his cards right on his first day on the job and will have taken pleasure in James Tarkowski heading home Dwight McNeil’s corner in the game’s key moment.

The shock was that this all came against the Premier League leaders who had been unbeaten since September and only lost once in the league all season long. Arsenal were sub-par at a stadium where they have failed to win since 2017 and suddenly looked vulnerable at the top of the table.

Mikel Arteta’s team still harbour a five-point lead but that could be cut down to two when second-placed Manchester City travel to Tottenham Hotspur on Sunday.

For Everton, this precious triumph lifted them out of the relegation zone but, most importantly, will provide belief that they can still compete at this level. A new manager bounce this may have been, but subtle changes that bode well were also clear. Notably, the togetherness which Dyche has called for since walking into this dysfunctional club on Monday.

The challenge now is to perform in such a manner consistently. Dyche takes his new team to Liverpool next Monday before hosting Leeds United a week later. A back-to-basics approach is what Everton have needed and what Dyche will offer.

Story of the game

Ahead of kick-off it was difficult to think of two clubs and two sets of fans at such opposite ends of the scale for happiness and positivity than those of Everton and Arsenal. Everton fans’ discontent with the club’s board — absent again due to perceived safety threats — will not die irrespective of any upturn on the pitch.

Getty: Clive Brunskill

A slow peaceful protest march was performed before the game. Everton failed to sign a single player during a winter transfer window that seemed to pass the club by, leaving Dyche to make do and mend with the current squad.

Meanwhile, Arsenal are in the mix for a first title since 2003/04 and have added one or two experienced heads during the past month in an attempt to provide the final missing pieces to their squad. Jorginho, signed for £12m from Chelsea, started as a substitute with Arteta sticking with his first-choice league line-up.

Dyche, back managing in the Premier League after leaving Burnley 10 months ago, made two changes to the Everton team that lost to West Ham United and brought Frank Lampard’s tenure to an end two weeks ago.

The inclusion of McNeil over leading scorer Demarai Gray suggested the order was to feed Dominic Calvert-Lewin with plenty of crosses. Abdoulaye Doucoure was also back having previously been out-of-favour. 

The new Everton manager didn’t dress up the task ahead but echoed his pre-match call for unity around the club in his programme notes, writing: “It’s a big challenge ahead, but one we are ready and eager to take on. The key to doing that must start with a basic principle of what Everton Football Club has always been about: hard work.”

The stadium PA played “All Together Now” in a further message ahead of kick-off and the home team set to work in preventing Arsenal from finding their rhythm and the home crowd backed them to the tilt. Dyche’s 4-5-1 unit frustrated the visitors, with the wide players doubling up on Arsenal’s wingers to good effect.

Getty: Daniel Chesterton

Arsenal’s only meaningful chances in the first half hour were a Thomas Partey shot straight at Jordan Pickford and Eddie Nketiah blasting wide after twisting away from Vitalii Mykolenko. Everton grew into the game, three corners in quick succession caused the visitors problems and Calvert-Lewin brought a low save out of Aaron Ramsdale from a narrow angle.

The Dyche era should have had it’s first goal when, in the 33rd minute, Amadou Onana broke down the left and pulled the ball back for Calvert-Lewin. However, the outstretched striker couldn’t get enough purchase to force the ball into an open goal. Doucoure also glanced a header wide from a McNeil cross as the Goodison Park crowd liked what they saw from their team.

Calvert-Lewin also spurned a good headed chance after Seamus Coleman delivered late in the half. Arsenal equally could have gone in at the break ahead when Bukayo Saka met a cross from the left with a controlled volley that sent the ball running to the far corner of the goal only for Conor Coady to clear off the line.

Everton continued to carry a threat after the interval. Idrissa Gueye struck a shot from the edge of the area which took a deflection, wrong-footing Rasmdale, who readjusted well to palm the ball away. At the other end, Martin Odegaard lofted an Nketiah centre over.

Then the deadlock was broken as two former Burnley players combined on the hour. McNeil’s corner kick was swung into the area and Tarkowski forced his way in at the back post. The centre-back sent a header back across Ramsdale for his first Everton goal since joining in the summer. It was nothing more than the hosts deserved.

Getty: Daniel Chesterton

It was now a case of whether Everton, who have dropped the second-most amount of points from winning positions in the league this term, could hold on for the final 30 minutes. Arteta sent on new signings Leandro Trossard and Jorginho, and the former quickly forced Pickford into a reactive save with a driven shot.

But Arteta’s team were running out of ideas. Oleksandr Zinchenko arrowing a shot into the stands from distance the latest evidence of this not being Arsenal’s day. For Everton and Dyche, they will hope this is the launchpad they so desperately need in their relegation fight.

Player of the match: Dwight McNeil

The winger was brought back into the team by his former Burnley manager and, arguably, produced the best afternoon’s work of his Everton career so far. Clearly, his orders were to serve Calvert-Lewin and there were plenty of crosses into the Arsenal area from the right flank. However, it was McNeil’s delivery from a corner-kick which proved most fruitful; Tarkowski heading home the winner.

McNeil was also instrumental in Everton’s defensive efforts. Dyche lined Everton up in a 4-5-1 without the ball and both wide players assisted the full-backs in limiting the impact of Arsenal’s wingers.