How do Everton solve their right back problem?
Ashley Young exits the pitch after his red card against Brighton (Photo: Carl Racine/GETTY Images)

Everton's loss to Brighton & Hove Albion at Goodison Park was a disastrous opening day for the blues.

However, it was made much worse by Ashley Young's sending off in the 66th minute for a foul on Kaoru Mitoma as it means the Englishman will serve a three game suspension.

This means that Everton are without a fit right back for the next three matches at the very least whilst Young serves his ban.

Seamus Coleman and Nathan Patterson, Everton's two other right-backs, are both still out due to their respective injuries with no news available from Sean Dyche on when they will both return.

James Garner, who played right-back during England u21's Euro Championships win, may have served as a contingency plan for the blues if a situation like this were to ever arise - however, he is also injured with no news on a return date.

So, who will Dyche rely upon to play right-back against Tottenham on Saturday and whilst Young serves his suspension, what are the Everton manager's options?

  • Trust in his players

Amongst Everton's ranks, there is one player who is very familiar with the role of right-back having played there numerous times across his career.

Mason Holgate has returned to Everton this summer after two unsuccessful loan spells at Southampton and Sheffield United, where he suffered 5-0 defeats in both of his debuts for each club.

The defender, who has been at the Toffees since 2015, failed to lock down a starting place for Russell Martin's promotion winning Southampton side in the first four months of the season, before being a part of the worst defence in Premier League history with Sheffield United for the second half of the season.

He was brought on after Everton were reduced to 10 men in their Premier League opener, however his substitution was met with boos by the Goodison faithful and was followed by a mass stadium exodus.

This suggests that Everton fans would not want to see Holgate start at right-back in Young's absence, but due to his experience which Dyche clearly values, he is the most likely replacement for the right-back position.

  • Place faith in the academy

Everton's preparations for the 2024/25 season involved five pre-season matches, where Dyche gave numerous valuable minutes to many promising academy players. 

One player who shined during these games was Roman Dixon, a 19-year-old right-back who has 70 appearances for Everton's academy at u18 and u21 levels. 

Dixon started a 3-1 win for Everton u21s away at Tranmere in the Bristol Street Motors Trophy alongside first team members, Beto and Jesper Lindstrøm, who were playing for match fitness.

The youngster was left out of Everton u21s' match against Chelsea on Friday night, all but confirming that he will be in the squad for the Toffees' trip to Tottenham.

There is one question mark around Dixon, however, and that is whether he is ready for first team action yet as he has never made a first team appearance for the club.

Throwing him straight into the deep end against Tottenham on Saturday would be a huge risk from Dyche and whilst it may backfire, a fresh face to the first team set up would be welcomed with there being every chance that he could succeed.

  • Dive into the Transfer Market

This summer transfer window has been another frustrating one for the Toffees.

Despite turning in an overall profit mainly from the sale of Amadou Onana to Aston Villa, looming PSR complications have made it hard for Everton to spend.

Whilst there is no time for a new signing before the Tottenham game, there is an obvious need for a right back to come in as, even with Young available, the blues look especially weak there with two of the three main right-back options being the age of 35 or older.

Kieran Trippier has been a name linked with Everton this week, with David Ornstein reporting on Thursday that the Toffees were interested in the England full back on a season-long loan.

Whilst Trippier is 33 years of age, he would be a very cost-effective option for the Blues on loan, adding international experience and security to an injury-ravaged backline.

Other names which Everton could look at include Kyle Walker-Peters, whose contract expires next summer meaning he could be available at a cut-price, or Tottenham's Djed Spence, who has struggled to break into the starting 11 at Spurs and may be available on a loan.