Everton Season Review 2023/24
LIVERPOOL, ENGLAND - APRIL 24: Everton striker Dominic Calvert-Lewin celebrates his goal in the Merseyside Derby (Photo by Tony McArdle/Everton FC via Getty Images)

Everton's 2023/24 season started with a familiar uncertainty surrounding the club. 

The Toffees had survived relegation by the skin of their teeth in the season prior finishing in 17th, just two points from the drop zone above Leicester.

However, with the appointment of Sean Dyche as the clubs new manager back in January 2023 there was room for plenty of optimism.

Dyche's spell at Burnley had shown he knew how to survive in the Premier League and even have his teams fighting for Europe. 

  • Expectations Vs Reality

The season started with the Toffees looking to add quality to their squad with the big money signings of Portuguese strikers Beto and Youssef Chermiti, wing pairing Arnaut Danjuma and Jack Harrison joining on loan and experienced fullback Ashley Young joining on a free transfer.

However, the transfer window ended with big departures for the Blues, midfielder Alex Iwobi signed for fellow Premier League side Fulham for a sum of £22 million and key winger Demarai Gray left the club to join Saudi league side Al Ettifaq. 

Premier League

Everton started the Premier League season in concerning form, with three losses in their opening three games, including a 4-0 thrashing away to Aston Villa.

The Toffees found themselves winless in their first five games with only one point on the board, it was matchday six when their first win came, 3-1 away at Brentford in late September.

On November 17th disaster struck for the club as they were charged with breaching profitability and sustainability rules by the Premier League and docked 10 points in the league leaving them in the relegation zone on just six points. 

The best run of form for Sean Dyche's men came off the back of the deduction, in early December where the Toffees flew up the table with four wins in four games including 3-0 and 2-0 wins at home to Newcastle and Chelsea respectively. 

Things continued to look up for the club going into February, with the previous point deduction of 10 points reduced to six on appeal.

Nonetheless, the Toffees struggle with the Premier League's financial rules was far from over with the club receiving a second deduction of two points in April.

Ultimately, the Toffees home form towards the end of the season solidified their top flight status, with five wins in the last five at Goodison Park and a huge derby day win over bitter rivals Liverpool.

The Blues would finish the season with a 2-1 defeat away to Arsenal, leaving them in 15th place and 14 points from the relegation zone.

After low expectations and a disastrous start to the league alongside losing out on eight points which would have them 12th, it is safe to say it was a relatively successful season. 

Away from the league camera, one of the stronger aspects was the Toffees Carabao Cup run, where they reached the Quarter Finals with 2-1 away wins against Doncaster Rovers and Aston Villa and a 3-0 thrashing of Burnley.

The run eventually came to an end with a thrilling 7-6 penalty shootout loss to Fulham at Goodison Park with the game ending 1-1 in normal time.

The Toffees’ FA Cup run was significantly more underwhelming than their performance in the EFL Cup.

Sean Dyche's men started off with a 1-0 replay win to Crystal Palace after drawing 0-0 at Selhurst Park. 

In the fourth round Everton travelled to fellow Premier League strugglers Luton Town who stunned the Toffees with a 96th minute winner from Cauley Woodrow.

Moment of the season

Merseyside Derby Win 

In a season of ups and downs, Everton fans will certainly remember denting their biggest rivals Premier League title hopes with their first win at home to Liverpool since October 2010. 

Strikes from Dominic Calvert-Lewin and Jarrad Branthwaite saw the Toffees come away with a historic 2-0 win and all but ensured their safety in the league, moving eight points from the relegation zone. 

Other moments include a late Idrissa Gueye winner against Crystal Palace at Selhurst Park in a 3-2 win and a dominating 3-0 display against Newcastle United at home. 

Signing of the season

Ashley Young - Free Transfer

A vital part of any relegation battle in the Premier League is the experienced players in a squad.

Everton's transfer window left little to be desired, consisting of mainly loans, youth signings and free agents but the arrival of Ashley Young on a free from Aston Villa proved to be a shrewd piece of business. 

The English full-back arrived into Sean Dyche's team boasting 15 years of top flight experience, whilst also being a Premier League and Serie A champion with Manchester United and Internazionale  respectively. 

Young made 31 appearances for the Toffees in the Premier League this season and now at the age of 38, the full-back shows no signs of stopping as he looks likely to sign a one year extension before his contract expires this summer. 

The loan signing of winger Jack Harrison also proved to be a tidy signing from Leeds, a deal that Everton may look to turn permanent for the upcoming season. 

Flop of the season

Beto - £21.4m  

A recurring problem for Everton over the past few years has been a below par recruitment system. The summer arrivals were limited yet again this season due to pressure from FFP.

However, Sean Dyche's side still managed to oversee plenty of incomings last summer with a total of £32.2 million spent in the transfer market.

Out of the seven arrivals for Everton only two demanded transfer fees with the signings of Portuguese strikers Beto from Udinese for £21.4 million and Youssef Chermiti from Sporting CP for a fee of £10.8 million. 

Given the greater fee linked to the transfer of Beto and the higher expectations considering his age (26) and experience, it is not a surprise to see why the striker has disappointed this season.

Beto started his career in Merseyside with a goal against Doncaster in the Carabao Cup on his debut. However, it took him until December to score his first Premier League goal and the striker ended the season on an underwhelming three goals in 30 league games. 

Villarreal loanee Arnaut Danjuma also had a tough season at Goodison Park after just one goal in 14 league games and a year plagued with injuries. 

Player of the season

Jarrad Branthwaite

A break out season to remember for the young centre-back, Jarrad Branthwaite proved to Everton fans that he was good enough to aid their hopes for survival. 

After sporadic appearances in the league for Everton since 2020 and a loan to Eredivise side PSV in 2022/23, the 21-year-old had a point to prove this season aiding the Toffees to twelve clean sheets, the second strongest in the division. 

The young centre half also scored three goals which helped his side to five points, with strikes against Tottenham, Brighton and local rivals Liverpool.

Branthwaite's performances this season have now caught the eye of England manager Gareth Southgate and he has been announced in the provisional squad for the European Championships in Germany this summer. 

Goalkeeper Jordan Pickford also deserves a special mention with the 30 year old playing every Premier League minute and keeping all of Everton's 13 clean sheets.  

Expectations for next season

Saying Goodbye to Goodison

The 24/25 season will be one which holds great sentimental value to Evertonians should the club continue on last seasons trajectory.

The Toffees will be bidding farewell to Goodison Park, a stadium that they have called home for a whopping 131 years as they look set to finish the construction of their new ground, Everton Stadium, for the 2025/26 campaign. 

Everton's time at Goodison has seen the club achieve the majority of it's success with 8 first division titles and 5 FA Cups. 

The Grand Old Lady has hosted more top flight games than any other ground in England, with a seated capacity of 39,414 and a record attendance of 78,299 against Liverpool in 1948. 

Transfer approach 

It still remains unclear if the Blues will enter the summer transfer window with an improved strategy in recruitment and smarter spending in compliance with the leagues rules. 

Sean Dyche's squad contains a mixture of talented experienced players such as Abdoulaye Doucoure, James Tarkowski and Jordan Pickford alongside the younger talents in James Garner, Jarrad Branthwaite and Dwight McNeil.

If the Toffees are able to keep hold of key talents such as Dominic Calvert-Lewin and Amadou Onana or replace them aptly, the expectation should be that the last season at Goodison Park sees them push for a return to European football.