Has Riccardo Calafiori claimed back his spot from Myles Lewis-Skelly?
Riccardo Calafiori charges past Mo Salah. (Photo by David Price/Arsenal FC via Getty Images)

Riccardo Calafiori was the most expensive signing of the summer in 2024, but by May of this year, he was firmly second in the pecking order behind Hale End academy graduate Myles Lewis-Skelly. He seems to have bounced back this campaign, but for how long will things work in his favour?

  • Calafiori’s contributions in August

For the second year in a row, Calafiori made his first Premier League start in a trip to Manchester. Last term, he rifled a long range strike to level against Man City in a 2-2 draw, and last month, he was present at the back post to grab the only goal of the game in a 1-0 victory against Man United.

However, the signal of better fortunes for the 23-year-old was the outcome of his work in his day job.

He struggled to get to grips with Savinho at the Etihad Stadium, slipping up in his attempts to hound the right winger on the way to a goal from Erling Haaland. Bryan Mbeumo, meanwhile, might have excited Old Trafford, but the right forward was ultimately frustrated on his debut for the Red Devils.

A second clean sheet of the season came against Leeds United in a 5-0 rout. At the start of the second half, the marauding left back left his mark in the final third once more. Calafiori clipped a high pass in behind the defence of the opposition to assist the first Viktor Gyökeres goal in the Premier League.

If that was not enough, the defender did not shy away from his duel with Mo Salah at Anfield. Even though the Gunners lost 1-0 to Liverpool, it was another solid showing from their defensive unit.

Calafiori capped off August with the award of Player of the Month for Arsenal and a nomination for the same prize across the Premier League. Above all, he started 3 consecutive league fixtures for the first time since the start of March: things are starting to look a lot rosier for the left sided defender.

  • Why has Calafiori displaced Lewis-Skelly?

One wonders if this was the plan for Calafiori when he arrived from Bologna last summer.

Calafiori made four straight starts in the league across September and October: that would be his longest streak of the season. He endured rotten luck on international duty with Italy, injuring his knees time and again as a player who had a suspect fitness record from his past in Serie A.

Lewis-Skelly surprised everyone with his immediate impact on the first team as a makeshift left back who had spent his time in Hale End as a midfielder. The 18-year-old wowed with his bullish presence on the ball, bravery, and ability to break the lines in central areas of the pitch thanks to his passing.

At times, that courage has gone against the 18-year-old. Most recently, he coughed up the ball to Pape Matar Sarr, who lobbed David Raya to score in a 1-0 victory for Tottenham Hotspur in preseason.

Yet, Mikel Arteta appears not to have made his choice at left back out of anger at the teenager.

The extent to which Arsenal have relied on his strengths in the new year was never the plan of the Spaniard. In his own way, Calafiori is an extremely forward thinking player who catches the eye.

The Italian is not afraid of taking the ball forward from the back and his movement gets even more manic in the final third. Whereas Lewis-Skelly has stood out as a midfielder in all but name for the Gunners, Calafiori carves running routes that release room for Declan Rice to drop into the pivot.

Arteta has every right to pick him and take the burden of expectation away from a teenage sensation.

  • A problem position of a different kind

With the way that the season is panning out, how much does this debate actually matter?

Injuries blighted the Gunners' prospects last season, and they are already dealing with absentees at the back. Ben White was absent from an open training session at the Emirates Stadium, and he missed the trip to Anfield while William Saliba suffered a knock to his ankle in that defeat a fortnight ago.

With the arrival of Piero Hincapie on a loan deal from Bayer Leverkusen at the start of the month, the squad has gained an extra player who can cover as a left central defender or a left back in defence.

The option of multiple reliable left backs is an affordance that Arteta has seldom enjoyed in his reign.

Nuno Tavares was a wildcard that never worked out, while a mixture of injuries and tactical demands saw Kieran Tierney sharply lose significance in the squad. Takehiro Tomiyasu briefly stabilised the position, but fitness was always an issue for the Japan international, and Jakub Kiwior would go on to show that he preferred playing as a central defender despite his stint in the role at the start of 2024.

If it is a do-or-die season for the Gunners, then it is best for the team to have as many tools as possible to face the trials of the next nine months. The best squads in the sport embrace stiff competition in the fight to be part of the starting eleven, so Calafiori and Lewis-Skelly should both relish the challenge.