
Things have never been so bad for Man United in the Premier League era. The team finished fifteenth in the table in the 2024/25 campaign, finishing with 42 points— 16 fewer than their previous worst tally.
To complete the humiliation of the season was a night to forget in Bilbao. The Red Devils emphatically defeated Athletic Club in the Europa League semi-final to deny them a final at their ground, but they then lost 1-0 to Tottenham with a limp performance that ended their opponents’ 17-year trophy drought.
Over £200 million was spent in the summer to strengthen the side. However, as Ruben Amorim remains present in the dugout, there are plenty of questions about the latest attempt at a revival at Old Trafford.
-
The rundown on the results
Man United kicked off the new campaign with the visit of title contending Arsenal. Fuelled with opening matchday adrenaline, the hosts narrowly lost 1-0 to a Riccardo Calafiori goal from a header.
A fast start was not rewarded at Fulham, but Leny Yoro put the team ahead in the second half at Craven Cottage before an equaliser from Emile Smith Rowe prolonged the wait for a win. The following trip to Grimsby Town in the Carabao Cup second round should have been a formality, but it became a disaster.
The Red Devils fought back to a 2-2 scoreline late in the second half before going out on penalties. A 3-2 triumph over promoted Burnley on the weekend was barely a reprieve from an embarrassing episode.
A Manchester derby at the Etihad Stadium marked the return from the international break. Phil Foden got his customary goal before Erling Haaland hit a brace to wrap up three points for the Citizens.
Then came a critical clash with Chelsea at Old Trafford. The Blues collapsed inside four minutes in this ‘Big Six’ affair with a red card for Robert Sanchez before conceding a couple of strikes from Bruno Fernandes, his 100th in a red and black shirt, and Casemiro. The victory should have been in the bag.
But this team have a habit of spoiling their good work, and Casemiro received a second yellow before half time. Trevoh Chalobah cut the deficit in half, and the win was far tighter than it should have been. A 3-1 loss at Brentford was the latest reminder of the inconsistency that has prevailed in performances.
Their last outing was a 2-0 win against Sunderland, taking the tally for the Premier League campaign to ten points. Sitting slap bang in mid-table at 10th position, Man United have experienced a mixed start.
-
What has been the return on investment?
Most of the summer outlay went on three attackers: Bryan Mbeumo from Brentford, Matheus Cunha from Wolves, and Benjamin Sesko from RB Leipzig. Goals win games, and they were in short supply for a side that tallied 44 from 38 league fixtures, the fifth lowest tally in the division last campaign.
There has certainly been a difference in the frontline thanks to the qualities of the three big acquisitions.
Cunha can be a selfish personality on the pitch, but he has the mindset and ability to act as a talismanic figure. Placed more centrally at the start of the season, he will look to do his best work from the left.
Sesko stands at 6’5” and his potential presence as an aerial outlet has been a weapon Amorim is willing to use. With two goals in his last two Premier League matches, there is positivity about his development as the starting striker, and he is a player who needs no invitation to get moving on the transition if possible.
Mbeumo may be the most economical of the trio in terms of his work. With a knack for wicked volleys and clutch contributions in front of goal, he has a habit of being involved in moments that matter most. Blessed with speed and an excellent first touch, he is also a calibre of outlet that has been sorely missed.
Yet, despite this impact, Amorim has wanted more. A certain figure is back from the wilderness.
Mason Mount has managed to stay fit for most of the campaign, and he has been a favourite for Amorim. The Englishman started on the left of the front three in the three league fixtures in August and even started ahead of Cunha against Sunderland, getting his first Premier League goal at Old Trafford.
He starred in that role of responsibility for Thomas Tuchel in a 3-4-3 structure, showing the ability to get on the half turn, move intelligently between the lines and score goals. At the same time, his pressing and work rate means getting the output of an extra midfielder off the ball. He is the type of player that can oil the mechanics of a system, and fitness permitting, even more playing time is likely for the 26-year-old.
-
What questions remain for the weeks ahead?
Mount’s presence reflects one challenge that has been a big talking point even before the season started.
Amorim has been insistent on a 3-4-3 formation since the first day in the dugout at Old Trafford, but there has been a gaping hole in midfield. Bruno Fernandes is the team’s joint top scorer with two goals, but he has also missed two penalties against Fulham and Brentford as the Red Devils dropped points.
More importantly than his form from spot kicks, his involvement a role in a double pivot points to imbalance for the team. Manuel Ugarte is a heavily flawed option who has lacked the discipline to even decisively see out games while Casemiro can oscillate from the sublime to the stupid as he ages out.
The club chose to hold onto their club captain amid interest from Saudi Arabia while Mount has been a favourite for the head coach. But with all three summer recruits also fit, how do the puzzle pieces fit?
Two talented individuals who have shone at stages in the last two years have also hit a bit of a roadblock.
Amorim did the footballing world a favour with the offering of consistent minutes to Amad Diallo. He excelled from the get-go under the Portuguese, but the form of the 23-year-old has been patchier this campaign. He came back from a bereavement from good effect against Sunderland, but time will tell how well the role of a right wing-back synchronises with the importance of Mbeumo in the final third.
Kobbie Mainoo, meanwhile, has been on the outskirts, barely getting minutes in the middle of the park. Fans have craved more opportunities for their top talent from the academy, and he offers even more reason for Amorim to consider the option of a three man midfield. But there is no budging on his part.
Beyond profiles and individual players, the biggest questions hang over the head of Amorim as a leader.
He has failed to earn back-to-back wins in the Premier League in the dugout, and most of his wins continue to come with big caveats of opposition being promoted outfits or being down to ten men.
His stubbornness with the setup, on the one hand, and resignation at the flaky form from the players, on the other hand, has been a concoction that produces concerning quotes and comments week to week.
It has not been all bad on the pitch. The intensity is higher, the pressing traps look sharper, and there is variation to go short through the thirds or longer to Mbeumo and Sesko. However, if results do not get much more consistent, doubts will continue about Amorim’s right to remain in his role at Old Trafford.

