Four things we learned from France’s defeat in the Nations League
Ibrahima Konaté, Manu Koné and Ousmane Dembélé dejected during the defeat. (Photo by Johnny Fidelin/Icon Sport via Getty Images)

France failed to reach the final of the Nations Leagueas they lost 5-4 to Spain in the semi-final in Stuttgart. It is the second year in a row that Les Bleus have second best to this opponent after bowing out at the same stage of the European Championship to the eventual winners. This loss was a much more valiant effort and an entertaining spectacle for the neutral, but it still left room for reflection.

Here are four things we learned from the French elimination.

It was not an ideal day to debut for Les Bleus. But pressure can make diamonds as much as it can burst pipes, and a French gem unearthed himself for the world to see in the final half hour of this contest.

Rayan Cherki came on for Michael Olise when the score was 4-1. Five minutes later, Yamal had added the fifth for La Roja. The duel was dead in the water, but that did not deter the 21-year-old.

First came a sweet half volley, then a through ball that broke the lines and allowed Malo Gusto to give Dani Vivian an unenviable situation as he scored an own goal. Finally, in injury time, Cherki clipped a delicate delivery to the far post and picked out Randal Kolo Muani for a fourth strike.

The creativity of Cherki was crystal clear in this cameo: goal, the pass before the pass, and an assist. He has no hesitation in switching between his two feet, he confidently throws chips, sole rolls, and even rabonas into his manipulation of angles. This is a man who carefully caresses the ball in each moment like an artist who is painting brush strokes on a canvas. He is a technician par excellence.

  • France’s forward depth is incredible

Cherki courted attention, but he was not the only forward-thinking player to put on fireworks.

At the same time as his entry, Bradley Barcola took the place of his club teammate Desire Doue. He is one of the most explosive wingers in world football when there is space to attack outside or around a backline, and was a wildcard for the French at the Euros last year. Again, he did his duty, pinning Pedro Porro backwards with his dribbling and speed, setting up Kolo Muani for a gilt-edged chance.

Doue himself had a quieter day than the Champions League final, but he still showed flashes of how powerfully he can assert himself in shooting situations, forcing Unai Simon to save twice in the first half. Similarly, Ousmane Dembele was not as decisive as we have seen from him at Paris Saint-Germain, but his standard right-wing shift still showed the dribbling skills that have shaken Europe.

Between them was Michael Olise. He has the ability to operate as a playmaker in a more central role than he has done at club level for Crystal Palace and Bayern Munich, where he features from the right flank. Some of the best work in the first hour saw him slip into space and link with Dembele.

There is even more talent to account for in terms of central forwards. Kolo Muani, a much-maligned figure, jolted Juventus into life on loan, Marcus Thuram got to the Champions League final with Inter Milan, and Jean-Philippe Mateta was not even in the squad. Didier Deschamps cannot call up all of them— let alone use them all in a lineup— but he can never say he is not spoiled for choice.

Does that depth mean that there might be more reason to remove the talisman from the team?

It is an emphatic no from Deschamps. He declared Kylian Mbappe will stay in the starting eleven and continue to be the striker despite other options on the roster and the form of Dembele in a more central role for PSG. But there is no doubt that the lights shine on the 26-year-old extremely brightly.

At Real Madrid, he found his shooting boots in 2025 to win the Golden Boot but was anaemic in the face of a disciplined deep block from Arsenal as they ended the defence of the Champions League title from Los Blancos. The knives have only sharpened further after the exploits of the Parisians in the wake of his exit and among a star studded cast, he could not nail down the role of the protagonist.

After six minutes, with the score at 0-0, he messed up a transition that allowed Simon to bail out a mistake from Merino, failing to score or set up Dembele for a tap-in. Around the half hour mark, he similarly screwed up a strike from a cutback into the penalty area. By the time he drew contact for the penalty he converted in the second half, the French were down four goals: it was too little, too late.

No one can take away Mbappe's extensive exploits from him, nor the fact that he is still one of the most frightening forwards in the world. However, he has made moves to pitch himself as the star of a story that needs him to maximise major moments. Once more, on Thursday evening, that did not happen.

  • France have a fullback problem

It is impossible to talk about this result without looking at the faults of the French in their defence.

Les Bleus broke down badly in their back four. It was the first time that they had conceded five times in an outing since a 5-0 defeat to England in 1969, and it is only the fourth time in their history that they have lost a fixture in which they have also managed to hit the back of the net three times.

Grace has to go to Deschamps. He was missing Jules Koundé and William Saliba due to hamstring injuries. Dayot Upamecano is also still sitting on the sidelines due to having loose tissue in his knee.

But all of that cannot take away from the persistent problem that hangs over the construction of the squad. For all of their talent at the front of the field, the French continue to struggle to find fullbacks.

Pierre Kalulu debuted as a right back and was second best to Nico Williams, who sensed he could get change out of his marker. Even Koundé, the typical first choice, is a central defender by trade.

Malo Gusto, who came on for him, has swung in and out of form for Chelsea with clear flaws if he is not in the role of an overlapping threat. Benjamin Pavard might have got the nod as the right back in the World Cup winning side of 2018, but he sat on the sidelines after the Champions League final.

Fullback classically goes down as a role that goes to misfits who do not make it as a winger, a central defender, or a midfielder. But a lack of confidence in competent choices has been visible for a while.