From polarising to undroppable? Aaronson’s case for a USMNT World Cup starting spot
NEWCASTLE UPON TYNE, ENGLAND - JANUARY 07: Brenden Aaronson of Leeds United celebrates scoring his team's third goal during the Premier League match between Newcastle United and Leeds United at St James' Park on January 07, 2026 in Newcastle upon Tyne, England. (Photo by Stu Forster/Getty Images)

Brenden Aaronson used to be the player everyone associated with Leeds United debated heavily.

Now he’s the player everyone has to talk about.

There was a time - not that long ago - when Aaronson’s name sparked more frustration than faith at Elland Road. Even Daniel Farke admitted in the autumn that the American “polarises” opinion. The work-rate was never questioned. The pressing, the energy, the constant movement - that was always there. What people wanted was end product. Decisiveness.

Right now? They’re getting it.

From polarising figure to in-form Premier League player

Aaronson is producing the best stretch of his career so far at Leeds United.

Over a one-month stretch, he delivered three goals and two assists, influencing games against Liverpool, Manchester United and Newcastle. In the chaotic 4-3 defeat to Newcastle, he was everywhere: two goals, nine duels won, four tackles, three shots on target, a created chance. Even the unfortunate handball that led to a penalty couldn’t mask the fact he was the most dangerous player on the pitch.

Daniel Farke summed it up recently:

“He embodies so much what we want to be, which values we want to stand for as Leeds United. Sometimes we don’t do it the easy way and he can sometimes have a bit more clarity in his situations, but we have a great heart and a great work ethic. We never give up.

"He embodies this hard and honest work so much and fully deserves praise after the last performances.”

That word - clarity - keeps surfacing. And that’s the difference now. Aaronson hasn’t stopped running. He’s just started making better decisions in the final third.

The context matters

Aaronson arrived at Leeds in 2022 for a reported £25 million fee. Expectations were heavy. In a relegation season, he scored once in 40 games. A loan spell at Union Berlin produced just two goals in 38 appearances. By the time he returned to Yorkshire for the 2024/25 EFL Championship campaign, narratives had already been written.

He responded with nine goals and relentless energy, helping secure promotion. Yet questions persisted. Was he good enough for the Premier League? Would Leeds need to upgrade?

Even Farke publicly urged patience:

“It’s important not to put too much weight on his shoulders… Sometimes the feeling with Brenden is that we are a bit over-critical in public.”

Aaronson himself addressed the perception when speaking to GOAL in 2024:

“I want to be outside of that box. I’m not just a runner. I’m not just a guy that’s pressing all the time. I’ll show that, of course, but I think I’m also more than that, you know? I think I’m a guy that brings other things to the pitch and, yeah, I just wish people could see that more.”

They’re seeing it now.

What does this mean for the USMNT?

That’s where the conversation gets interesting.

The United States have depth in wide and attacking midfield areas heading into the 2026 FIFA World Cup. Aaronson has often been viewed as a high-energy squad option rather than a guaranteed starter. A useful piece. A pressing trigger. A late-game disruptor.

But current Aaronson isn’t just running. He’s deciding games.

Brad Friedel told GOAL:

“I don’t think this is just his best spell at Leeds, I think this is his best spell in his career, ever. He’s done it at a pretty good time with the World Cup coming up!”

That timing is indeed crucial. The World Cup will be on home soil. Form heading into that tournament will matter. Coaches lean towards players they trust in big moments, and right now Aaronson is delivering in big Premier League matches.

Does that make him an automatic starter? Not yet, but it forces a rethink.

If he continues to produce against top-level opposition - not just running, but scoring and assisting - he moves from “rotation option” to genuine starting candidate. His ability to press aggressively while also contributing technically suits tournament football. Games compress. Margins shrink. Players who can flip momentum in seconds become invaluable.

Starter or impact weapon?

The debate may ultimately hinge on his role.

Aaronson can play as a right-sided attacker, a narrow No.10, even tucked inside in a hybrid role. Under Farke, he’s shown improved understanding of space, especially when drifting between lines rather than staying glued to the touchline.

If the USMNT want balance and control, he might start. If they want chaos and energy late on, he becomes a devastating impact option.

The key question isn’t whether he’s good enough anymore. It’s whether he can sustain this level through the remainder of the Premier League season.

Because if the current version of Brenden Aaronson turns up this summer - sharp, decisive, confident - he won’t just be in the squad. He’ll be very hard to leave out of the starting XI.