
After losing in the World Series last season, the New York Yankees failed in their pursuit of their prized free agent, Juan Soto. The Dominican superstar instead headed across town to the New York Mets signing a record-breaking 15-year $765m contract. It meant the Yankees were left with a giant hole in what was already a flawed lineup, which they have made great attempts to fill through multiple positions. A huge criticism of the Bronx Bombers was their lack of fundamentals and defensive quality. Despite Soto’s supreme offensive talent, he left a lot to be desired in the outfield. Players were also played out of position, with Jazz Chisholm Jr at third base and Aaron Judge in center field.
The conversations following the World Series defeat centered on the side’s drawbacks, and defense was a key area in GM Brian Cashman’s off-season plans. This began with the non-desire to bring back Gleyber Torres, who ranked second worst in defensive runs saved of all MLB second basemen. Alex Verdugo and veteran Anthony Rizzo were also let go as free agents, while the bullpen needed a revamp with the departures of Clay Holmes and Tommy Kahnle.
Max Fried – 8-years, $218m
The Yankees made an almost immediate pivot post-Soto, signing starter Max Fried to an eight-year contract. With $218m in total money, this makes him the highest-paid left-handed pitcher in MLB history. Conversations were had with the pitcher’s camp just before Soto went elsewhere, and he put pen to paper shortly afterwards.
They added to an area already blessed with great strength and depth, as Fried slots in just behind ace Gerrit Cole. This right and left-handed one-two punch gives New York one of the most impressive pitching duos in the entire league. Fried had spent his entire eight-year career with the Atlanta Braves before making the switch to the Bronx. He enjoyed great success there, playing a key role in their World Series win in 2021, as well as achieving multiple individual honors, including two all-star berths and three Gold Gloves, highlighting his defensive capabilities on the mound. Fried also has a devastating curveball, one of an array of pitches he has in his arsenal which also includes four-seamers, sinkers, changeups, sweepers, sliders and cutters.
Last season, he started 29 games, recording an ERA of 3.25. This ranked 15th in MLB and eighth in the National League. This would have ranked second in the Yankees’ rotation last year, with only Clarke Schmidt’s 2.85 ERA better, though this did come in just 16 starts. Fried will join a deep pitching staff which also includes reigning AL Rookie of the Year Luis Gil and Carlos Rodon. With replacing Soto’s offensive production proving an impossible task, the Yankees made a concerted effort to improve run prevention.
Cody Bellinger – acquired via trade from Cubs
A move that may have been inevitable regardless of Soto’s destination, the Yankees acquired long-term target Cody Bellinger from the Chicago Cubs. After plenty of deliberation between the two teams, New York sent a package which included pitcher Cody Poteet and cash considerations. The Cubs also sent over $5m to cover some of the remaining $52.5m on his two-year deal. The Yankees and Bellinger had long felt the perfect fit, and now the former MVP and World Series champion is following in his father Clay’s footsteps in competing at Yankee Stadium.
Despite going through injuries and regression throughout the last couple of seasons, the hope is that Bellinger can rediscover his old self in the Bronx. An appealing quality to the Yankees is his versatility, as he can play any position in the outfield as well as first base. The departure of Verdugo opened up the left field position, set to be taken by the club’s biggest prospect Jasson Dominguez. Bellinger is slated to take over center field from Judge, who will revert to his preferred station in right.
In 2024, Bellinger played 130 games, hitting .266 with 18 home runs. Though nowhere near the outlet that Soto provided, the 29-year-old offers a complementary left-handed bat to Judge’s right-handed power, whether that be ahead or behind the slugger in the lineup. The Yankees 1-9 was so inconsistent outside of Soto and Judge, that even with a decline in Bellinger’s stats, he would have been the fourth-best hitter in terms of batting average. Only Soto, Judge and Giancarlo Stanton recorded more home runs, so Bellinger should be a crucial addition on both sides of the ball, especially with the short porch.
Devin Williams – acquired via trade from Brewers
The focus on pitching improvements became even more apparent with the surprising trade to acquire star closer Devin Williams from the Milwaukee Brewers. The signing of Fried meant the Yankees had a slew of starting pitchers, allowing them to make a trade of this ilk. It was left-hander Nestor Cortes who was dealt, alongside promising second baseman Caleb Durbin, who had earlier been tipped to make the opening day roster. Williams gives the side a bona fide closer in the bullpen, allowing Luke Weaver to take on perhaps a much more effective role as the setup man. Weaver replaced Holmes as the closer in the middle of last season, following 13 blown saves from the now-departed reliever.
Pitching coach Matt Blake now has an even stronger relief group to work with, despite losing the likes of Holmes and Kahnle. Weaver did an admirable job serving as the closer on their way to the World Series, but now he can pitch in front of one of the best in the league in Williams.
Williams had a heartbreaking end to his Brewers career, blowing a 2-0 lead in the ninth inning to the Mets in the NLCS, which ultimately sent them home. However, he has recorded a sub-2.00 ERA in each of the last three seasons. Overall, he has an ERA of 1.83 in 97 appearances, showcasing ‘The Airbender’, the name given to his elite changeup.
Paul Goldschmidt – 1-year, $12.5m
The latest of the Yankees’ new major acquisitions was the signing of first baseman Paul Goldschmidt. With another former MVP, the side has looked to build a roster filled with a perfect blend of experience and youth and will lean on the 37-year-old to provide an additional ounce of leadership and insight. He will replace Rizzo, who led a first base group which ranked bottom in OPS (.619) in the entire league last season. Rizzo had dealt with injuries throughout his Yankees career, suffering with a concussion and broken arm in recent years. While Goldschmidt is older than him, the former St Louis Cardinal has missed just eight games in each of the last two seasons, making him a reliable and durable bat.
However, the Yankees should still give him an opportunity here and there to get off his feet, and they will look to give Ben Rice at-bats to continue his development from last season. Oswaldo Cabrera and Bellinger could also be alternative options. Goldschmidt is a five-time Silver Slugger award winner, and MVP recipient as recent as 2022, though has shown signs of decline in the two seasons since. Although, like Bellinger, the Yankees are hoping for bounce-back campaigns in a new environment and a more talented lineup.
Similarly, even with the regression, Goldschmidt should prove a major upgrade from last year’s lineup. He hit .245 with 22 home runs, both of which would have ranked highly within the Yankees roster. He also has an elite glove, continuing the theme of prioritising defensive improvements. Goldschmidt is a four-time Gold Glove winner and will serve as part of a talented infield formation alongside Chisholm Jr and Anthony Volpe.
Tim Hill & Jonathan Loaisiga – Re-signed Free Agents
Tim Hill was a revelation for the bullpen last season after he was picked up following his release from the Chicago White Sox. He was a reliable arm in crucial moments, delivering during the high-stake innings, including deep into the postseason. The Yankees needed to retain their left-hander for a bullpen devoid of southpaws. Hill recorded a 2.05 ERA in 35 relief appearances. He re-signed on a one-year $2.85m contract with a $3m club option for the 2026 season.
Jonathan Loaisiga has been with the Yankees since the 2016 season, though it is a career plagued by injuries. His 2024 campaign was cut very short as he was diagnosed with a torn UCL following three scoreless appearances. It required surgery, meaning he has not played since and is not expected to return until late May or early June. Despite his prolonged absences, Loaisiga is expected to be a key part of a strong Yankees bullpen. He is a reliever who excels at limiting hard contact and boasts a career ERA of 3.44 in 163 games. The 30-year-old is contracted to the Yankees for the 2025 season with a club option for 2026.
The Yankees also acquired RHP Fernando Cruz in a smart trade which sent catcher Jose Trevino to the Cincinnati Reds, further bolstering their relief options.
Explore more stats, standings and news on VAVEL Data: New York Yankees

