
In the past week, three of Manchester United's younger players have been brought back to Old Trafford after spending the first half of the season on loan. Ben Pearson was with League One Barnsley, Will Keane was in the Championship with Preston North End and Adnan Januzaj was in the Bundesliga with Borussia Dortmund. All three had contrasting fortunes on loan, and now back in United's bosom, they may have contrasting fortunes in the not too distant future.
Pearson to leave again?
Pearson has left Barnsley with his head held high. He spent time there at the back end of last season, and he has flourished this season. The Barnsley manager, Lee Johnson, said this week that he was "gutted" to lose the talented midfielder and heaped praise on the youngster. At 20, he could be vying for a place in the first team, but with so much competition there is little chance of that.
It is thought that United have recalled him as they are looking to place him in the Championship and give him a step up. Preston, after losing Keane, are ironically said to be interested in doing just that, but additional reports suggest that Bournemouth are prepared to take him on a permanent deal. There have been plenty of kids given opportunities under Louis van Gaal, and if Pearson were allowed to leave it would suggest he is not as advanced as certain other players. He is an excellent prospect and it would be rather sad if United allowed him to leave for good. Another loan sounds like the best all round solution, and in the coming weeks, his future should be clearer.
Keane to bolster U-21's?
Keane's recall is the most curious. At 22, he needs first team football and Simon Grayson, the Preston manager, suggested he is being brought back to go into the first team squad. He featured for the U-21's on Monday against Tottenham Hotspur, as did Pearson, and both acquitted themselves well. For Keane to get a chance in the first team, though, it would be remarkable. He has only ever made one first team appearance in the game that Paul Pogba described as the game he decided to move from United, against Blackburn Rovers in 2011. Some of that may be down to his horrendous luck with injuries, as he has suffered one serious knee injury and a succession of others whilst away on four loan moves.
James Wilson has continually been tipped for big things, but it is Keane that has been recalled. In all honesty, he is back up. He will not remove Wayne Rooney or Anthony Martial from the starting line-up, and quite possibly he is going to play most of his football this season as an over-age player in the U-21's. Or van Gaal will spring a surprise, but without being disrespectful to Keane, he has not shown enough at Wigan, QPR, Sheffield Wednesday and now Preston to think that he can excel at a much tougher level. The young player of the year in 2009-10 was a goal machine in his younger days, but he has only managed four senior goals during in his spells, which have mainly been spent in the Championship. It could be a long few months, and ultimately he is likely to follow his twin, Michael, onto pastures new.
Januzaj at a crossroads
It is fair to say that Januzaj's career has stalled. From his meteoric rise after scoring a brace against Sunderland in 2013, he has pretty much gone backwards. Although that probably is not the case. The hype that surrounded him when he broke into United's side was over the top. The clamour for his services at international level now look quite foolish, and England should for the time being think themselves lucky that they never pushed the boat out to 'steal' him. Belgium was the natural choice, but ironically had he chosen Albania - although Kosovo was his birthplace, that would have been worse than choosing England - it may have helped his career at this stage. Such is the competition in Belgium that now he is struggling at club level, there is no shortage of talent to occupy the spot he took up at the 2014 World Cup. Since his appearance in Brazil, he has played just one minute for the international Red Devils.
This season started well for Januzaj. He started the second game against Aston Villa and scored the winner. He started the next three games also, but as the transfer deadline approached a deal was brokered with Dortmund for him to go to Germany for the season. It was unusual, but the warning signs were there after the Villa game. When van Gaal was interviewed, the reporter fed van Gaal a question intimating that Januzaj had done well. Van Gaal dismissed this and focused solely on what the youngster could do better. So whilst it was a surprise, with the likes of Memphis Depay, and as we now know Anthony Martial, being brought into the club the move to Dortmund was a good fit. Not so. It is quite likely that had Januzaj stayed, he would have got as many appearances with United as he did in Germany. 12 appearances of which only three were starts was not what was expected.
Yet he has been brought back at his own request, not because van Gaal thinks he needs him. That doesn't bode well. The chances are he will see game time, but with van Gaal stating that he needs more pace then Januzaj may well find himself playing with Keane in the U-21's to get some fitness. It is not that Januzaj is not talented, he clearly is. He has a bit of Jesper Olsen about him when he glides past players. Indeed, it was reported that the coaches of Belgium had to have a word with him in the training camp in Brazil, as some of the older players were fed up with him 'nutmegging' them. He is not short of confidence, or at least wasn't. It is his attitude that is being called into question with the story going round that he is not applying himself as he should be. For all his talent, if that is the case he will be out of the picture altogether at United before much longer. Watch this space.
Loan moves not working for United
There seemed to be a clear policy from United when players used to go out on loan. The idea is that the players gain experience at other clubs, and come back with an eye on challenging for the first team. If they don't quite have the talent, then the experience should help secure a move when the time comes. David Beckham, whilst only playing four games, benefited from the experience. Players such as John O'Shea and Jonny Evans came back and established themselves in the first team with distinction. Even certain players like Danny Simpson and Phil Bardsley gained invaluable experience from the loan moves. They had Gary Neville in their way, so it wasn't their talent that was lacking. They have both had good careers and the loan moves, at least, put them in the shop window. Latterly, the scattering of players seems haphazard, and the number of players coming back and using the experience to push for a first team place are rare. Tom Cleverley did it, but ultimately was deemed not good enough for United. One of Keane's 2011 youth cup winning team-mate, Jesse Lingard, is another. He has a chance of a career at United, but you feel that another big signing or two may also seal his fate.
Lack of quality
If it is not the loan policy that is the problem, then more worrying it is the lack of quality. Nobody expects the likes of Beckham, Paul Scholes, the Neville's et al to keep coming off a conveyor belt, but there seem to be fewer and fewer that are establishing themselves as a regular first team player. From the 2011 youth cup winning team, the ones (or one) that have made it have done so elsewhere. Keane and Lingard are joined only by Tyler Blackett and Sam Johnstone as survivors from the youth team. Both Blackett and Johnstone are on loan, wouldn't you know. Blackett is at Celtic, and not in the first team picture, whilst Johnstone is starting his second spell with Preston, where he did excellently last year. Johnstone is another good point in the case at how even successful loan spells don't mean a great deal these days. After a great pre-season on the back of his time at Preston, he was overlooked by van Gaal for Sergio Romero, who had been at the club for a week.
It is not all doom and gloom, as United have a number of young players in the team, and the likes of Cameron Borthwick-Jackson have made their debut this season, and several others made the bench. The bottom line is that unless you are good enough, you won't make it at United. However, the three recall's do throw into question what the purpose of sending players out on loan really is. In due time, we will find out.

