Pep for City? Mourinho not your cup of tea? Who is next for Manchester United?

The smart money is on Pep Guardiola coming to Manchester after his time at Bayern Munich comes to an end in the summer. Most people connected with Manchester United would not pass up the opportunity to obtain one of, if not the best manager in the world.

Unfortunately, the project that Manchester City have put together has been geared to securing Guardiola, and that smart money is on them getting their man. If Guardiola does go to City, then there are not too many other options of that calibre. One would be the currently unemployed Jose Mourinho. It is reported that Real Madrid approached him after relieving Rafa Benitez of his services. They wanted him to take up a second spell at the Bernabeu, but Mourinho passed on the opportunity. If that's true, then it is quite possible he has eyes on Old Trafford.

The problem for Mourinho is that United don't seem that keen to roll out the red carpet. After the awful sequence of results in December, the pressure on Louis van Gaal reached new levels and it seemed that with Mourinho available the immediate switch made sense. Although United halted a series of defeats, they have still looked lifeless and some way off what everyone at the club expects, but van Gaal stayed put.

So it seems van Gaal will remain until the summer at least. If he does leave in the summer, then the only thing Mourinho will have in his favour is that securing him would not involve any compensation as he is a free agent. However, United apparently snubbed him when appointing David Moyes, and the feeling is that Mourinho will not be the choice if and when van Gaal departs. There is no doubting his managerial credentials, but his off-field antics are obviously a stigma.

Mourinho the 'Marmite' man

From a fans perspective, Mourinho would divide opinion. Certain sections are willing to ignore his ungracious behaviour and feel that United winning is all that counts. Others, probably more sensibly, believe that winning is important but upholding the club's traditions is just as important. Forget about the eye gouging, and Arsene Wenger baiting, Mourinho's brand of football is not exactly a million miles away from the dearth that is being served up under van Gaal right now.

Many fans are complaining it is the style that is the issue, and playing attacking football would be more satisfying than results. Well, under Mourinho it is likely that the only real difference would be results. He is a master tactician, and he manages to do what is required to win football matches. Until this year. Wherever Mourinho ends up, it will be interesting to see how he reacts to probably his most difficult experience as a manager.

Scarves on sale at Old Trafford (Photo: Alex Livesey/Getty Images)
Scarves on sale at Old Trafford (Photo: Alex Livesey/Getty Images)

He imploded spectacularly after guiding Chelsea to the league title last season. He created a public row with the club doctor that has ended up in the law courts. He blamed every man and their dog for the terrible results, but uncharacteristically he also started to blame players. No matter what he did, he could not arrest the slide and his fall from grace was quite startling. He is now taking a break, and it maybe that a bit of time to reflect may produce a different Mourinho when his sabbatical ends.

For him to get the job at United it would require him to change his ways on and off the pitch. Whether that would dilute his effectiveness, but more importantly whether he would be prepared to do that, remains to be seen.

Giggs waiting in the wings

The fact that United ignored Mourinho over Christmas means the theory that Ryan Giggs is being primed to take over from van Gaal has more weight to it. Sir Alex Ferguson has endorsed Giggs, and van Gaal himself believes that the United legend will be his successor. Van Gaal has allegedly recently relaxed some of his strict rules and has given Giggs more responsibility in a bid to improve performances. Even if that is the case, the man in the press conferences is still van Gaal and that means he is the man making the decisions. And taking the responsibility.

Until Giggs is making those decisions himself, then any negativity towards him being United's manager is unfair. As Giggs is part of the staff, by association he is seen as partly responsible for the woeful football United are playing. Again, that is unfair. Regardless of whether it is right or wrong, this is the football world these days and if Giggs does get the top job, he can be assured that criticism will come from all angles.

His links to van Gaal is something he must shake off quickly. Any performances that mirror anything seen this season, and the blades will be sharpened. The biggest criticism of Giggs as a boss is that he does not have the experience. Four games in charge as caretaker, and in the summer he will have had three years on the coaching staff. That doesn't seem enough to qualify you for one of the top jobs in football, but what does? Pep Guardiola had experience of coaching Barcelona B before taking up the reigns at Camp Nou. Those jobs are not the same, not even in the same ballpark.

Zinedine Zidane was the man Real turned to after Benitez' departure. He has also only managed their B team. If coaching at a lower level is qualification enough, does that mean that Nicky Butt has a great chance of succeeding van Gaal? Probably not, but he has almost as much experience as Guardiola and Zidane did. Giggs' association with United goes back to the 80's and his perceived lack of experience should not prevent him from getting the job, or evoke criticism. David Moyes and van Gaal both had the experience, but one has already gone and one is on borrowed time.

The last criticism of Giggs will come in the form of his personal life. His publicised affair is something that will never go away, but certainly the fact that he is still employed by the club means the incident is not something that will mar  his chances. The club appears to have a different policy to the one in place that cost Tommy Docherty his job in the 70's. So the fans may have some moral objections to a Giggs appointment.

He hasn't got the job yet, and if he does then he deserves to be given all the support in the world. He is a living legend, and there is also concerns that his star will be diminished if he fails. That sort of thinking is ridiculous. Firstly, it is assumed that he will fail in the job. Giggs may surprise a lot of people if he gets the chance. However, even if he doesn't succeed, why should he no longer be considered a legend? He has been one of United's greatest ever players, and is the most decorated. If he follows a succession of experienced managers in failing to bring success in what is becoming an impossible job, then it should not detract from his playing achievements and his reputation should not be harmed.

Who else could do the job?

Should United look beyond Giggs, and still want him to cut his teeth as either a number two or even elsewhere then what does that leave? Mark Hughes. 'Sparky' was also a playing legend for United, but he has been in management for some time now and in the main part has enjoyed success. He started out with Wales and came as close as anyone to get them to a major tournament, failing in the play off's against Russia in 2004. At Blackburn, Fulham and now at Stoke City, he achieved his goals in keeping them in the Premier League and, as can be seen, now at Stoke, he is doing so with some panache.

His teams are well organised, but the steel is nicely complimented with no shortage of style. He is attracting some top quality to the Potteries, so imagine what he might do at United. He is earning a lot of plaudits now, but it wasn't so long ago he was being quite unfairly written off. At QPR, he endured a tough time and was blamed solely for their relegation, despite Harry Redknapp managing the club for the majority of that season.

Hughes could be a success

Hughes made mistakes at QPR, one of which was signing a host of players in the summer of 2012 after narrowly missing out on relegation the year before. The influx of quality was negated by the volume of new faces, and unable to integrate everybody, Hughes lost his job. Still, that blip in his career is something that wouldn't be considered a problem. It is his association with the enemy that will draw the most raised eyebrows. Hughes is damaged goods in some quarters after managing across the city at the Etihad. It's not what he did, but the mere fact that he was the direct rivals for a while.

He also came in for some criticism for what he achieved at City, considering he was the first to be bankrolled by Sheikh Mansour. He did spend a lot of money, and although the team never looked like challenging for the title, it was a stepping stone. He brought Pablo Zabaleta and Vincent Kompany to the club, both of whom continue to be integral to City's continued success. It is difficult to say Hughes wouldn't have brought success given time. It is also hard to say he wouldn't do that at United.

Mauricio Pochettino anyone? As is the norm these days, the foreign managers seem to be lauded and coveted in equal measure, regardless of what they have achieved. Flavour of the month at the moment is Tottenham Hotspur's Argentine boss. He started out at Espanyol in Spain, where he had been a player. He took over with the team facing relegation, but took them to mid table.

Mauricio Pochettino looks on against Everton. (Photo: Alex Livesey/Getty Images)
Mauricio Pochettino looks on against Everton. (Photo: Alex Livesey/Getty Images)

He continued to do well in Spain, but he was sacked in his fourth season with the side rooted to the bottom of La Liga. He came to Southampton midway through the 2012/13 season, after Nigel Adkins was quite cruelly dismissed. Pochettino enhanced the good work that Adkins had done and achieved a 14th place finish, and in his first full season took Southampton to eighth in the table. He was in vogue, and Spurs came calling. His first season went okay, and was pretty much par for the course finishing in fifth place. Southampton, under Ronald Koeman, finished seventh but just four points behind Spurs and a vastly superior goal difference.

Pochettino not yet deserving

This season, Spurs are occupying fourth place, and could well finish in the lucrative Champions League spots, but the progress Spurs have made under Pochettino has hardly been earth shattering. United's fans are expecting someone to come in with a magic wand, and if Pochettino took over and made progress at the same rate, it is unquestionable that the fans patience would be tested.

When all said and done, Pochettino has not achieved anything in his short career so far to suggest he deserves, or is ready, for such a huge position. Indeed, Claudio Ranieri has more credentials having managed some huge clubs around Europe with a modicum of success. His Leicester City team are a joy to watch, and have lit up the Premier League, but Ranieri will not be in the frame.

Neither will Alan Pardew, but should he be considered? A successful start at Reading saw him take over at West Ham United. He took them to an FA Cup final, narrowly losing to Liverpool on penalties. Results started to wane, and after his sacking, he had rather miserable spell at Charlton. From that point on, though, he has shown what a good manager he is. He, like Nigel Adkins, was harshly treated by Southampton after guiding them back to the Championship and winning the FA Trophy. He then moved to Newcastle United, and his achievements there have been very understated. With the purse strings tight, to say the least, he continued to produce good looking teams and kept Newcastle afloat comfortably. He still had to endure some dogs abuse from the fans and eventually moved to Crystal Palace in December 2014. What he has done since then is quite sensational.

Pardew underrated

Palace were in the bottom three with only 16 points when Pardew took charge. Newcastle were 10th with 26 points. At the end of the season, Palace finished 10th while Newcastle accrued a miserly 13 points after his departure. Pardew himself bagged 58 points combined last season. That would have took a team to eighth in the league. He has continued to make Palace an exciting and difficult team to face. John Carver, Pardew's replacement, showed he was nowhere near up to the task in Newcastle yet Steve McClaren, himself well respected and vastly experienced, is also struggling badly at the 'Toon'. On the face of it, you are not going to associate Pardew with the United job, but the likes of Pardew, Redknapp and Sam Allardyce are all excellent managers. They don't seem to be appreciated for what they have achieved. They haven't really done anything in terms of winning trophies, but there are only a handful of trophies available. In England, Sir Alex Ferguson, Wenger and Mourinho have monopolised those over the years.

Options abroad in short supply

In truth, there is not much else to choose from. Looking abroad, you could make a case for Diego Simone. He has done an amazing job at Atletico Madrid, and he has at least made La Liga a three horse race without the same resources as the big two. He could certainly be on the shortlist.

Another name that has recently cropped up is Laurent Blanc. That would be an interesting appointment. He is an ex-United player of course, and that would help. He won the French League with unfashionable Bordeaux and managed the National team with distinction. He has shown at Paris Saint-Germain that he can handle money and has spent his considerable budget wisely. With Mourinho apparently on PSG's radar, the option of Blanc may not be so fanciful.

One other name managing abroad is wanted by the odd fan. Gary Neville. There is no point in even expanding on that possibility, it shouldn't and won't happen.

United now the hardest job in football

So the reality is that Pep and Mourinho are the two big fish that are almost certainties to provide trophies. After that, you have the rookie in Giggs, one or two in England with a shout, or a couple of decent options abroad. Whoever comes in is going to be expected to produce immediate results, and yet there is no basis for that sort of thinking.

The job at United is becoming the hardest in football. The clubs stature, history and tradition bring acute pressure but English football is now more difficult than ever to win trophies. The league is awash with cash, so not only do the big clubs present challenges, the likes of Leicester, Palace, Watford and Bournemouth can acquire decent players and there are no easy games. United's current team have not shown anything to suggest that they deserve to be at United. A couple of players can hold their head up, but many have been quite poor to say the least.

Van Gaal could end the speculation by somehow dragging United to victory in one or more of the competitions they remain in contention for. If he secured even the FA Cup. then it may give him a stay of execution. Even that may not be enough to prevent a change. United are in danger of losing their identity.

Van Gaal was a fantastic appointment on the face of it, but his philosophy either hasn't materialised after 18 months in charge, or is completely and utterly flawed. You would hope that van Gaal and his process is the problem, because if it is the players that are not up to United's standards then even the cream of the managerial crop will have their work cut out to change things in the short term.