James Tarkowski looks to the sky after conceding to Manchester United (Picture by Alex Livesey - Getty Images)

Despite only losing one game in their last eight, a distinct lack of goals has drawn criticism for the Blues recently. 

Their defence has been a positive so far this season, and the re-introduction of Jarrad Branthwaite to the side has been a catalyst to their improved defensive record. 

Only four goals conceded in their last eight games seemed a strong positive and, with their opponents only scoring 13 in their last 12 league games, the odds of a clean sheet for the away side were favourable. 

How the rout unfolded

Dyche's side made a strong start to the game, but a deflected goal through Marcus Rashford opened the floodgates for the United attack. 

Another goal before halftime from Joshua Zirkzee and another two after the interval saw the Toffees lose the game by four goals to nil in the end. 

Here are the player ratings for Everton in their torrid defeat:

Everton Player Ratings

Jordan Pickford - 4

A disappointing day for England's number one, conceding four goals but he was not helped by his defence in the slightest. 

Vitalii Mykolenko - 2

Another poor performance in a particularly poor season so far for Everton's number 19. Amad Diallo seemed to have his number from the first whistle and the Ukrainian struggled all game with United's fast breaks. 

Investment in a new left back during the January window seems more and more likely by the day. 

Jarrad Branthwaite - 3

Perhaps his worst performance in an Everton shirt. A mistake leading to a goal and a few wayward passes throughout the 90 minutes highlighted a poor game for the England international. 

James Tarkowski - 2

As with his defensive partner, Tarkowski also made a mistake leading to a United goal in what was an equally poor game for the centre-half. He was replaced by Jake O'Brien late in the game, and for good reason. 

Ashley Young - 3

Not a textbook performance upon his return to Old Trafford. The 39-year-old also struggled to contain the pacey Reds attack. 

Idrissa Gana Gueye - 4

A strong first 30 minutes for Everton's veteran midfielder was overshadowed by a poor hour of football, filled with wayward passes and constant overrunning in midfield.

Abdoulaye Doucoure - 3

This should spell the end of Doucoure's time in the starting 11 for the Toffees. His technical ability is not strong enough to play in a holding position in the Premier League. 

Jesper Lindstrøm - 3

The Dane's quotes pre-match spelt a bit of excitement in Everton fans for a positive attacking performance. However, this was far from the case.

A few free kicks hit straight at the United wall deep in the second half — the only thing of note from the winger throughout the game.

Dwight McNeil - 2

Sean Dyche's experiment with McNeil in the 10 role should be over after this game. 

Every attacking opportunity that went through the midfielder seemed to come to an end as soon as it reached his feet. 

Illiman Ndiaye - 6

The only positive from a pitiful performance overall. 

Man United defenders took a step back every time the tricky midfielder touched the ball. He could become a real success at Everton. 

Beto - 4

The striker struggled all match with a lack of service at Old Trafford.

Substitutes

Orel Mangala - 5

Jack Harrison - 5

Dominic Calvert-Lewin - 4

Nathan Patterson - 5

Jake O'Brien - 5

Assessing the substitutes

With Sean Dyche only choosing to make a substitute when his side was already 4-0 down, it is hard to get an accurate gauge of how the Everton substitutes performed.

However, the away side did look like a better team after the changes were made.

Amorim's side did put their foot off the gas after adding their fourth, however, and the Blues still failed to threaten at any point during the game in front of goal.