
Manchester United's last two displays against Chelsea and Swansea City showed a fair bit of improvement compared to the shocking run of games against Wolfsburg, Bournemouth, Norwich and Stoke City. They did so with two recognised 'pacey' players. On the left wing there was Anthony Martial, and in the right full back position was Ashley Young. In the dismal games preceding Chelsea, United probably had more pace, because as well as Martial, Memphis Depay and Jesse Lingard featured, yet United struggled badly. One reason is that Depay and Lingard are proving that they are not yet up to playing consistently for Manchester United. They may prove so in time. One of the biggest reasons though is that the 'Sch-midfield' were re-deployed against Chelsea.
New midfield signings have been missed
Bastian Schweinsteiger played against Wolfsburg but was quite ineffective, before a three-game league suspension. Morgan Schneiderlin missed all four defeats. It was quite surprising to see his continued omission and not much of a surprise to see the immediate improvement when he and Schweinsteiger were back in tandem. Despite United's lack of pace, United looked a lot quicker, playing at a higher tempo and the most important aspect was that they moved the ball quickly. A football moves quicker than any player, and although neither performance was flawless, by shifting the ball quicker they opened up space and created more chances than they had for quite some time. However, although the catalyst were the expensive midfield summer recruits, the win against Swansea was achieved, to a large extent, as a result pace.
United's best two players against Swansea were Martial and Young. If United were going to score a goal, you always felt that it was going to come from one of those outlets. Indeed, that is how things panned out. Young showed that although he is playing as a defender, he still has the quality in the wide attacking areas and his cross for Martial's header was perfect. Martial has rare ability, and will become a special player in time. He still shows inconsistency, but yesterday he once again glided past defenders and he created Wayne Rooney's goal brilliantly although the captain still had a lot to do to finish it off. Having two quick players of genuine quality is not enough though.
Of all the other midfielders and forwards, you wouldn't label anyone quick, and you are more likely the describe them as 'not slow'. There are a couple of exceptions though. Rooney himself is one. He used to have a burst of pace over five or ten yards, but that is getting less and less apparent. His brain gets him the odd yard or two of space and he rarely stops working, but playing as the number nine he is not able to get beyond a defence. He did on a couple of occasions in the away game at Everton, scoring once, but he also had about a five-yard start with his second and still allowed the defender get back close enough to put him off. Rooney is by no means the slowest. That accolade, unfortunately, goes to the diminutive Spaniard, Juan Mata.
Mata's quality not enough at times
Mata is an enigma. He is undoubtedly a top quality player. In terms of statistics, he must be up there in terms of goals and assists since his arrival at Old Trafford in January 2014. Signed for a fee of around £37.1 million, you might be forgiven for expecting that. Despite him being United's creative spark in terms of numbers, he has to be accommodated and when he is delivering it is great, but when he doesn't he is the main problem. United have to accommodate Mata. Generally, his position is a wide forward position on the right. You can say that is his starting position because he rarely stays in that position. It can work to good effect when he drifts inside, as it can give defenders a problem with regard to who picks him up. It can also give United a problem by taking up space in the already congested the central areas.
What that also does is put the onus on the full back to provide width on the right-hand side. Young and Antonio Valencia before his injury, are both willing to do a shift and did so to good effect, but when an out and out defender plays at full back you are losing out on a real attacking threat on that side. You are also exposed defensively because Mata provides no support. The odd occasion he does get back into defensive positions he is suspect as it is not natural to him, and he is inclined to go to ground too easy. It can result in free kicks, or him out of the game. When he has played in behind the striker at times this season, he has failed to really shine. It should be ideal for him, as with relatively no defensive responsibility he should be able to pick up the ball in the areas between the opposition midfield and defenders and cause havoc. It just hasn't happened.
He has touch, vision, can pass long and short and can score goals. I doubt too may United fans have a bad word to say about him, especially after his Anfield heroics last year, and he is such a likeable person. He hurts after every bad performance and rarely has a bad word to say about anybody. He held no grudges after his exit from Chelsea, and you have to admire his positive outlook. One of the reasons for his Chelsea exit is the fact that he needs to be accommodated. Chelsea set up their team to get Mata on the ball, for him to direct proceedings in the final third, and to great effect. However, Jose Mourinho doesn't accept that one player should be so key to the team, and neither does Louis van Gaal. Javier Hernandez - a goalscorer with pace - could have thrived throughout his United career had van Gaal set the team up to use his strengths. He didn't, and Hernandez is showing what he can do now in the Bundesliga. Yet van Gaal is obviously a fan of Mata's and continues to play him.
Herrera, Fellaini and Mata for No.10 role?
There is no one solution, and it is not to suggest that Mata's days at Old Trafford are numbered. United need to try and inject more pace and quality into the team. Schneiderlin and Schweinsteiger continue to be important and keeping them injury and suspension free will ensure that the tempo is high. However, Mata deployed wide right gives too many problems and until better quality with real pace can be used in there, then United are still going to be living in hope as to whether Mata will be an influence or not. Young could do the job with a full back in behind, but both Depay and Lingard, currently injured, are not really providing a cutting edge. If United do find someone with pace and quality it would leave Mata to compete with Ander Herrera and Marouane Fellaini for the position behind Rooney. That would be a tough call to make.
Herrera is also a fans favourite and he gives more bite. He is also creative, can score goals but has more pace than Mata. If someone passes Herrera he has the ability to chase back and recover. With Mata, once a player gets beyond him, he is gone. Think Peter Reid in 1986 treading water for England against Argentina when Maradona scored THAT goal. Fellaini is not exactly a fans favourite, but most fans are at least prepared to accept that whilst he is not a 'typical' United player, his mere presence on the pitch causes problems for the opposition. His height means that opponents cannot ignore him, so just by being on the pitch he needs looking after. He scores goals, and whilst he is not as gifted as either of the Spaniards, he is a much better footballer than he gets credit for. It is a conundrum that van Gaal must solve, but it is unlikely the solution will come with new recruits. January is not the transfer window where major signings move from one big club to another. With the exception of Juan Mata, of course.

