What has gone wrong for Garnacho at Man United?

Ruben Amorim’s stance on his relationship with Alejandro Garnacho was made clear on the final day of the Premier League season.

The Manchester United boss reportedly said that the Argentina winger must ‘pray’ that he ‘finds a new club’ amid a stark ending to an even duller overall season for the Red Devils.

United finished 15th in the Premier League - their lowest position since the 1973-74 season when they were relegated from the First Division - and lost out on silverware when they fell to a 1-0 defeat against Tottenham Hotspur in the Europa League final.

If United won in Bilbao it would have certainly lifted the mood around the club at the end of a drab 2024-25 campaign but has instead driven those feelings further into the ground.

To add to their misery, United went on a post-season tour of Southeast Asia where they played twice, and shockingly lost their first game against ASEAN All-Stars.

Muang Muang Lwin scored with under 20 minutes to go in Kumbar Lumpur before boos and jeers rang around the National Stadium which was bursting with 72,550 supporters.

Garnacho came on as a substitute in that fixture before starting against Hong Kong in the final game of the tour, which United won 3-1.

However, a move for the winger is most likely after a turbulent last six months at the club has left him with very little alternative options.

Where did it all start between Garnacho and Amorim?

When Amorim took charge of United in November last year, he was almost stubborn in his tactical approach.

The former Sporting manager found success at the Liga Portugal side with his 3-4-3 system and felt he could emulate that with United, but it never came.

If anything, Amorim’s style caused more harm than good and was the reason why red flags cropped up in training and, subsequently, in the media too.

Garnacho struggled to find form under Amorim (Photo by Marc Atkins/Getty Images)
Garnacho struggled to find form under Amorim (Photo by Marc Atkins/Getty Images)

Garnacho’s natural style is that of a wide player, but Amorim’s set-up doesn’t accommodate that so moving him to a more central role was the only option.

This could be partly why Garnacho was exposed by Amorim for a lack of effort in training, alongside Marcus Rashford - both of whom were dropped from the squad against Manchester City in December.

An uptrend in form and mentality (that lasted just 110 days)

It was on February 1 that Amorim praised Garnacho for an instant mentality shift that saw him perform better in training and as a result gain more minutes.

But the 40-year-old’s system still didn’t suit Garnacho’s preferred style of football and it was on the night of the Europa League final where the winger reached boiling point.

Only 110 days after Amorim’s praisal, Garnacho came on after 70 minutes in the final in Bilbao before watching his Spurs counterparts lift the title in triumph.

Garnacho’s brother indirectly hit out at Amorim after the game by posting a photo of the United winger, with the caption: “Working as [hard as] no one else, helping every round, coming from two goals [in the] last two finals just to be on the pitch [for] 19 minutes and get thrown under the bus, wow.”

Garnacho has made 144 appearances for Man United (Photo by Stu Forster/Getty Images)
Garnacho has made 144 appearances for Man United (Photo by Stu Forster/Getty Images)

That statement grew further concern around the future of Garnacho at United after he himself also cast doubts over where he will be next.

“Up until the final I played every round helping the team, and today I play 20 minutes, I don’t know,” said Garnacho.

“The final will influence [my decision] but the whole, the situation of the club. I’m going to try to enjoy the summer and see what happens afterwards.”

That is when Amorim followed up by saying that Garnacho should “pray that you can find a club to sign you”, which almost asserted his imminent exit to either another Premier League outfit, or somewhere overseas this summer.

Recent reports by Fabrizio Romano also stated that an agreement has been made between both the club and player for a departure in due course.

Where next for Garnacho?

Even with his vast experience of playing over 140 games for United, people forget that Garnacho is still only 20 years of age.

According to TransferMarkt, Garnacho has had the interest of Atletico Madrid, Napoli and Chelsea as of January this year, with the latter two most likely to grab the winger.

Napoli sold Khvicha Kvaratskhelia to Paris Saint-Germain earlier this year for a fee of £59m and have been left without a replacement despite winning the Serie A title.

Garnacho would be viewed as a deft addition to Antonio Conte’s side, though he has used a similar system to Amorim over the course of this season.

The 20-year-old is a graduate of United's academy (Photo by John Peters/Getty Images)
The 20-year-old is a graduate of United's academy (Photo by John Peters/Getty Images)

A stay in the English top-flight could also ensue for the winger as Enzo Maresca remains interested in the winger.

Chelse have held talks with Borussia Dortmund’s Jamie Gittens, offering him a seven-year stay at Stamford Bridge.

The Blues stated that they are ready to pay £30m, but Dortmund are wanting an additional £10m on top of that to reach an agreement.

Garnacho is valued at approximately £40m too, so if Dortmund remain stubborn on 20-year-old Gittens, a switch to the Argentina winger would be expected.