
According to reports from Fabrizio Romano, Newcastle United are set to announce the signing of Southampton goalkeeper Aaron Ramsdale on a season-long loan deal, with the option to make the move permanent next summer.
The deal brings an end to Newcastle’s chase for a new shot stopper, as the five cap England international goalkeeper will arrive at St James’ Park after the Magpies failed to secure the signature of James Trafford, who moved to Manchester City.
However, whilst Trafford was expected to slot into the side as the number one goalkeeper, Ramsdale’s position is less clear, as he was not the primary target following his relegation from the Premier League last season with Southampton.
Although both him and current number one Nick Pope will likely get opportunities to impress due to the plethora of fixtures, including in the Champions League, that Newcastle will play this season, Ramsdale will have to displace Pope if he is to become Eddie Howe’s starting keeper.
With that being said, in this piece we compare the goalkeepers and see who is more likely to be handed the gloves at the start of the season.
Howe has History with both
Although it will not benefit either of them individually in this comparison, one advantage to Newcastle of signing Aaron Ramsdale is that Eddie Howe is extremely familiar with the talents of both of his goalkeeping options, and this trust could be crucial if the Toon are to mirror their successful campaign from last season.
Indeed, Nick Pope was signed in Eddie Howe’s first summer transfer window in charge of Newcastle, and he has been the Magpies’ first choice in goal since his arrival from Burnley in 2022.
Meanwhile, Howe signed Aaron Ramsdale for Bournemouth back in 2016, and after successful loan spells at Chesterfield and AFC Wimbledon he broke through to the senior team for the 2019/20 season.
Although his time in the first team at the Cherries was limited by their relegation from the Premier League, Howe will have been watching Ramsdale’s potential and his development for years.
Both goalkeepers clearly have a strong relationship with their manager, and although it is unhelpful when considering which player will be the number one, both players being in the position where they are trusted by their manager will be hugely advantageous for Newcastle when fixture congestion starts to play a part later in the season and rotation becomes necessary.
The Underlying Metrics
Beyond the relationship they hold with their manager, goalkeeping statistics also serve as a crucial indicator of who may be poised to start in goal for Newcastle.
When looking at data on FBref, both players appear to be fairly similar when considering their shot stopping ability.
Indeed, when looking at saves made, the two keepers are almost indistinguishable. Ramsdale made more saves per game (4 vs 3.07), but Pope had a higher save percentage (67.6 per cent vs 71.7 per cent).
However, this data has the caveat that Ramsdale was playing for one of the worst teams in Premier League history last season, while Pope was helping his side fight for Champions League football.
This means that Ramsdale inevitably faced more shots, and with a higher xG, meaning that he had more chance to make saves to boost rates and figures, but was also more likely to concede goals.
This difference can also be used to explain why Ramsdale played significantly more long passes than his counterpart (686 vs 351), but at a lower success rate (37.5 percent vs 43 percent) as his teammates were less able to retrieve possession regardless of the quality of pass, meaning that the ball had to be cleared longer to avoid dangerous turnovers.
However, one metric that takes the quality of team out of the equation is PSxG, meaning Post Shot Expected Goals, which is the chance of a shot going in once it’s been taken.
The ambition for goalkeepers is to have a positive PSxG, meaning that they save more shots than they are expected to concede. However, Ramsdale performed disappointingly in this data category, as his metric was -0.08 per game, which is notably worse than Pope who overachieved with 0.06.
Given that Pope is now 33 years old with his contract expiring next summer, it is possible that Newcastle have signed Ramsdale on loan with the ambition of watching his performances this season to identify if he is capable of replacing Pope, either as the first choice or the understudy to a potential new signing, should he leave the club next season.
With the two players producing similar performance levels, Newcastle fans will have to be patient and wait to see which of Ramsdale or Pope are given the responsibility of starting in goal.
Should the transfer be completed as expected, then Ramsdale may be set to make his debut on the 16th August, when Newcastle travel to Villa Park on the opening day of the Premier League season.

