
Newcastle will face League 2 side AFC Wimbledon in the third round of the Carabao Cup as the magpies scraped past Nottingham Forest on a humid night at the City Ground.
The toon started very brightly, scoring after just 18 seconds. Joe Willock, recently returned from a long-term achilles tendon injury, latched onto the rebound from Alexander Isak's low shot.
Unfortunately for Willock, it appears he may be spending more time in the doctor's room, as he limped off after just 15 minutes, with a suspected thigh injury.
Despite a very bright start, the Magpies never looked comfortable and dropped off deep, allowing the hosts to maintain constant pressure on the Newcastle goal.
Taiwo Awoniyi missed the biggest chance of the half, as his header from no more than six yards out somehow missed the target following a deep free-kick, in which Nick Pope remained rooted to the spot.
The Toon held a 1-0 lead going into the second half, but the Reds continued after the break where they left off in the first half, eventually getting their reward, Jota Silva striking into the top right corner, on his home debut, following a long-throw in from the left.
The last twenty minutes was a clear improvement from the Magpies however, Howe's subs brought fresh legs and a more attacking mindset.
Tino Livramento combined well with Harvey Barnes, before the latter struck just wide, and Lewis Hall forced a save out of Forest keeper Carlos Miguel.
However, the next goal proved out of reach for both teams and so the contest was to be decided with a penalty shootout, as there is no extra-time in the Carabao Cup.
The hosts won both coin tosses, electing to have the penalties taken at the Trent End, before choosing to take first. Callum Hudson-Odoi duly stood up and fired past Pope, before Isak cooly slotted it past Miguel, leaving it a 1-1 after a penalty each.
Nikola Milenkovic proceeded to score, before Joelinton had his penalty saved by Miguel, who performed exceptionally in his first home game for the club. The Reds' advantage was increased even further, as Nico Williams found the back of the net.
Bruno Guimaraes had to score, and did, as he slotted the ball into the bottom right corner, before Ibrahim Sangaré hit the bar to allow the Toon an opportunity back into the game. Anthony Gordon, placed the ball past Miguel, meaning that the teams were tied at 3-3 on penalties, with one remaining.
Up stepped Awoniyi who proceeded to blaze his penalty over the bar, and halfway up the Trent End, allowing Sean Longstaff to step up and score the winning penalty, sending Miguel the wrong way.
The cups are the only realistic chance of silverware for the Magpies this season, so to make it through to the next round will be a confidence builder, and with AFC Wimbledon up next, they should find themselves a round-of-16 place.
Newcastle Plater Ratings
GK - Nick Pope - 6
While there was nothing he could do about Jota's bullet strike, Pope was more cautious at the City Ground, and appeared less confident on crosses, as seen with Awoniyi's glaring miss at the back post.
Only one save in the game, and he couldn't repeat his heroics of the Carabao Cup game against Crystal Palace, where he saved a remarkable three penalties. Good in possession however, with an accurate pass percentage north of 78%
RB - Kieran Trippier - 6
After impressing on Sunday's draw with Bournemouth, Trippier was given his chance to start in Nottingham. Appearing short of fitness, he was tidy, but with not much threat in the attacking half of the pitch.
CB - Emil Krafth - 7
Another solid game from the Swede, who is looking reliable in Schar's absence. 80 touches with 64 successful passes is a solid return, especially with Tottenham representing a tough test on Sunday, as Newcastle continue to try and play out from the back.
CB - Dan Burn - 8
Another very good performance from Burn who looked a class above the rest of the defence at points in Nottingham. An alert clearance off the line early in the game, followed by key tackles later on in the game. 46 passes, all of them complete, and dominant in the air as usual. One of Newcastle's most important players right now.
LB - Lewis Hall - 5
Perhaps the decision to drop Hall for the weekend game against Bournemouth was justified. An unusually poor performance from the Surrey-born youngster today, with his defensive positioning very poor at times, he had to be bailed out by Burn and other members of the defence at regular intervals.
CM - Sandro Tonali - 7
This game proved to Newcastle fans just how important Tonali is to the side. Coming back from a 10-month suspension, the Italian was involved in the first goal, and almost made it two after just three minutes.
His overall game looked in a good place, and there were emotional scenes at the end, as he repaid the faith the Geordie faithful had put in him.
CM - Joelinton - 5
Following on from a 2020 Joelinton performance on Sunday, the Brazilian was poor in an unfamiliar position at the City Ground. Playing in Guimaraes' usual role, he looked fazed at times, and failed to assert himself on the game. A penalty shoot-out miss just added to his poor performance.
CM - Joe Willock - 7
What a shame. Brilliant in the opening 10 minutes, with great instinctive play to follow in Isak's shot, the midfielder's energy makes the Toon a completely different team. However, his injuries are clearly a problem, and if the situation isn't resolved soon, Newcastle may need to cash in to find more reliable options.
RW - Miguel Almiron - 6
His brilliant pass in the first fifteen seconds for Isak to run onto was the highlight of an unremarkable game from Almiron. Denied by a good save from Miguel later into the first half, an energetic display was ended when he was subbed off on 60 minutes. With Fulham lurking, he may have played his final game for the club.
ST - Alexander Isak - 5
Another poor game for the Swede, but a lack of service isn't helping him. Made up for it with a calm penalty in the shoot-out, but his indifferent form will be a worry for Howe. A mere 28 touches, with one chance created, which was in the third minute.
LW - Harvey Barnes - 6
Thrown in from the start following his strong performance off the bench at Bournemouth. Provided a clear threat down both sides and was unlucky not to have scored as his low drive struck the side netting. Played his way into contention to start on Sunday against Spurs.
Substitutes
Bruno Guimaraes - 6
Subbed on for Willock, Bruno was not up to his usual high standards, but still was dominant in midfield. A good penalty backed up his performance, with five duels won in midfield, and 35 accurate passes across the pitch.
Anthony Gordon - 6
Gordon still has not hit the heights of last season, but provided a good cameo appearance in Nottingham. 95% successful passes and three key passes lifted the tempo of the match, before slotting an important penalty past Miguel.
Tino Livramento - 7
Offered something different to Trippier for the half an hour he was on the pitch for. Got forward at will and almost got an assist following a good run along the byline. Five duels won and 95% accurate passes, as he provided stability and calmness. In a better position than he was at the start of play to start against Tottenham.
Sean Longstaff - 6.5
Subbed on for Tonali in the 60th minute, the North-Shields-born midfielder, may not match the technical ability of the Italian, but his constant hard work provides a reliable backup option. Cleaned up in midfield as Forest looked to counter, but unremarkable.
A good winning penalty in the shootout ensured the toon made it to round three.

