Four things we learnt from Newcastle’s narrow defeat to Barcelona
Eddie Howe crouching on the touchline against Barcelona. (Photo by Stu Forster/Getty Images)

Newcastle United could not mimic the magic of their Champions League debut upon their return to the competition after a season long hiatus. They again hosted Barcelona at St. James' Park but ended up on the wrong side of a one-goal margin, losing 2-1 thanks to a Marcus Rashford brace.

Here are four things we learned from a disappointing defeat within a positive performance.

  • Good but not great in the key moments

Goals win games, and again, Newcastle missed the moments when they needed to strike decisively.

Within the first five minutes of the match, Newcastle engineered the ideal situation. Anthony Elanga got running on the right flank in a serious speed mismatch for Gerard Martin, and Gordon again showed his sharp movement inside the box to peel off Ronald Araujo, but he miskicked the ball.

Then came another breakaway in minute 23. Bruno Guimaraes had the guile and awareness to delay a decisive action, leaving Elanga to get on his bike and charge down the wing again. This time, his target was Harvey Barnes in the penalty area, but Joan Garcia got his body in the way of the ball.

The shot stopper for the Blaugrana has been an excellent pickup from Espanyol, but this story still feels all too familiar for the fans at St. James' Park barely one full month into their new campaign.

Yoane Wissa is still recovering from the knee injury he suffered on international duty, while Howe is trying to gently ease Nick Woltemade into life on Tyneside. However, the ghost of Alexander Isak and his talismanic presence as a nine still hangs over the Toon, who are doing so many things well.

  • Howe has flexibility in his forward options

It was clear that the attack needed a different dynamic. Elanga was getting success over Martin, but Barnes was struggling to get away clean crosses or shots against Jules Kounde. Even if all their tools are not neatly in place, Howe had the option to try to ask new questions of Barcelona after the break.

The introduction of Woltemade after the first hour meant that Gordon could go back to his favoured flank on the left in place of Barnes and bring an even higher level of threat in that area of the field.

On his part, the German got only a little involvement with the ball, but his link-up and creativity were visible in those flashes. A neat flick helped open a shooting opportunity for Guimaraes, and he held onto the ball with his back to the play to release the room to find Gordon from out wide for his goal.

Jacob Murphy, who has been nursing an Achilles injury, also came off to play from the right wing in the final phase of the contest. He is a hard working figure who has allowed Howe to switch to a back five in-game before, but his devilish deliveries make the most impact, and one of them set up Gordon.

Pace, power, and directness are still the name of the game for Newcastle, but the group is evolving.

  • The midfield motors meet their match

A big talking point before the game was whether the midfield trident of Newcastle would impose itself in the same way that it does weekly in the Premier League against the craft of the Blaugrana.

Guimaraes, Sandro Tonali, and Joelinton excel with their sharpness on the ball and, above all, the physicality, running power, and dirtiness to muddy up the middle of the park for most opponents they face. However, the task of taking down Pedri and Frenkie de Jong is a different challenge altogether.

It was a good battle. The Toon held it together in the first half, but they could not keep a lid forever on a pair of players who had the willingness to work on top of their technical quality and intelligence.

It is impossible to prevent Pedri from pulling out magic for a full 90 minutes. Whether it was his passing, agility off the ball, or his slaloming carries, he cut Newcastle open on several occasions.

The biggest nights in the Champions League are often a reminder that technical excellence can have an answer for even the most powerful and physical players in the game. This clash was no exception, and it forced Howe to look for something different in the final half hour in the form of Joe Willock.

  • The spirit of 1997 lives on

After missing out on Europe last season, Newcastle were marking their return to the Champions League for only the second time since 2003 with a re-run of their iconic debut under Kenny Dalglish.

The Toon beat Barcelona 3-2 in their first Champions League fixture thanks to a hat-trick from Tino Asprilla in front of the fans at St. James' Park. The dream was that this team could do the same.

Football is not full of fairytales at the highest level: the best players are on a platform where they can prove they are a cut above the rest. However, it has been a magical ride for Newcastle in the last four years under Howe, and the club did their best to embrace the emotional aspects of this occasion.

The Geordies are always a passionate bunch in the stands, and fight is never something supporters have to question anymore about their team with their manager. But the club clearly leaned into their history with the Blaugrana without failing to put on a professional performance on the evening.

The PSR pinch might have constrained what the club could do this summer, but Howe has a knack for keeping the camp competitive. He knows how to get more than expected out of the group, and playing into the advantage of the cauldron that is their ground might make a massive difference in Europe.