
When Spurs appointed Postecoglou, I knew little about him other than he'd achieved what almost every manager at Celtic achieved. However, upon inspecting his career trajectory to that point I saw someone who had succeeded wherever he'd been, and each time on a higher plain than previously.
When I heard what others had to say about the Greco-Australian, it was that he only believed in one way of playing and that this style would be in sync with Spurs' values.
When I finally heard the man speak, I sensed that he knew what he was getting into, was happy to be judged within the parameters of the club, and that he in no way thought the North London club should be grateful to him for joining in stark contract with two of the three previous appointments.
My expectation was a season where Spurs would push, and maybe succeed, for the top four playing more attractive football than the club had seen in recent seasons, and that the manager would take accountability for that.
More hot mess than Hotspur
That this was ultimately what took place might suggest that Postecoglou only hit par, particularly given the disappointing early cup exits, but this would ignore the circumstances surrounding the club:
- Harry Kane, the shining light of N17, was sold on the eve of the season.
- An extremely young defence of whom of the regular starters only Romero had entered the second half of his twenties, that same player the only one signed before the year 2023.
- A hugely discontented fan base with loud calls for ENIC and Daniel Levy to sell the club.
- No obvious captain with Kane gone and once untouchable Hugo Lloris lasting six more months only due to Nice's lack of gumption in approaching him.
- A squad filled with players bought across several seasons, for several managers, with no identifiable footballing philosophy to unite them and who now had to embrace Postecoglou's more progressive mantra.
When you bake all of the above in, you end up with a lemon drizzle beef wellington with a side dish of pickled milk. A complete mess, and I don't mean my metaphor.
Come May, the Spurs season has finished with more points, more goals scored, fewer goals conceded and three places higher than the last. Postecoglou's side started the season brilliantly, playing superb attacking football and clicking into gear far earlier than anybody expected.
While the club never fully recovered from that fateful night in November against Chelsea, with the season subsequently becoming one of stops and starts, the club had in many ways already achieved what it had set at to, or at least fulfilled the expectations I described earlier.
Progress
A look at the broad statistics tell you that Spurs has improved in most aspects from the previous season. The "eye" test will suggest that at points the North London side has played the most exciting football seen on Tottenham High Road since at least the height of the Pochettino era, if not far longer.
The noises coming out of the club will tell the story of relative harmony for the first time in a long time, with the board unified behind the manager and the majority of players, even those used less frequently, enjoying life under the man from Nea Filadelfeia.
Another fallow season
Progress, however, is never linear, and there have been valid questions asked of some of Postecoglou's decisions. The earliest instance dates back to August 2023, when Spurs' heavily rotated side lost at the first time of asking in the Carabao Cup, beaten on penalties by Fulham.
The Spurs manager argued that with no European football, this was the best chance he'd have to see his wider squad. Many supporters of the club felt that, having failed to win any trophy since 2008, this would damn them to end the season empty handed nine months in advance.
This is not the last time Postecoglou could be accused of being out of sync with the clubs supporters. While it isn't his job to pander to those less qualified than him to assess priorities, some more empathy with his audience wouldn't hurt in these moments.
In game management
Throughout the season questions could be asked of Postecoglou's substitutions, almost always favouring like of like chances without much by added impetus off the bench.
However, Spurs strength in depth largely lay deeper on the pitch, players like Hojbjerg, Lo Celso and Bentancur (if not starting) far more proven than the attacking options available.
The long term injuries to Perisic (before being transferred) and Solomon, with Richarlison also struggling to stay fit, didn't help. Even Werner saw his season ended prematurely after his promising start to life at Spurs.
Johnson, Son and Kulusevski were the only Spurs attackers able to give Postecoglou upwards of 30 league matches. As such, it feels unfair to criticise a manager for not having his full armoury of forwards regularly available.
Stubborn as a Spartan
The most common debate, at least once Spurs' season began to falter, was around whether or not Postecoglou was being overly dogmatic in his philosophy.
A high line without Van de Ven, Spurs' only truly rapid defender, had many calling the Spurs manager inflexible, while the insistence on inverted full backs even when Udogie and/or Porro were unavailable often felt unnecessary given how ill suited that role is to Davies and Emerson.
What began as applause for Postecoglou's refusal to sacrifice his style when down to nine men v Chelsea later on became frustration that he seemingly cared more about implementing his style than he did about winning.
In return, he'd assert that a quick fix to maybe win an extra match or two was not worth sacrificing the continued indoctrination into "Angeball" he was attempting with the Spurs squad.
I'd be inclined to agree, given that the players unsuited to his style are unlikely to be at the club considerably longer than they need to be, having seen enough of what it could be in that first two months of the season.
Now ex Chelsea manager Pochettino's first season was not much different, with some highlights but generally inconsistent results punctuated by a couple of great performance, and once the wheat had been sorted from the chaff Spurs went on to enjoy the club's best sequence of league finishes since the 1960s while playing some of the best football in the country.
Win at any cost (unless it helps Arsenal)
I earlier raised the question of Postecoglou's empathy with the Spurs faithful, and this reared it's head towards the end of the season when faces with the rearranged visit of Manchester City.
Win, and the title would almost certainly end up painfully nearby on the Seven Sisters road. Lose, and the blue half of Manchester would be all but crowned champions of England for the fourth consecutive season.
Postecoglou was in no way willing to entertain the thought that Spurs should want anything but victory in the match, and I completely agreed with him (and am on record as doing so on episode 117 of The Spurs Plus Dave Pocast).
However, as Spurs supporters who potentially have to live with the pain of seeing their rivals winning a title, there was a strong feeling that winning this match, maybe qualifying for the Champions League, a fleeting joy, did not outweigh the negatives if it secured Spurs' most bitter rivals a championship.
Postecoglou's mistake was not so much that he didn't realise the strength of feeling, but that he dismissed it in both the build up and aftermath to the match. It never sits well with football fans to see a manager confronting them.
The ex Celtic manager did well to communicate with a little more understanding in his next press conference, which combined with the rightful goodwill he has generated will have placated the masses.
Time to shine
When I started out stating Postecoglou has been successful so far, I expected to write more of a love letter than this.
However, my view at this end of the piece remains the same, Postecoglou's first season at Spurs has been a success. Perhaps not unadulterated, and certainly not without lessons for the 58 year old to learn from.
However, at 38 years old, I can recall almost all of Spurs' time as a Premier League club (as opposed to the old First Division) and when the side did click into gear this season, it was as exhilarating as the best Tottenham sides I've seen.
Having briefly drunk the Kool-aid of "elite" managers Conte and Mourinho, and seen the club fall flat on its face both times, watching the club play football as my father taught me it should be played, with verve and panache, is not negotiable.
That there have been hiccups is immaterial, as this was the first year with an almost entirely new side, a young side, which had lost the player on whom it had relied for almost a decade.
I've already listed the metrics by which Postecoglou has tangibly improved Spurs from the 2022/23 season.
Now I look forward to next August with the hope that the foundations are in place for an even better season, with consistently high quality attacking football, more points on the board again, and maybe even a trophy.
With backing from Daniel Levy and ENIC in the summer, I have ever faith that next season Spurs supporters will again be singing "I'm loving Big Ange instead".

