
On a night filled with drama and emotion, Newcastle advanced to the fourth round of the EFL Cup, but they needed penalties to do so.
The Magpies had a dream start when Joe Willock put the away side ahead after just 18 seconds.
Nottingham Forest controlled much of the game and got their much-deserved equaliser in the 50th minute after a thunderous effort from new man Jota Silva.
The game ebbed and flowed after that, and ultimately, penalties were required. Newcastle won 4-3, with Geordie Sean Longstaff scoring the winning penalty.
Story of the Match
Hosts Nottingham Forest made wholesale changes to the team that beat Southampton at the weekend, with only Elliot Anderson keeping his place; he was set to start against his boyhood team.
Nuno Espírito Santo gave four players their Forest debuts: Alex Moreno, Eric Moreira, Ramón Sosa and goalkeeper Carlos Miguel all took the field wearing the red of Nottingham Forest for the first time. Taiwo Awoniyi made his first start for Forest since February.
Eddie Howe named a relatively strong team, indicating his side's intentions of competing for a domestic trophy this season and ending their near 60-year wait for silverware.
There were six changes to the team that survived a last-minute scare against Bournemouth at the weekend.
The headline was the inclusion of Italian midfielder Sandro Tonali in the starting XI. The former AC Milan man had been suspended for 10 months for breaching betting rules and was playing his first competitive game since the backend of October 2023.
There was a first start of the season for England full-back Kieran Trippier as well as Harvey Barnes, who impressed coming off the bench at the weekend.
As has been the case across all EFL Cup games this week, before kick-off, both sides took a moment to remember former England manager Sven-Göran Eriksson.
It only took 18 seconds for Newcastle United to take the lead; Miguel Almirón played a perfectly weighted ball into the path of Alexander Isak, whose effort was palmed into the path of Joe Willock, who had the luxury of the whole net to aim at, and he did not falter.
Forest keeper Miguel should have done much better with Newcastle's first effort; it was far from the ideal start for the debutant.
Just a minute later, Tonali very nearly had the dream return to action when Isak put him through, but Miguel did much better this time around and denied the Italian.
The game was being played at a frantic pace, resembling a basketball match, as the ball went up one end and then immediately down the other in the blink of an eye. You simply could not look away from the action for a single moment. It was almost as if there were no midfielders on the pitch as both sides cut through one another with ease.
Dan Burn cleared off the line after Nick Pope mis-punched a cross, which very nearly went in his own goal. The big defender was there to clear up after his keeper.
Goal scorer Willock had to be brought off after picking up a knock; he was replaced by Bruno Guimarães. Willock cut an incredibly frustrated figure as he came off the pitch; the 25-year-old only started nine games for the Toon Army last season due to injury and had seemingly picked up yet another.
Newcastle put together a gorgeous move that started in their own box and ended with a well-saved Almirón shot. Eddie Howe' s side looked a lot brighter than they had done in their lethargic draw away at Bournemouth at the weekend. The passing was crisp, the forwards were interchanging and making life difficult for the Forest defence, and Tonali had started the game as if he had never been away.
Every time Forest ventured forward, they were leaving themselves exposed to Newcastle. They were committing far too many players forward, and it seemed every time the North East side went forward on the break, they might very well score. But in Forest's defence, when they went forward, the moves looked threatening and tidy. They just lacked a killer pass into the feet of their forwards.
As the tie reached the 30th minute, it appeared to have become much calmer and resembled an actual game of football rather than the chaotic affair it had been for much of the first period.
Nottingham Forest were beginning to look like the better team. Former Newcastle man Elliot Anderson was pulling the strings in the heart of the midfield, and Nuno's side was starting to tick. The game was almost exclusively being played in Newcastle's half, as the away side struggled to alleviate the pressure created by their hosts.
The midfield battle between Anderson and Tonali was interesting. The two often marked each other, each getting the better of the other on occasion.
Awoniyi had an opportunity to level for Forest as a beautiful free kick was put into the corridor of uncertainty; Pope hesitated and did not come to meet it, and the Nigerian could not quite keep his shot down.
The Geordies were grateful to hear the half-time whistle, as Forest had turned on the pressure in the last 20 minutes of the half and showed no sign of letting up.
Five minutes into the second half, Forest had a richly deserved equaliser, and it came from new signing Jota Silva. Alex Moreno launched a long throw into the box, which the Newcastle defence did not deal with, and the ball found its way to the Portuguese winger, whose effort was a thunderbolt, striking the post before going in. Nick Pope could only stand motionless as the ball flew past him.
It was Silva's first start for the club, and the goal, a truly thumping effort, will undoubtedly live long in the memory of the City Ground faithful.
The goal did not liven Newcastle up; instead, Forest continued their assault on Howe's defence, with Silva and Anderson consistently causing problems.
It was Nuno Espírito Santo who made the first changes of the game, bringing on Nikola Milenković and Ibrahim Sangaré in place of Zach Abbott and goal scorer Silva, who may have impressed enough to play some role against Wolves at the weekend.
Not long after, Eddie Howe made a triple change to try and inject some life into his somewhat weary side, bringing on Tino Livramento, Sean Longstaff and Anthony Gordon for Trippier, Almirón and Tonali.
Sandro Tonali was impressive in his first game back, particularly in the first half; his performance may very well have earned him a place in the side for Sunday's match against Tottenham Hotspur.
It was clear that both sides wanted to avoid penalties, Nuno introduced Neco Williams and Callum Hudson-Odoi in an attempt to win the game in normal time.
Welsh full-back Williams almost set up a goal instantly, but Awoniyi could not get the ball out of his feet.
25 minutes into the second half, Newcastle finally started playing; Moreno blocked Barnes' close-range effort after a nice move from the Toon Army. Lewis Hall had a half chance from the edge of the box, which the youngster dragged wide.
Elliot Anderson was brought off to a warm applause from both sets of fans. The Newcastle academy graduate had been excellent all night, both offensively and defensively. Anthony Elanga came on in his place.
Dan Burn went close after a Forest somehow conspired to leave the 6ft7 centre-back unmarked from a corner; his header went just wide of the post.
Penalties were looming at the City Ground as Newcastle upped the ante in an effort to avoid spot kicks. Hall once again received the ball on the edge of the box; this time, his effort was much better and forced a good save from Miguel, who dove acrobatically to deny Newcastle.
In the end, penalties were needed to separate the sides after a highly entertaining cup tie.
The penalties were to be taken in front of the Forest fans at the Trent end after Willy Boly won the coin toss, and Forest would take first.
Hudson-Odoi stepped up for the first penalty and finished coolly.
Swede Isak took Newcastle's first spot-kick and had no problems; making it 1-1.
Milenković was up next for the home side and rolled it into the bottom right corner.
Joelinton took the second for the Toon Army and saw Miguel save his effort. There was not much wrong with the penalty; it was just a great stop by Miguel.
Williams looked to extend Forest's lead and did just that with a lovely penalty.
Newcastle captain Guimarães took the third spot kick and scored; after converting, he attempted to rally the Geordie fans.
Sangaré took the fourth for Forest but canoed his into the crossbar.
Gordon was up next and brought his side level with an excellent penalty to the bottom left.
We were in sudden death now, and Awoniyi stepped up. But his spot kick went miles over the bar, and it was now in Newcastle's hands. Score, and they win.
Local lad Sean Longstaff shouldered the burden, placing his penalty into the bottom right. The Magpies had won, but by no means had it been easy.
It was a testament to the character of this Newcastle team as they were under the cosh for the majority of this game and had been down in the shoot-out, but at no point did they give up.
-
Player of the Match- Elliot Anderson
Anderson had a tremendous night despite coming out on the losing side in the end. The former Newcastle midfielder put in an incredibly mature performance and looked very assured on the ball.
He looked unphased by the constant presence of Tonali and, at times, outclassed the Italian.
When the 21-year-old was brought off in the 80th minute, he received a very warm round of applause from both sets of fans and very much deserved it.

