Newcastle United have one foot in the Carabao Cup final after an inspired performance in North London last night. Eddie Howe’s side secured a 2-0 victory against a faltering Arsenal team, whose attempts to break down Newcastle's defence proved futile.
The Magpies are now poised to reach their second final in three seasons. To progress, they only need to avoid defeat - or lose by a single goal - in the second leg at St James’ Park on February 5.
While Newcastle’s success owed much to resilience, there were moments of good fortune - Gabriel Martinelli struck the post in the first-half, and Jurrien Timber headed over from close-range.
Backs against the wall
Above all, the players showed immense commitment, often throwing themselves in front of shots to deny Mikel Arteta’s men. Despite missing key players Bruno Guimarães and Fabian Schar, Newcastle looked far from overwhelmed by the occasion.
Newcastle posed a consistent threat on the counterattack during the first half. Alexander Isak, pivotal as an outlet for the visitors, linked effectively with in-form wingers Anthony Gordon and Jacob Murphy.
However, Newcastle’s failure to capitalise on early chances might have worried fans - particularly when Sandro Tonali fired over from 20 yards. The Magpies could have extended their lead if Murphy’s deliveries into the box had been slightly more accurate.
The breakthrough came from a set piece - an area Arsenal has excelled in this season. Rumoured Saudi-bound goalkeeper Martin Dúbravka launched the ball forward, and after Sven Botman’s flick-on, Isak lifted it over David Raya to score his 10th goal in nine matches across all competitions. A light-hearted remark from a fan welcoming Isak “home” to the Emirates might now seem regrettable.
Botman's excellent return
Particular praise must go to Botman, who has seamlessly returned after a 294-day absence due to an ACL injury. The Dutchman was instrumental in forming a formidable defensive unit that appeared untroubled in open play and handled the latest incarnation of Tony Pulis’ Stoke with composure.
Botman’s workload will need careful management, especially as Newcastle faces Bromley in the FA Cup this weekend. Having played over 180 minutes in four days, the medical staff will need to ensure the former Lille man’s recovery is not rushed.
More frustrations for Willock
Joe Willock, deputising for Guimarães, struggled to make an impact. This frustration was shared by the player who cut a dejected figure when he was substituted in the second half for Sean Longstaff. Persistent injuries have hindered Willock’s consistency since the unforgettable 2022/23 season, and given the ever-watching gaze of PSR, Newcastle may consider moving him on in the summer to secure a more reliable midfielder.
Another standout performer was 20-year-old left-back Lewis Hall, whose weekly improvement has silenced earlier doubts about his signing. Hall’s composure in possession and growing confidence have made him one of England’s most in-form left-backs.
Kai Havertz was shifted to the right-hand side, perhaps in the hope of creating a mismatch in the German’s favour. However, Hall never appeared unsettled, confidently dealing with the challenge. He expertly brought down several high balls under pressure while simultaneously holding off the former Chelsea player with ease.
An emotional goodbye
Goalkeeper Dúbravka also delivered a stellar performance, notably saving a close-range effort from Gabriel. Visibly emotional at full-time, Dúbravka’s clean sheet against Arsenal capped a remarkable career at Newcastle. The saga surrounding his move to Manchester United on loan had strained his relationship with fans, but his recent performances have restored his reputation.
What Newcastle will miss most is his comfort with the ball at his feet – something which does not come naturally to Nick Pope.
With rumours swirling about a potential move for James Trafford in the January transfer window, Pope’s position as Newcastle’s No. 1 may be under threat. In the meantime, Greek international Odysseus Vlachodimos is expected to make his competitive debut soon.
