
Confidence was clearly high as Newcastle dominated the opening half-hour, cutting through Manchester United with ease. Alexander Isak, in scintillating form, scored his eighth goal in six games, prompting delight from Howe while his managerial counterpart might have wished he’d stayed in Portugal.
Midfield Dominance
Benefiting from the hosts’ aging midfield pairing of Christian Eriksen and Casemiro, Newcastle’s trio of Bruno Guimarães, Sandro Tonali, and Joelinton dictated the tempo with ease. With 45% of the game played in midfield, they operated cohesively and looked like a formidable unit. Early concerns about whether this trio could effectively play together have now been put to bed.
If not for the first-half introduction of Kobbie Mainoo, replacing Joshua Zirkzee, it is easy to imagine a far more damaging scoreline for the hosts.
It was a quiet night for Newcastle’s form player, Jacob Murphy, as the team largely opted to attack down the left-hand side. Amid persistent rumours of his potential departure, Anthony Gordon has developed a formidable partnership with Lewis Hall.
Throughout the evening, Gordon tormented Noussair Mazraoui, tracked back to support his international teammate, and even provided an assist for Joelinton’s towering 19th-minute header.
We need to talk about Lewis Hall...
Special praise must go to Hall, who made a strong case for man of the match. Having featured only eight times in his debut season for Newcastle, Hall is quickly becoming indispensable.
His close control and passing ability—hallmarks of a player who spent his youth in central midfield—are exceptional. Defensively, he continues to improve, making several crucial blocks on the edge of Newcastle’s penalty area.
However, fans may have some concerns about his physicality and pace. While he uses his body effectively to shield the ball, his attempt to race onto a pass before the offside flag was raised felt as though the game was being played at 0.75 speed.
On the right side of defense, Kieran Trippier made his second consecutive start—the first time since early October. The set-piece specialist attempted to emulate Son Heung-min and Matheus Cunha by scoring directly from a corner, but despite his limited game time, he didn’t look out of place.
Unfortunately, Trippier pulled up with a hamstring issue in the second half. Though he was keen to continue, Howe replaced him in the 58th minute with Tino Livramento. If Trippier is set to leave the club in January or the summer, Newcastle will want to avoid unnecessary injuries complicating any potential transfer.
Changing for the Better
The biggest compliment to Newcastle is that their style of play is evolving for the better. In previous years, their success often relied on relentless, high-intensity performances.
Now, they are increasingly controlling games, sometimes without shifting out of second gear. Some may have criticised their second-half performance, but it likely reflected a tactical approach from Howe, who trusted his team’s defensive shape and ability to keep the opposition at bay.
This shift in style may also reflect the quality of their opponents, but it is a more sustainable long-term strategy. Much of this change is attributable to Tonali’s presence at the base of midfield. With Tonali receiving the ball in deeper positions, Guimarães can operate further up the pitch, where he is most effective.
Message to the Hierarchy
These recent performances send a strong message to Paul Mitchell and the broader Newcastle hierarchy. With fifth place potentially enough for Champions League football this season, the club must strengthen the squad in January. With a League Cup semi-final against Arsenal on the horizon, Newcastle will undoubtedly face challenges that require investment.
Fortunately, Sven Botman is close to returning from a long-term injury, reportedly missing out last night only due to illness. However, it may take some time for him to regain full match sharpness.
Above all, Newcastle desperately needs a quality right-winger to diversify their attack, which has often been one-dimensional this season. A player like Yohan Bakayoko (PSV), Bryan Mbeumo (Brentford), or Antoine Semenyo (Bournemouth) could be the solution.

