
Following the departure of David De Gea at the end of the 2023 season after 12 years at the club, the Red Devils brought in Champions League finalist André Onana from Inter Milan and Altay Bayındır from Fenerbahçe.
After Bayındır's man of the match performance against Arsenal in the FA Cup, there is a debate about whether Onana should no longer be the first-choice keeper after many disappointing performances during his time as Manchester United's goalkeeper.
Onana came into the club with high expectations after a brilliant previous season at Inter Milan, securing their 20th league title and only conceding 22 goals.
Alongside a brilliant year for the Italian giants, it wasn't solely the goalkeeping that caught the attention of Manchester United and former manager Erik Ten Hag. Having coached Onana during his time at Ajax, the Cameroonian prefers playing out from the back and having the ball at his feet.
Onana hasn't had the easiest career since joining Ajax in 2015 after leaving Barcelona the same year, due to him not being able to play for the Catalonian club as he was under 18 and a non-EU Citizen.
The goalkeeper had to go on loan to two lower-league Spanish sides UE Cornellà and Vista Alegre. However, in 2021 Onana was banned by UEFA after testing positive for Furosemide, he said he took his wife's medicine by accident and Ajax joined in his appeal. The ban was eventually reduced to nine months by the Court of Arbitration for Sport.
Bayındır has been talked about taking the number one spot at Old Trafford after another disappointing display against Brighton, he has been asked by many to be given a chance in the Premier League.
The Turkish international hasn't made a league appearance for the club yet since he joined the club from Fenerbahçe while recovering from a lumbar hernia operation.
During his stint at Fenerbahçe, he was a consistent and a good goalkeeper for the Turkish side. Despite never winning the league with the club, he was always in touching distance of the league but unable to get over the line.
Bayindir made his United debut against Newport County in the FA Cup on January 28 2024 in a 4-2 victory.
-
Why choose Onana?
As we have seen in other goalkeepers and even outfielders, high performance and consistency are achieved through confidence and stability.
This was seen during periods of last season, especially in the final games of last season where he received an average of 7.36 in match ratings and an average of 7.21 throughout the Premier League.
Onana was brought in as the first-choice keeper and has shown when he has confidence and the defence is strong, he can become one of the best keepers in the world again like he was at Inter Milan.
Onana suits Ruben Amorim's playstyle. With the attacking wing-backs and the high line of the back three, he is more suited as 'sweeper keeper' and is happy to play further up the pitch.
-
Why choose Bayındır?
Bayindir is full of confidence after a fantastic performance against title challengers Arsenal, not only with the shot-stopping but was also confident when coming to claim corners when many keepers have failed to properly defend them.
During his time at Fenerbahçe, he had a strong defence in front of him but when called upon he was ready to make the save and didn't concede many goals from outside the box, where many times this season Onana has failed too.
While confident with his hands he is also confident with the ball at his feet in his box, with a very good passing accuracy with an average of around 70%.
As Amorim continues to try and find his perfect team and which players will be best suited for his playstyle, there is a chance that Bayındır will continue to get his chances and prove himself to be Manchester United's first-choice goalkeeper for next season.
However, there is still a chance that if the Red Devils backline can become more secure and stop making mistakes, Onana will avoid making errors which grab everyone's attention.

