Tottenham 1-0 Man United: Post-Match Man United Player Ratings
RBruno Fernandes after 1-0 defeat to Spurs. (Photo by Alex Pantling - Getty images)

It was another disappointing defeat for Manchester United on Sunday evening as they dropped to 15th in the Premier League table following a 1-0 away loss at the Tottenham Hotspur stadium. James Maddison scored the only goal of the game after anticipating an Andre Onana error and following the ball into the back of the net.

It's been a difficult week for Reds as they've not only lost their 12th game of the season but have also lost key player Amad Diallo through an ankle injury for the remainder of the campaign. Other injuries to Kobbie Mainoo, Manuel Ugarte and Toby Collyer also saw them miss this important Premier League clash.

This quick build-up of injuries forced Ruben Amorim to overload the bench with youth prospects with Victor Lindelof being the only senior player amongst the group. The likes of Chido Obi-Martin, Sekou Kone and Jack Moorhouse were all involved in the matchday squad. Obi-Martin was the only one brought onto the field in the dying seconds of the game and therefore was unable to make an impact. 

Wasteful in front of goal

United had many chances to level the game but it was a familiar story in front of goal as countless opportunities were wasted across the entire front line and ultimately their wastefulness was punished. 

Questions over the benched youngsters

The question most United fans are asking is why were the youngsters on the bench given no minutes to prove themselves? Was this a mistake by Ruben Amorim or does he not think they're ready for the Premier League?

 

Here's how the players got on in North London.

Andre Onana - 5 

The United number one made some good saves throughout the match and was comfortable playing the ball out under pressure.

However, he could have dealt with the goal much better by either catching or pushing the ball further out wide. He got caught in the middle and pushed the ball perfectly in the path of James Maddison who anticipated the direction of the ball and tapped it into the back of the net. This was the only goal of the 90. 

Noussair Mazaroui - 6 

He was back in his seemingly better position as part of a back three today and noticeably looked more comfortable as he didn't have as much attacking responsibility. In saying that, he crossed a pinpoint ball on to the head of  Joshua Zirkzee that should have resulted in a goal. 

Harry Maguire - 6 

Played a few good long balls and stepped into the midfield to win the ball back on a couple of occasions. Mathys Tel managed to get a couple of attempts on goal but Maguire put enough pressure on the lad to see his attempts never trouble Onana.  Arguably should have located higher up the field sooner when United were pressing for an equaliser. 

Matthijs de Ligt - 5

Similarly to Maguire, he stepped up and won a few balls back in the midfield with his aggressive interceptions. However, his performance was let down by his static response to James Maddison following up the save for the goal. He also lacked composure and put the ball out for a corner on a couple of occasions rather than realising the amount of time he had to pick out a pass. 

Diogo Dalot - 4

He didn't follow the managers instructions when you could see Amorim telling him to get tighter to Heung-Min Son. Minutes later Son still had the space to volley in a cross that ultimately led to the goal.  He attempted a few crosses himself but none were accurate enough for anyone to get on the end of.

Bruno Fernandes - 6

As always, created numerous chances for his team. He slipped in a beautiful ball for Alejandro Garnacho and played some brilliant passes from deep to set his team on the counterattack. Despite his creativity he was tasked to play two positions at once which often meant him vacating the midfield a lot in the first half, resulting in Tottenham being able to easily play through the centre of the pitch. 

Casemiro - 4

His first start to 2025 and it was clear to see why. He was booked early on and often lost the ball in silly areas when he was needed in the centre of the field. Looked like he struggled to keep up with pace of the game and would have probably been substituted if more experience was on the bench. 

Patrick Dorgu - 6

Was more effective on his natural left side today as it allowed him to put crosses into dangerous areas. Constantly overlapped Garnacho and should have been played through more often. He did get booked and made a couple of defensive errors but showed some promising moments that United fans should be happy about.

 

Joshua Zirkzee - 7

United's best player and showed some real quality in moments throughout the game. Had flair, linked up with his team mates well and played a couple of excellent through balls for his team to run on to. Had a chance to level the game with a header that he should have been put away but other than that was the standout man for United today. 

Alejandro Garnacho - 6

Tested the goalkeeper on multiple occasions and was direct with the ball at his feet. However, he missed the biggest chance of the game for United that should have been a guaranteed goal but instead rushed his chance and put the ball in row Z. 

Rasmus Hojlund - 5

Started the game positively and created a couple of good chances testing the goalkeeper early on. He regressed and became less involved as the game went on and was caught offside whenever he looked like going through on goal. Another game without a goal for the Danish international.