Analysis: Manchester United not hunting bargains in the January sales

Since the inception of the transfer windows in 2003, any club dipping their toe in the water to splash some cash in January are doing so with some trepidation. There are generally no bargains to be had in the world of football after Christmas. Manchester United seemed to realise this rather quickly, and rarely delve into the coffers to make a purchase in January. When they have done, it is largely to try and capture a bargain, some cover or a player with potential. There are some exceptions.

Buy when you don't need to

Two of United's greatest ever servants were Patrice Evra and Nemanja Vidic, and they both came in January 2006. They served United with enormous distinction, both spending eight trophy-laden years at the club. The reason they were a success is simple. They were bought when United were in a position of strength. United did not need either player. Gabriel Heinze was established as the left-back, and United had Rio Ferdinand, John O'Shea, Wes Brown and the emerging Jonny Evans in the central defensive positions. They could have survived without Evra or Vidic. Sir Alex Ferguson wanted them, and a deal was struck for reasonable money so it made sense.

That sort of thinking doesn't just apply to the January window, but of course if a club is actively looking to buy in January, then it means one thing - they are likely to make a panic buy.

Louis Saha was another January signing bought from a position of strength, and he came for a hefty fee. Had he not spent more time on the treatment table than the pitch, he could have also been considered a success. He was one of the main reasons that Ruud van Nistelrooy exited the club, but ultimately his injuries prevented him becoming a legend as his ability was outstanding.

Jury still out on Mata

The most high-profile January signing, and at the time United's record purchase, was of course Juan Mata. As talented as he is, and he clearly is, even now two years on the jury would have to be out as to whether he is a success to date. His fantastic double at Anfield last year will forever endear him in United fans' hearts, but he is a puzzle that Louis van Gaal in particular is finding hard to solve. For such a fee a team should be built around him, but that has never been United's way and his purchaser, David Moyes, didn't buy him to be the fulcrum of the team. He was simply desperate for an injection of quality, at any cost, and the result was a panic buy. The summer transfer window had been a disaster, so needs must.

If United were desperate under Moyes, then two years later they are equally needy if not more so. Leading up to December, the football was tedious to say the least, but the results were coming and being in a great position in the league and still in all competitions, everything seemed fine. Not brilliant, but certainly looking like it had the makings of a successful season. The demise in the last two months has been staggering, and if ever United needed new recruits, an injection of new blood, then it would appear to be now. So why, as the closure of the window fast approaches, does it appear that nobody will be coming to United?

Harder for United to secure talent

Maybe nobody wants to come. That may seem amusing, why would anyone turn down United? Ask Aaron Ramsey, or Gareth Bale or John Stones. In fairness, the current situation didn't deter any of those, as it was Ferguson that tried to sign all three - though since he left Ed Woodward has made it his mission to secure Bale, repeatedly and unsuccessfully. Maybe Woodward has seen the impact, or lack of impact, that Mata has had and decided that sort of business would not be repeated in the shortest transfer window. He may want to make a marquee signing, but may have seen sense that January is not the time to do it.

Let's face it even if he wanted to, the Champions League is still going on and anybody involved in that competition are hardly going to make a switch unless it is clear they are unwanted by their current employers - as was the case with Mata. So it means that United would once again have to take the best of the rest. Someone like Alexandre Pato for instance. No, he has just turned up at Chelsea for a fee that is believed to be in the region of £7million. He had a fall from grace but has re-invented himself back in his native South America. Five years ago £7million wouldn't have bought his big toe, but Chelsea are prepared to take a low-risk gamble and at that price, it seems fair.

If United do not want to take a risk on a high-wage earner, then they could try and take untapped potential. Even that seems beyond them. Moussa Dembele, the Fulham striker, is 19 and doing rather well in the Championship. Tottenham Hotspur have been linked with a move for him, but it appears even they may miss out to Monaco who are offering more money. United don't have to be interested, and maybe never were. However, if Spurs are then United should be.

Spurs, remember, took a chance on Dele Alli. This is a kid who destroyed United under van Gaal's nose whilst at MK Dons, and now looks a world beater. Maybe United didn't fancy him either. Spurs not only fancied him, but they were brave enough to play him, not just stick him in the reserves. Unlike Manchester City, who bought Patrick Roberts, the ex-teammate of Dembele at Fulham in the summer. They threw a cool £8million at this kid, and he now plies his trade for their U-21's. Perhaps he wasn't good enough for United.

Perhaps it is because United have an abundence of youth coming through that is making them reluctant to go for even young kids with potential. Maybe they do. Cameron Borthwick-Jackson has looked a decent prospect, and there are several kids with reputations coming through the ranks. Some of those youngsters were involved in the 5-1 home defeat to Chelsea in the FA Youth Cup last Friday. Still, it's a process. So long as these kids believe in and are moulded by the clubs philosophy, they and United will be fine.

There are probably several reasons why United haven't bought and the one outlined to begin with seems the most sensible. There is no value in the January transfer window and to buy reeks of desperation and generally hikes up prices. Let's assume this is the pragmatic and prudent approach that United's management have taken.

Then again, you could assume that Ed is also probably reluctant to hand a transfer kitty to someone who won't be around much longer, and that would be the most damning and damaging aspect of all if true. They won't buy due to a lack of value, or they won't give money to a manager who will never reap the benefits as he is on borrowed time? January is a crazy period, but where United are concerned the craziness looks like it will continue long after the window shuts.