Grading each Bundesliga team's season
Getty Images/Mika Volkmann/

Wow, wow, wow. What a season of Bundesliga action!

We’ve seen thrills, spills, and the first invincible season in the Bundesliga’s history.

I did a half-season review back in December just after the winter break, in which I gave every team a grade from A* to F based on how their season had been so far.

Because I’m a sucker for continuity, I’m going full circle and giving my grades for each Bundesliga team’s season.

I’ll be going from first place down to last place, grading from A* to F, and basing my rankings solely on league form, so there’s no need to get your pitchforks out when you see the grade I’ve given Dortmund.

1st Bayer Leverkusen: A*

Do I need to explain this? Not really, but my editor won’t be happy if I don’t.

In Xabi Alonso’s first full season in senior management, he not only won Leverkusen’s first-ever Bundesliga title but did so without losing a single game, whilst also ending Bayern Munich’s 11 grip on the Meisterschale.

They played some unbelievable football along the way and scored a ridiculous amount of last-minute goals on their way to becoming the Bundesliga’s first invincible champions. One of the best seasons we’ll ever see.

2nd Stuttgart: A*

What Sebastian Hoeneβ has done at Stuttgart is simply staggering.

In just the space of a year, he's taken Stuttgart from the relegation play-off to the Champions League. If someone says they saw this coming they’re either lying or you need to ask for next week’s lottery numbers.

He’s also transformed players like Serhou Guirassy, Chris Führich, and Deniz Undav into some of the league’s best players. 

Without a huge budget and with some good old-fashioned management, Hoeneβ has pulled Stuttgart from the depths and given them their highest finish since their title win in 06/07. A stunning season.

3rd Bayern Munich: C

Let me get this out there now: Bayern haven’t been as bad as people have made out.

They actually ended this season with one more point than they did last season when they won the league, and they lost the title to an incredible Leverkusen side which will be remembered for generations.

There were shining lights in their season though. The record champions finished as the Bundesliga's top scorers, and 100 million Euro man Harry Kane finished the season with 36 goals as well as the European Golden Shoe.

But nowadays anything other than the title is considered a failure for Bayern. I think a C is a fair grade.

4th RB Leipzig: B

Another season, another top-four finish for RB Leipzig. They were ransacked of their best players as usual before the start of the season, with Christopher Nkunku, Joško Gvardiol and Dominik Szoboszlai all moving on.

But Marco Rose’s side regrouped and reassembled another brilliant side. New signings Benjamin Sesko, Lois Openda, and Xavi Simons all proved instrumental in helping Die Roten Bullen (the Red Bulls) qualify for the Champions League for the sixth season on the trot.

5th Borussia Dortmund: D

Just remember this list is solely based on league form alone. Dortmund have been outstanding in Europe this season, but in the league, not so much.

They’ve gone from almost winning the league last season, to fifth place. Fifth may not sound that bad given they’ve qualified for the Champions League anyway, but it’s their worst finish in nine seasons.

6th Eintracht Frankfurt: C

Decent. That’s what I said back in my half season review and my opinion hasn’t changed. Frankfurt have done a great job of shaking off the mid-table mediocrity that has plagued them in the past.

With their sixth-place finish this campaign, they’ve kept their impressive record of qualifying for Europe in five of the last seven seasons.

A winless final four drew the chasing pack slightly too close for comfort, but a good season beforehand, which included a 5-1 trouncing of Bayern Munich, saw Die Adler (The eagles) through and into the Europa League again.

7th Hoffenheim: B

After narrowly avoiding the relegation play-off last season by just three points, Hoffenheim have bounced back brilliantly.

In Pellegrino Matarazzo’s first full season at the club, Hoffenheim secured European football for the first time in four seasons, and got veteran forward Andrej Kramarić and young prospect Maximilian Beier firing in perfect tandem, with the pair scoring 31 league goals between them.

But at the other end, only three more teams have conceded more goals than Hoffenheim. So if Matarazzo can secure his team’s backline we could see Hoffenheim do some big things next season.

8th Heidenheim: A*

Nearly everyone, including myself, expected Heidenheim to struggle in their first-ever season in the Bundesliga.

But Frank Schmidt’s men have stunned us all this season!

The loyal coach, who’s been with the club from the start of their amazing run, assembled a fantastic squad. Promotion stars such as Tim Kleindienst, and Jan-Niklas Beste combined with new faces such as Eren Dinkçi created a team whose sum was significantly greater than its parts.

And thanks to their amazing efforts, and Leverkusen’s Pokal win, Heidenheim, a side that was in the fourth tier just 15 years ago, will play in the Europa Conference League next season. What a story!

9th Werder Bremen: B

If a Bremen fan from 20 years ago saw I’d just given their side a ‘B’ for finishing ninth, below Heidenheim, they’d be baffled.

But given the up-and-down nature of the last five years, I think Bremen fans will be pleased with their finish this season, and they should be!

Despite losing talisman Niclas Fϋllkrug to Borussia Dortmund in the summer, Bremen actually got better, with them missing out on a 14-year awaited return to Europe by just one goal difference.

10th Freiburg: D

With Christian Streich’s men qualifying for the Europa League the last two seasons, this season left something to be desired.

Despite them taking the European fight to the final day, it just wasn’t to be for Streich on his farewell tour. His side went winless in the final five and handed the European spot that was all but theirs to Bundesliga newcomers Heidenheim.

With Christian Streich’s now departing after 13 years in charge, I can see Freiburg struggling next season.

11th Augsburg: C

A brilliant season spent mostly in and around the European spots was spectacularly thrown away at the end by the Bavarians.

With just five matches left to go, Augsburg were in the driving seat for seventh place. But five straight losses in the final run-in blew their chances of Europe, and gave them their ninth consecutive finish below 10th place.

12th Wolfsburg: D

I was certain Wolfsburg would be challenging for Europe this season, but no, not even slightly.

An average, but salvageable start to the season quickly turned sour after Die Wölfe (the Wolves) went 11 games without a win and were  teetering on the edge of the relegation scrap. 

In mid-March Wolfsburg swapped Niko Kovac with former RB Leipzig and Southampton boss Ralph Hassenhuntl. A subsequent good run of form pulled them away from being dragged down, extending their 27-year stay in the Bundesliga.

13th Mainz: D

Mainz picked up just one win from their first 21 games and were nine points from safety. By all accounts they were doomed.

But Die Nullfϋnfer (the 05ers) would complete an astounding great escape.

After their 8-1 embarrassment from Bayern Munich on Matchday 25, Mainz went unbeaten in their final nine games, winning five, drawing four, and seeing themselves to a 13th-place finish – unimaginable just a couple of months prior.

14th Borussia Mönchengladbach: E

Borussia Mönchengladbach’s slow decline hasn’t been documented enough.

Throughout the 2010s, Gladbach were Champions League regulars. But the last three seasons have seen them struggle for consistency, with this being their lowest finish to a league season since 2011.

Before the season they let star player Marcus Thuram go to Inter Milan for free, Jonas Hoffman leave for pennies to Leverkusen and saw club legend Lars Stindl depart to Karlsruher.

They failed to properly replace them, and it showed. They won just seven league games, conceded the third most goals in the league, and finished just one point shy of the relegation play-off.

A worrying season for Die Fohlen (the Foals) and maybe a sign of things to come?

15th Union Berlin: E

It’s been a very topsy-turvy season for Union to say the least.

They played in the Champions League for the first time ever, lost eight games in a row, and saw their most successful manager ever leave.

Then key losses to Bochum and Kӧln and good results from Mainz saw Union slip into a final day relegation scrap, with a last-minute goal from Janik Haberer securing Union’s Bundesliga status for next season.

The departure of prolific strike duo Sheraldo Becker and Kevin Behrens in the summer made Die Eisernen (the Iron Ones) struggle for goals, with only relegated sides Darmstadt and Kӧln having scored less.

Just this week Union announced former Mainz boss Bo Svensson as their manager for next season, a great appointment in my opinion. It'll be interesting to see how Union will fare in their sixth season as Bundesliga club.

16th Bochum: D

Firstly, what an incredible comeback in the Relegationspiele from Bochum! 3-0 down going into the second leg, away from home against Fortuna Dϋsseldorf, and going on to win on penalties. Incredible.

But, their amazing turnaround in the play-off doesn’t hide the fact their poor season saw them end up there in the first place.

They had the second leakiest defence in the league, conceding 74 goals, and would’ve been in serious trouble if not for midfield maestro Kevin Stӧger’s 17 goal contributions.

17th Kӧln: E

The two-window transfer embargo given to them before the start of the season put the writing on the wall for Kӧln.

But every shred of credit has to be given to  Die Geißböcke (The Billy Goats). They never gave up and fought to the bitter end, with them somehow managing to give themselves a slim chance of survival on the final day.

But alas, it wasn’t meant to be, and the two-time champions will return to the 2.Bundesliga after a five-year stint in the top flight.

18th Darmstadt: F

F means fail and that is exactly what Darmstadt did.

Selling their top scorer from their promotion season, Phillip Tietz, to Augsburg before a ball was even kicked wasn't exactly the most promising start.

They conceded the most goals, won just three games all season, and finished a whopping 16 points from safety. 

Many, including myself, expected them to go straight back down, but I also expected they’d have at least put up more of a fight. Shocking season from Darmstadt.

And that’s it! All 18 Bundesliga teams’ seasons reviewed.

What will happen next season? Will Leverkusen replicate this season's heroics? How will newly promoted northern duo Holstein Kiel and St. Pauli do? Will Bayern find their way back to the top of the pile?

We'll just have to wait and see what our beloved Bundesliga has in store for us...