
Paul Mitchell has completed his move to Newcastle United replacing Dan Ashworth as sporting director.
Ashworth completed his much-desired move to Manchester United last week, as the Reds continued revamping backroom staff following the arrival of INEOS, led by Sir Jim Radcliffe.
Ashworth has been credited with much of the success that Newcastle has achieved since he arrived from Brighton in May 2022, but Mitchell will be tasked with returning the Magpies into continental football, as well as progressing the club off the pitch.
Mitchell has performed a similar role before, having been the sporting director at AS Monaco for over three years, before leaving the south coast of France in October 2023.
This article will be looking at the success of his past, before looking ahead towards the future, and what Mitchell will bring to the table at Newcastle.
-
Background
Mitchell was born just east of Manchester, in Stalybridge, and was part of the Manchester City youth set-up before joining Wigan Athletic on a permanent deal in 1999.
After spending five years at the Latics, Mitchell joined MK Dons but only managed 59 league appearances in four seasons, before being sent out on loan to Wrexham and then Barnet before retiring due to injury concerns in January 2009.
-
Career off the pitch
Shortly after retiring, he was appointed first team head of recruitment at MK Dons before moving to Southampton in 2012, taking up the head of recruitment role.
During his time on the south coast, he oversaw promotion from the Championship in the 2012-13 season, before working closely with newly appointed Mauricio Pochettino.
Mitchell was been accredited with the signings of ex-Liverpool star Sadio Mané and Toby Alderweireld as Southampton prospered back in the Premier League, finishing in the top half for four consecutive seasons between 2013 and 2017, including a record sixth-place finish in the 2015-2016 season.
Mitchell and Pochettino had a close relationship, as the former joined the manager in joining Tottenham in November 2014.
At the Lilywhites he again took the head of recruitment role and was responsible for signing now-captain Heung-Min Son from Bayer Leverkusen for a mere €22 million.
Furthermore, young prospect Dele Alli was suggested by Mitchell, who moved to Tottenham for an initial £5 million. However, after only two years, "his dream job had turned into a nightmare" and after a fallout with chairman Daniel Levy, he was placed on a 16-month notice period.
Mitchell looked abroad for his next job and was recruited as head of recruitment and development for Bundesliga club RB Leipzig in February 2018.
He was responsible for signing both Nordi Mukiele and Christopher Nkunku, the latter for a lowly €11 million. It was during his time in East Germany that Manchester United were reportedly interested in appointing him as sporting director, but decided against it.
The 42-year-old's final job before arriving on Tyneside was in Monaco, where he kick-started a complete rebuild of the club, starting with appointing former Bayern Munich manager Niko Kovač.
The playing squad was cut, with the number of professional contracts dropping from 77 to 39 over his time at the club.
The academy was massively utilised, with the number of minutes played by academy players at the Monégasque club rising significantly, from 1421. In the 2019-20 season, the season before Mitchell's arrival, to 3654, in his first year at the club.
Mitchell left the club in October 2023, as he felt he had "completed [his] mission" in Monaco, having helped oversee the club into a sixth-place finish in the 2022-2023 Ligue 1 season.
-
So What Should Newcastle Fans Expect?
Once described by former teammate, Aaron Wilbraham, as a "workaholic", Mitchell will be expected to be more ruthless than Ashworth was, meaning that fringe players may be sold, such as Martin Dubravka and Emil Krafth, among others who may be on the receiving end of a squad overall.
The Magpies need to finish in a European place next year, but the current squad doesn't allow for this. Limited squad depth, as evidenced this year, especially in the winter months where benches were often filled with three goalkeepers or almost exclusively academy players.
On the subject of the academy, Newcastle are not as blessed as Monaco was, when it comes to academy strength.
Talented youngsters who made their first XI debuts last year, such as Amadou Diallo and Michael Ndiweni have been released, and despite the arrivals of hot prospects, such as Irishman Cathal Heffernan and Alfie Harrison, who signed in January from Manchester City for a fee believed to be around the €1 million mark.
Both Harrison and Heffernan, alongside star academy player Alex Murphy, are likely to be given chances in and around the first XI this year, as this is seen as a more useful way for youngsters to gain first-team experience, as loans are decreasing in popularity, due to rough treatment by some lower-division clubs towards loanees.
Eddie Howe and Mitchell will hope that the phased introduction of some of these youngsters will have a similar effect on Lewis Miley this season, who impressed last season after being given the opportunity by Howe, as injuries plagued the midfield.
Alongside youth players from the academy likely to be given a chance, Mitchell's recruitment policy is relatively similar to Ashworth's.
At Monaco, he was data-informed, rather than data-led, so the scouting team are likely to find a certain style of player, which Howe, is in favour of, and will use data to find similar players.
The majority of the players brought in will be young, mostly under 25, whilst some older players will be kept in the squad to ensure leadership is still evident both on and off the pitch.
At Monaco, Mitchell appointed Kovač as he wants his club to play an attractive, high-octane style of play. Newcastle certainly plays that style of football and will continue to do so. Newcastle games produced the most Expected Goals (xG) of any team in the Premier League last season, scoring 85 goals along the way.
-
Overall Thoughts
Paul Mitchell is almost the perfect appointment for Newcastle. While Dan Ashworth is a huge miss, Mitchell has a very similar style off the pitch, especially with transfers, and with the academy.
Mitchell is likely to oversee a revamp of the current squad, with young players coming into both the academy and the senior team. Fringe players are likely to leave and replaced by younger players with high potential.
If Europe is not achieved this season, then it is likely that Howe won't be manager next season, but Mitchell will ensure the aggressive, fluid style of football will be transferred over to the new manager, as that is a key trait of the post-takeover Newcastle team.
That will not want to be lost on the supporters, who constantly fill grounds, both home and away, in the hope that they see expansive and exciting football.

