Borussia Dortmund 1-0 Paris Saint-Germain: Post-Match Player Ratings
Jadon Sancho (centre) of Borussia Dortmund is tracked by Lucas Hernández (left), Marquinhos (right) and Nuno Mendes (centre-left) of Paris Saint-Germain during Dortmund's 1-0 Champions League semi-final first-leg win at Signal Iduna Park, Dortmund, on Wednesday 1st May 2024 (Photo: Rico Brouwer/Soccrates/Getty Images)

Niclas Füllkrug’s superb 36th-minute effort ensured Edin Terzić‘s team will take a 1-0 aggregate lead into next Tuesday’s second leg at the Parc des Princes.

An engaging spectacle at a raucous Signal Iduna Park could so easily have produced more than just the one goal.

Kylian Mbappé and Achraf Hakimi struck a post for Luis Enrique’s side within seconds of each other early in the second half, while Füllkrug, Marcel Sabitzer and Julian Brandt could all so easily have extended the hosts’ lead.

It may well be that the fifth-placed Bundesliga side – who continue to hit impressive heights in Europe, having topped Group F ahead of PSG earlier this season – come to regret not securing a healthier advantage ahead of the Paris return match.

There was, though, more than enough promise within this display to suggest they will pose a considerable threat in the French capital.

Manchester United loanee Jadon Sancho – who continues to look reinvigorated back at the club where he caught so many eyes between 2017 and 2021 – put in a spellbinding display, while Karim Adeyemi and Füllkrug also played a big part in a consistently menacing attack.

Both teams have reason to be optimistic about their chances of facing either Bayern Munich or Real Madrid, who are tied at 2-2 on aggregate in the other last-four tie after Tuesday's Allianz Arena first leg, in the Champions League final at Wembley on 1st June. 

  • Borussia Dortmund

Gregor Kobel – 8/10

Made a potentially crucial 72nd-minute save from Ousmane Dembélé after Mbappé’s clever through-ball.

Smartly gathered Bradley Barcola and Mbappé efforts early in the second half after having exceedingly little to do in the first.

Could only watch as the ball hit the inside of both of his posts within seconds following 51st-minute Mbappé and Hakimi attempts.

Julian Ryerson – 7/10

Assured. Made an important clearance from a dangerous Dembélé cross late in the first half and marshalled Bradley Barcola well.

Mats Hummels – 7/10

The 35-year-old’s experience often made up for his reduced dynamism.

Commanding at the heart of the hosts’ defence and caught the eye with a thunderous but fair challenge on Mbappé to sustain a spell of Dortmund pressure in the second half.

Nico Schlotterbeck – 8/10

Superbly flighted pass in behind set up Füllkrug’s opener, moments after his expertly timed tackle halted a dangerous Hakimi run in the Dortmund box.

Strong, composed and cultured.

Ian Maatsen – 7/10

The Chelsea loanee was booked inside the opening 20 minutes for a mistimed challenge on Warren Zaïre-Emery. Dynamic and technically proficient in most of his work aside from that.

Marcel Sabitzer – 8/10

A persistent threat and energetic presence in midfield.

Forced Gianluigi Donnarumma into a good early stop, after his well-timed run into the box was nicely found. His volley shortly prior to the break was also well kept out by the Italy goalkeeper.

Emre Can – 8/10

A commanding display from the Dortmund captain at the base of the midfield. Protected the back-four effectively and used the ball neatly and incisively when he got it. 

Jadon Sancho – 9/10

A joy to watch. An effervescent, fleet-footed and creative performance from the 24-year-old Englishman.

Could so easily have registered two assists after his cross was volleyed over by Füllkrug and his sublime through-ball led to Brandt having an effort superbly blocked by Marquinhos.

That he attempted 18 dribbles, completing 13, reflects just how prominent he was. After all his struggles at Old Trafford, how pleasing it is to see him lighting up such a stage.

Returning to Germany this summer as part of England’s Euro 2024 squad still feels a long shot, given his last cap came in October 2021 and the Three Lions’ depth of talent, but displays of this ilk at this level won’t do his chances any harm. 

Julian Brandt – 7/10

Nicely weighted pass set up Sabitzer’s early chance. Ought to have done better when Marquinhos blocked his 84th-minute effort following that brilliant Sancho pass.

Karim Adeyemi – 8/10

Productively used his speed defensively and offensively down the Dortmund left. Understandably tired prior to his late substitution.

Niclas Füllkrug – 8/10

An excellent striker’s performance. The 31-year-old took his goal brilliantly – taking Schlotterbeck’s pass wonderfully in his stride before sending a powerful low finish past Donnarumma.

Should have doubled his and Dortmund’s tally when he volleyed Sancho’s cross over just before the hour mark.

Linked the play with intelligence and deftness.

Substitutes

Marco Reus – 5/10

Headed a Sancho cross over which would likely have been better left for Füllkrug.

Marius Wolf – N/A

Felix Nmecha – N/A

Youssoufa Moukoko – N/A

  • Paris Saint-Germain

Gianluigi Donnarumma – 6/10

Made sharp saves from Sabitzer at either end of the first half but will likely be disappointed to have been beaten at his near-post by Füllkrug’s admittedly well-struck opener.

Achraf Hakimi – 6/10

Unusually outmanoeuvred. Struggled in both directions against Dortmund’s nimble left-sided duo of Maatsen and Adeyemi, particularly in the opening 45 minutes.

Unfortunate to hit the inside of the post early in the second half and later set up Dembélé, who failed to hit the target.

Marquinhos – 7/10

The visitors' skipper made a superb last-ditch block from Brandt and set up one of PSG’s best chances of the night with an excellent early cross that Fabián Ruiz headed wide in the 56th minute.

Inadvertently played Füllkrug onside for the goal.

Lucas Hernández – 4/10

Made way in the 42nd minute after seemingly sustaining a knock while attempting to block Füllkrug’s opener.

An unfortunate way for the 28-year-old’s night to end, although his failure to drop earlier left him with unnecessary ground to make up on the German striker.

Nuno Mendes – 4/10

A tough night for the young Portugal left-back.

Was caused numerous problems by the electric Sancho and had a couple of lucky escapes when he was dispossessed by the Englishman in the first half, leading to Sabitzer’s early chance, before his push on Füllkrug after the break could easily have conceded a penalty.

Warren Zaïre-Emery – 5/10

A largely quiet evening for the 18-year-old midfielder, which felt one of several markers of the hosts’ effectiveness. Sent a late header comfortably over

Vitinha – 6/10

Another whose influence was limited. Still an energetic presence who saw plenty of the ball, completing 79 of 82 attempted passes (96%), more than any other player on the night.

Fabián Ruiz – 5/10

Ought to have at least hit the target with that chance early in the second half. Like fellow midfielders Zaïre-Emery and Vitinha, his level of impact was low.

Ousmane Dembélé – 6/10

Lively and positive but insufficiently ruthless. Was denied well from close range by Kobel’s second-half save. Missed the target with a couple of early efforts from range and when well found by Hakimi late on.

Kylian Mbappé – 6/10

Subdued prior to the interval but immensely unlucky not to equalise with a curled 51st-minute effort that struck the inside of the post.

Found the gloves of Kobel with a later attempt and the home goalkeeper then made his best stop of the night from Dembélé, who was played in by Mbappé’s intelligently scooped pass.

Bradley Barcola – 5/10

A quiet evening for the young French winger. He saw a dangerous low cross well cleared by Maatsen in the first half and an attempt from range gathered by Kobel 

Substitutes

Lucas Beraldo – 6/10

Rarely easy to come into a game at centre-back, particularly one of this magnitude. The 20-year-old Brazilian settled into the match smoothly after taking Hernández’s place and played his part in ensuring no further goals were conceded.

Randal Kolo Muani – 5/10

Didn’t make a notable mark on the game after his 62nd-minute introduction. That, arguably, was as much a reflection of Dortmund’s sterling defensive efforts as anything else.